Garfield’s Restaurant & Pub

This place has been one of my favorite places to go since I was little. Unfortunately the past few times I’ve ate here, the service and food have been far from the best. Last night the cook walked out during dinner rush. The bartender had to step in and cook until they could find another cook to come in. I waited 45 minutes for my chicken mac & cheese. The manager on the floor was my waitress so she was occupied and there was no kitchen manager to run the kitchen. It was a hot mess. They took $ 2.50 off of my meal for the wait and the waitress/​manager was very kind and felt bad for the issues. But the food was well done and not worth the money spent. The chicken was tough and noodles were rubber. I don’t want to see the place close, so please get it together. I probably won’t be back for awhile, but I hope it turns around.

We have been eating here for years, when we could afford it. It is rather expensive for a meal here. They do offer pretty generous portions, though and I like fish or shrimp and steak, ribs. I also liked their fried mushrooms until they decided to change them to slices instead of whole mushrooms (BOO!). We eat here once in a while now since we tried JR’s and like them better for steaks and mushrooms at a better price.

I ordered the Chicken Quesadilla Salad which was supposed to come with: cheese quesadilla, grilled chicken, guacamole, fiesta corn, green onion, tomato, cilantro, cheese and tortilla chips. I quickly realized that the guacamole and chips were missing and the waitress brought them out. A bit later I realized that the green onion, cilantro and cheese were also missing. The kitchen staff clearly doesn’t know the menu. I would not bother eating there again.

We don’t go here very often but when we do I am usually pleasantly surprised. They have pretty good sandwiches.

I like going here every once in a while. It’s a tad bit more on the expensive side but I’d say it’s worth it to stop for a meal every few weeks. I’ve had a lot of different things here. I’ve had BBQ wings, burgers, salads, steaks, and everything was pretty good. It’s also a ritual for my friends and I to share an Oreo milkshake. The servers have always been super friendly to us and it’s really fun to be in the bar area during games.
Menu selection /​variety — ⁴⁄₅
Staff friendliness /​helpfulness — ⁵⁄₅
Food quality /​taste — 4.5÷5
Price /​«bang for buck» — ³⁄₅
Atmosphere — ⁵⁄₅