Everybody’s Pizza

Was fortunate enough to check out this spot before the relocated up the street. Reguardless, this is great, great pizza. I’ve been there on several occasions & they always deliver. Great pizza & beer! :) I give the Italian Market Pizza 2 thumbs up!

I’m a fan of the pizza sandwiches. Try the City Chicken sandwich. I’m getting hungry just thinking about it. Everybody’s pizzas are also fantastically good. They have a character all their own, with fresh toppings – hand-​crafted by real pizza artists. (I swear.) Plus the wait-​staff flirts with me. At least, I think they’re flirting with me. Either way, I love the City Chicken sandwich. My friends like the pizza salads. The Thai Chicken thing is a major hit. And Everybody’s is just comfortable. It’s a true neighborhood hangout that provides consistently yummy food and friendly service. And I’m tellin’ you man, the City Chicken sandwich, you know? Mmmmm.
I hope the rumors of this place closing in favor of another (yawn) sushi restaurant are untrue. We don’t need another sushi restaurant. We need more masterpiece creations like the City Chicken sandwich.

Everybody’s has really excellent pizza — innovative topping options and a tasty crust. I I love the pizza sandwiches (two slices with salad in between). The salads look like some of the biggest, freshest things I’ve ever seen. I love that they have cider on tap, too. And the service is always friendly and quick.
I’m sad to hear that this location is closing at the end of 2010, for sushi. Like we need more sushi places. Bah. Now I’m going to have to go over to Emory for my fix.

Stopped in for a pretty decent pizza dinner. The selection here is quite sizable, including many Salad Pizzas that looked to be packed with salad goodness.
We had the Chicos Pizza which has Pineapple, Ham, Golden Raisins, and 3 Cheeses. Different, but very good.
I’m from out of town, so I took a taxi to get here, but from the looks of it the parking situation might be rather frustrating.
Prices seemed okay, maybe slightly on the high side. Overall though, the experience was a good one.

This is a solid neighborhood pizza joint, which serves as a nice compliment to the other neighborhood restaurants on the block. I love the porch!
The vibe and service are really great. My boyfriend and I were the first to arrive in our party of 5 who were all in a rush to eat and get to Park Tavern for Unplugged. The server had no problem with us placing the order for the table early and made sure it was timed to arrive to the table right as the rest of the group sat down. One large pizza was plenty enough to satisfy 3 hungry boys and a lady friend. I ordered the hummus for myself as I wasn’t very hungry. Everything was delish and we had plenty of leftovers!
The server even put in a rush order on a small cheese pizza for us so that we could bring it to some other friends at the park.
PS. Parking in the lot behind the restaurant is free if you eat at any Everybody’s or any of the other neighboring joints.

I love having lunch at Everybody’s. The staff is always so friendly and the food is extremely affordable. If you’re in a hurry at lunch it’s great for that too. I usually don’t even order pizza here although it is really good. I just can’t pass up the Country Chicken Sandwich. It’s served on a flat bread which I think is their pizza dough and has field greens, goat cheese, roasted garlic and thinly sliced chicken. Oh. My. God. I also like to get the Spinach Artichoke Dip which is served with breadsticks for dipping. Heaven. Plus, I always have plenty leftover for lunch the next day.

Good pizza and they now carry Little Kings beer from Ohio.
The Little Kings alone gets them 4 stars. Try some today.

