Randy’s Up the River

This is a very cute bar.
Service: my mother, sister and I were there about 4pm. One waitress at the time for all the tables ans she kept up very well. Was great with questions and suggestions.
Food: If you are looking for a greasy tasty meal then this place is perfect. Their wings are crispy and nicely sized. The mini corndogs are a nice fair food starter. I had the ridiculous Gorilla burger. That was a huge pile of crazy deliciousness. A juicy burger between two grilled cheese sandwiches. I felt so ashamed yet extremely thrilled after I finished it.
Atmosphere: Its decorated fairly adorable for a riverside bar. And yes its got a rougher crowd at night. But its definitely worth checking out. Especially when you just want straight to the point tasty bar food.
I was hapoy we came here and i will be back. If not just for the jalepeno cheese stuffed pretzel.

Great atmosphere and food. All the locals go there. Give them a try and have a burger or fish fry

I went here on the night before Thanksgiving. I ordered the grilled chicken breast and a Busch. It was delicious, the service was amazing. I will definitely be back when I’m in town again.

I’ve been here twice now when visiting my fiancés former college town and the wings are definitely the way to go. Crispy (you can request them extra crispy if you really like a nice crunch) and a good variety of tasty sauces. Everything else on the menu is just your run of the mill bar foods. Great prices. Has a log cabin feel, definitely a cozy place to enjoy a beer on a snowy day during a football game!

The best place around for a fish fry! They have very friendly staff. The food is always amazing! The price is very reasonable! My favorite is the beer battered fish fry!

This place is great! The menu is huge, and I’ve had everything from the salads to the burgers and have never been disappointed. There’s an outdoor patio for the summer and a big, beautiful fireplace inside in the winter. This is a perfect place to grab some drinks on a Friday night or bring my family when we’re all in town. I highly recommend checking it out if you haven’t done so already.

We really enjoyed the wings! They were done to perfection! Better than average bar food. Very friendly wait staff.

Randy’s has the best wings on the planet, hands down. The 24K are unmatched. Can’t wait to get back to Allegany for a Bonnies game and a couple dozen wings.
«Fast food isn’t good and good food isn’t fast»

Holy crap! The Gorilla was awesome! I also saw a Pittsburgh Salad… tossed salad with French Fries… another future option (when I’m dieting). Should I come to Olean area again, this will be the «go to» place.

Fish fry is great, wings great, sandwiches great!!! Service very good as well! Always friendly, fast, hot and large portions. Decent prices also!

Randy’s wings = 5 stars

Randy’s was recommended to me by a friend as a good place to go for a fish fry. It was good, but not great. The sides were brought out ahead of the fish; far enough ahead so that they were long gone by the time the fish arrived. The fish was good-​sized and had a pretty decent beer batter.
The price was really reasonable; at first we thought they had forgotten to charge us for one of our dinners. The dining room and bar are dark, cozy and very casual. I will definitely be back some time for their wings, even though it’s a little bit of a trek from my hometown.
We were there for the food, but it seems like a pretty cool bar to hang out at. There was a really eclectic group of people; everyone from college students to bikers, the night that we were there. If I still lived in the area, it would definitely be one of my regular watering holes.

For wings alone, this place gets a 5 star rating. The service and prices aren’t bad either, but if you’re a wingnut, this is the place to be in the Southern Tier.