My Tomato Pie

We have always loved My Tomato Pie, and while the décor will take some time to get used to, the food is still the same delicious Italian-​American fare we have known and loved throughout the years.

Same delicious menu, new location!
The interior of the new place is really nice. Styled along the lines of The Cheesecake Factory. Classy! I’m so glad that the food is still the same. The personal pizza I had was just as good as the pizza at the old location!
Don’t be turned off by having to drive to a different place to enjoy the amazing eats at MTP. It’s a much nicer space! Plus Kohl’s, Wegman’s, Tops is all right next door, so you can shop after you eat!

My Tomato Pie is a staple of my life. Whether you’re craving pizza, Italian, or just want to have a few drinks, definitely stop in and enjoy what my tomato pie has to offer. They also have a banquet room for groups.

Great food and staff. The luca is my favorite. Family friendly with full bar. The new location is great. stop in for a beer or two.

We came here on a busy Friday, so I’ll cut them some slack and add a star, but our visit left a lot to be desired. First the person taking names at the desk was incredibly rude and ignored my family and the lady in front of us for a solid 5 minutes while we awkwardly stood there. Someone walked in that the hostess knew behind us and she greeted them and let them know the wait, at which point the people in front of us had enough and decided to leave. Af this point the hostess took our name and we were seated on time but in the time we were waiting we saw two instances where tables were skipped, once because they were at the bar but I’m not sure on the other one. When we were seated we ordered the spinach bread which when it came out was just a sub roll with spinach and cheese on it, not quite what I was expecting and it was cold when we got it (there was some confusion about whose table it was going to). Luckily our pizza came out nice and hot, what it lacked in seasoning it made up with an abundance of cheese. The wings were also hot and crispy, probably the one thing saving this review. I’m gonna give them some time to work out their kinks and I’ll be back at least 1 more time as I don’t like writing local businesses off on one visit.

New location for one of my favorite restaurants. Had a chicken Florentine focaccia sandwich which was wonderful. The pasta salad as my side was dry and tasteless. The service was a little slow, but the waitress was very busy as was the restaurant. Still, my waitress was knowledgeable, helpful and did bring us refills on water. Over all good experience.

I have never been to a my tomato pie before and they just opened up there new location near my house so i took my son there for lunch to try it out and Im very glad I did!
Food was quick and delicious. Service was great and the atmosphere was terrific! Ill be sure to bring the rest of my family here.
I wrote the same review on the other one but i was referring to this location.

The brand new location for My Tomato Pie has finally opened. They have shifted down the Blvd and brought with them the same family atmosphere and good food that you have come to expect.
They have relocated to a newly renovated space that was the former location of Buffalo Wild Wings in the Tops Plaza on Niagara Falls Blvd and E. Robinson. The front of the new location looks quiet, lacking the open windows and neon signs of the previous location. The entry way is large and opens onto the front counter, waiting area, and restrooms. The staff was quick to greet and willing to accommodate our seating requests. While we waited for our table to be cleared, I looked around…
To the right of the waiting area is a very large banquet room, much more modern and brighter than the one at the old location. It’s windows are blocked out by dark shades, and offer some privacy from the front parking lot. Behind this area is the dining room, complete with booths, tables, and half booth/​table seating. To the left are the kitchen doors, hiding away a brand new, state-​of-​the-​art, modern kitchen. In the back of the space, behind a mid-​level wall, is the new bar. The bar features a tap selection, liquor, and wine.
We were seated rather quickly. Our server came by right away to take our drink order. We put in our food order as well, and then sat back to enjoy the new decore. The ambiance is warm and inviting. The dark woods, fireplace, and mild lighting help to complete this feeling. Our table was comfortable and the dining are, although complete with high ceilings, did not produce any annoying echoes.
Our food was served about 25 minutes after ordering. Everything was great. Portions were large (especially the amount of chicken that topped one salad). Our server came back multiple times to check on us and to keep our drinks refilled. While we ate we were greeted by the owners, who asked us not only how we were doing but also how our meal was, and then stayed to discuss the new location. This small town attitude is something I always missed when I was living out in CA. It feels great to be invited into someone’s home when you are at their place of business. The owners of The Pie always go out of their way to make their customers feel welcome.
The experience was really great and I found the new location built positively upon the old. I can’t wait to go back and have some more of that amazing tomato basil soup!