The pizza here isn’t like other places and I can’t figure out what makes it taste so different. Usually I order the same thing every time I go to a restaurant but at Everybody’s I tend to switch it up a bit. The food at both locations is equally great– the thing about this one is that it is in VaHi and you know, parking is a nightmare (never mind the extremely high number of people who may qualify as douche bags because let’s face it, VaHi is plagued with that crowd). Anyway– the food!
I like the Spinach Artichoke Dip — be warned that this comes with super bread-​y bread sticks! And really it never feels like there are enough pieces of bread, though. Pace yourself!
So sometimes I get the salad and it really is huge– HUGE! I’m a weirdo with my salads (in addition to other stuff) so I usually have to explain to the waiter/​waitress what to do with my salad because I don’t like that crunchy clear/​white ice burg lettuce crap. At Everybody’s I just order the Organic Mixed Field Greens and Roma Tomato Salad! It is SOOOO tasty and perfect! I get the Everybody’s Herb dressing and mix it up before pouring it on the salad. They have some great chicken that you can get added on as well. They do NOT do croutons.
Tip: If you think the salad is going to be TOO big for you then take out some and put it on the plate and add the dressing there. You don’t want to have dressing on the whole thing and try and take it with you!
When I don’t get a salad I get the individual sized Everybody’s pizza. That comes with Mushrooms, pepperoni, green peppers, roma tomatoes, extra cheese. I don’t know that I would call it extra cheese but whatever– I’m not the extra cheese sort of person so I’m glad. It’s a good pizza and it’s a lot to eat! I’ve never been a peppers on pizza person but here I am!

We came tonight with some trepidation based on the reviews. I wasn’t THAT worried since we had two Groupons for $ 50 — what’s the worst that can happen, right?
All of the other members of my happy little band (Spouse and three of 5 offspring) were resigned to having to eat a salad (since they are GF); it wasn’t that dire!
They got a HUGE salad that had lots of good stuff and was sufficient to end justifying a trip home for the remnants (seriously, 4 people ate of it and about half was still left over).
I got a personal pizza that was good — I don’t like thick crust and they did a good job with the thin. I got a lot of toppings and they were good, but a little insipid.
We went on a Friday night and, surprisingly, were immediately seated and waited upon. Hope this doesn’t mean that they are doing a slow death spiral!

YOU «WILL» NEED FINANCIAL AID TO EAT HERE!!!
With pies that are $ 24.95, not 25.00, and a salad menu that reads more like an ingeniously confusing nickel dime operation that naturally steers you into one of their $ 13.25 house salads.
Honestly guys, 25 cents?
So…
.
Dinner for two.
Appetizer.
shared salad,
two drinks each,
pizza, and tip
Only out about $ 79,95 what a deal folks!!!
Final note… Not put off by used car lot style menu pricing? Don’t forget that you will more than likely need to pay for over priced parking too.
It’s your money sucka~

Ive been here a few times and I gotta admit that i’m not a huge fan of the pizza, We also had the lasagna which was ok but it didn’t really separate itself for the price that it cost.
The service was good and they have a great beer list, just wasn’t all that excited about the food.
It is worth noting that they have a great deal here for lunch where 6.99 gets you beer or wine a salad and a personal pizza.

Service was pretty solid and I like their beer on tap selection. No complaints there. This 2 star review is more for the food.
Got the mixed lettuce salad with Italian dressing, and that was good. Got bacon bits on it – covered the entire thing with bacon, which, I have no complaints about at all. However, if you want it to be a bit lighter on the bacon, you should ask, or else they top the entire bowl of salad with a layer of bacon (why would anyone ever complain about that though?) Salad with tons of bacon = win.
The pizza was really disappointing. I’m willing to say I’d rather go to Domino’s for a pizza instead of Everybody’s. Got a BBQ chicken pizza to split with friends and it was just not good. The crust was thick and bready and didn’t taste like pizza. The toppings were okay — the chicken was more like it was taken off the bone and dark meat, and the tomatoes are a weird addition to a bbq chicken pizza (also made the pizza soggy). Perhaps I just made a poor choice, but come on, a specialty pizza should have been a tried and true recipe, and this just was not it. Also, the specialty pizzas are not cheap, which just made this worse.
For pizza, Mellow Mushroom, or if you want to spoil yourself, Antico’s. This is a place to hang out and grab a beer, but not to eat a good slice.

