Olde Town Pizza House

Olde Town Pizza House has a lot of competitors that do a lot better and don’t come with an attitude! The pizza has good flavor, but the toppings have become less and less. The «thin» crust is not the typical thin crust either. I’ve never known a thin crust pizza to have a thick outer crust. For the price, competitors offer an overall better pizza. The pizza always seems to come with an attitude too! The past two times we’ve placed a to go order, we’ve received an attitude when asking for the order to be repeated back to ensure the toppings are correct. The young mans response was a big sigh and then he said you ordered a large and a mini with plus some items and minus some items. WOW! I had to take a deep breath and just chuckle to keep from saying what was really on my mind because it wasn’t a nice thought. Most places repeat your order back as an act of professionalism and also quality control to avoid an unhappy customer who receives an incorrect order. When the order wasn’t repeated and I made what I thought was a simple request, you would have thought I was asking the guy for something that he was unable to do. Just as anticipated, one of the pizzas came without pineapple as requested! We lived without it, but it certainly would have been nice to receive what we ask for and also paid for. The young man needs an attitude adjustment! Unilocal has a lot of followers and this is a sure way to have a voice and attitude that will certainly speak louder than your rude employees! Needless to say, when we arrived to pick up our order the older gentleman couldn’t have been nicer and knew for certain how to treat your customers. I would suggest having him answer your phones.
*FIRST CLASS PIZZA: LORENZO’S PIZZERIA, JIM’S PIZZA BOX & BRICK OVEN BISTRO*

Last minute stop in for take away on a Sunday evening. Awesome Hawaiian Pizza — thick crust and loaded with ham, sweet pineapple and different cheeses! Can’t wait to have the leftovers for breakfast! Would definitely go back on next visit!

My 4^th visit to Olde Town pizza. I was so disappointed… «where’s the beef»?! I added toppings at home! My pizza was so skimpy with toppings. I don’t mind paying any price for quality pizza or driving 25 mins, but consistency is KEY, as I’m sure this family run business will agree. The person who made my pizza could not possibly have any interest in your business. It was a sausage pizza, there were actually 3 slices that had NO sausage! I ordered extra sauce, didn’t happen. Please, Olde Town pizza, hire people that will uphold your high standards in serving quality food! To think I left a nice tip…
#unsatisfiedcustomer

I’ve been here twice, both times the food was absolutely delicious, the service was subpar. The wait staff were not very friendly or attentive, even though it was not crowded. The last experience I had here, our pizzas came out exceptionally late, which we would have overlooked had we not felt so rushed to leave! This place closes at 10 pm and our pizzas came out around 8:45. The staff was clearly trying to close by 9 and did not apologize for the lateness of our food but made us feel like we were being rude by staying (we left by 9:10). I hope the employees take this into account because the food, drinks, and atmosphere are great — just cheer up and be more accommodating!

I love Old Town! IT is SO GOOD. I will admit I haven’t had the pizza. But the salads are amazing. Also I had a gyro and it was delicious as well. The atmosphere is great. Food tastes fresh and good and classy. The best place in Amherst for absolute sure. Plus the service is great. Sometimes it takes a little time to get orders. but servers are friendly and overall I love this place!

This pizza was well made and people at our table loved it. It’s just not my taste in pizza. The sauce was too sweet and didn’t have enough flavor for my taste. The cheese also had the same problem. The crust was very underwhelming. Again, none of this is the fault of the kitchen, I just do not like the recipe. I’ve heard the salads here are great, so I’ll give that a try next time. The staff was friendly here as well.

First time here and we thoroughly enjoyed it from the service to the food! The margarita sauce is made to order and is DEVINE! I had this on my generous spaghetti dinner served with cold salad (pick your 3 toppings) and a giant breadstick! I can’t wait to eat my leftovers for lunch tomorrow! My husband had the Schobel fold over (spicy pepperoni, lean ham, bacon, ricotta, mozzarella and sauce)…he loved it! He also has leftovers to take home (6 slice pie) after his side salad too!
We will definitely be back!
I might add also that the website said they were open til 10 (Monday) and they actually closed at 9. We arrived a bit after 8. We finished slightly after 9 and noticed them doing their side work and clean up. My husband asked when they close and that’s when we found out the time was wrong. YET, they never rushed us nor made us feel as if we were in their way. Whereas, many other restaurants get downright rude and ignore you. So for that alone, we’d add another star! Thank you ladies who worked tonight (8÷10÷15)!

Always my go-​to when I’m back home in Amherst. From stombolis and Woogies to pizza and pasta it’s all good here. Family owned and operated, they always come out and greet the customers and add that extra bit of comfort to a great food experience. I had the fettuccine pasta with blush sauce and meatballs tonight. This came with a salad and a breadstick all for under $ 10 which is definitely a great deal compared to most Italian restaurants. They’ve recently added a small patio which was the icing on the cake with my meal tonight. Couldn’t recommend it enough to people stopping through town.

Been going here since I was a kid, a bit of a family stop for years. Food is always good, but I do agree with some people that the service could use some work. The servers as of late seem to not have the attentiveness that they used to. I also noticed some have been dressed more plain clothes than wearing the old town shirt and such, which at first made us confused if it was a server or a random person coming up to talk to us. Other than that, a lot of work was put in adding the new (ish) front end to the building and the interior looks great for it.
As for some people complaining that they get turned away at like 8:50…The dining room closes at 9. It is because they keep the place open an hour later for pick up. Says so right on the site, and they tell you that if you ask.

After going apple picking in the area, my boyfriend and I decided to come here for a late lunch not really knowing of many places in the area to get some good food. The service was decent, got our drinks and side salad appetizers relatively fast. Their side salads are delicious. You get to pick your toppings and dressing, and they proved to be quite filling. I would definitely recommend getting one to start. We decided to order a pizza after taking a while examining the large menu! It was hard to decide, lots of options. The wait for the pizza was about 35 minutes. Not too bad for a fresh pizza, but when you are hungry it was on the verge of taking too long. The pizza was good, but nothing to brag about. I would come back if I were in the area again, but I would probably try something different! Prices are good as well!

Dine in or carry out– I have never been dissappointed. Love their pizza– but the calzones are my favorite.

i think olde town is maybe 3.5 stars. they do make a mean calzone. it is just ok for a small town kind of place. the place is packed on friday and saturday nights, but i think there are only a few maybe one other sit down pizza place in the area, so by default this is where the ‘regulars’ crowd to for their ‘big night out!’ # justsayin
i do have to give them high regards to the famous woogie bear. i grew up on these as a child and although i have not had in a LONG time, i remember them being a crispy, cheesy yummy treat.
we typically order the family style calzone, sauce on the side. it is HUGE. always comes out of the oven super dee duper HOTTT!
if you are in the area, give them a try, but dont drive long distances to try the pie!
xo

I’ve come back many times since my last review and have never again had an issue. They are polite and always on spot with the order, and if not, immediately fix it. And seriously, best piece of pie in the county. Try the blackjack chicken fold over pizza, or the bacon mushroom cheeseburger pizza. Don’t forget their massive cheese sticks. Amaze balls.

The food is not bad, but not even close to good enough for the rude service! I used to love the pizza but the rudeness of the owners makes it worth going somewhere else.

It’s pretty good pizza, It was a 5 star back in the day when it was Danny Boys but still pretty good. I am a fan of the calzones. Some days are better then others

In all seriousness, this is probably one of the best pizzas that you can get in Lorain County. Yes, it’s that good. While it might take a bit of time to actually get your pie (it took us 30 minutes for a carry-​out order), it’s still a good quality. The crust is good, not too thick and not too thin, the source is flavorful (but not ‘tangy), and the toppings are well placed and bountiful.
If you’re not in the mood for pizza, their other menu options are pretty good as well — my wife gets a «Woogie Bear» which is amazing. The prices aren’t bad — a family pie will feed three people (probably could have fed four) and is under $ 20 with a few toppings.