Whodda thunk this pizza place is vegan-​friendly? In fact, it’s more than vegan-​friendly, it’s lovin’ itself some veganness. Because they have a cheeseless pizza here. That, interestingly enough, happens to be THE BEST CHEESELESS PIZZA I’VE EVER HAD. They load it up with veggies and don’t just give you bland tomato-​sauce underneath, or plain old olive oil, but HOT PEPPER INFUSED olive oil! AND as if THAT weren’t enough, they sprinkle sesame seeds on top! For some extra nutritional value for us malnourished vegans! Since when does an omni pizza place think of such little touches for us humble herbivores? AMAZING!
We went for lunch on a sunny day and sat in the back, which I thought was really pleasant. Granted, I’m from San Francisco, so all this sunshine in April craziness and outdoor dining insanity has me super-​enamored and probably really easy to impress when it comes to patios and porches and things but WHATEVER I liked it. And the service was friendly — I made the admittedly weird (BUT ALSO APPARENTLY BRILLIANT!) request of asking for some hummus to go with my pizza and the server didn’t bat an eyelash. He brought me a huge side of hummus which, *VEGAN TIP* was AWESOME on top of the pizza. Next time I’m going to request that they just slather that puppy with hummus pre-​baking and I bet you they will let me do that because they are NICE and it is a REALLY GOOD IDEA.
So next time your omni friends want to go here and you think about making them pick another place because you think you’ll have a crappy vegan meal, think again! You CAN feel like a «normal» person!
Go here. Order this pizza. Even if you are not vegan, because you really should think about eating fewer animal products because they are mean and bad for the world. And order it with hummus. And without roasted bell peppers because those things are slimey and gross. Or keep them on there if you’re weird and into that, but either way message me to thank you after because YOU’RE WELCOME.

I give it 5 stars for service when I get the shoulder massage from bart.
good place to get loaded before going home alone.

Everybody’s has been a consistantly good experience. They almost always have a great pie, good beer list, and a good vibe. They also have a great deck in back.
However, last time we became adventourous and ordered the Thai chicken pizza crisp which was a huge mistake. Think peanut butter and a little chicken on pita. And not even Jiff! Trust me– don’t do this.

The service was a little slow, but we were in no hurry. The beer menu was surprisingly fun– lots of mixed beer/​ale concoctions. I had the black velvet, and would recommend that to anyone who likes hard apple cider.
The pizza was fantastic, though not really finger-​edible. It was LOADED with delicious toppings, and I had a hard time stopping myself from eating far far beyond full. There are a lot of really good sounding pre-​mixed pizza topping suggestions on the menu, but I recommend making your own choices for your first visit here. I had pepperoni, italian sausage, onion and artichoke heart. It was WONDERFUL!
The atmosphere was a little noisy, but we were still able to have a conversation. Its a smaller place, but it appears that they also have a heated patio. There was a party of 20 next to us, so they can definitely handle large groups if you come at the right time and/​or give them the right amount of notice.
The menu is quite large– lots of different things that I would like to try: salads, pizza breads, calzones, subs. It all sounds very good. As far as I could tell, the dessert menu had 2 options on it. Thats ok, though. I recommend letting your pizza digest a wee bit, then head to the gelato place across the street from the other side of the gas station (cash only!). You wont regret it!
Overall I will certainly be coming back. I gave it 4 stars because it didnt quite push things to AMAZING level. Great for dates, family dinners, get togethers with friends…

I can’t believe that I haven’t already reviewed Everybody’s! I used to be a way-​too-​regular at the N. Highland store a couple of years ago, when I lived just a mile or so away. I returned yesterday for take out dinner, as I was in the ‘hood. The good feelings, great people and service, and delicious food are all intact.
I love sitting at the (small but cool) bar at this location (I specify, because there’s a totally different vibe to the bar and restaurant location by Emory — not bad, just different). They have Strongbow on tap. They are super-​happy to make your order to go and graciously let you know that it’s ready whenever you are — no hurry, stay if you want, or if you’re rushed we’re ready. .. that kind of attitude. My mixed field greens plus goat cheese (with the Everybody’s garlic ranch and vinaigrette on the side, so I could mix them) was perfect. The small cheese-​with-​extra-​cheese and the small chicken-​spinach-​roma tomatoes were excellent.
Yum and yum, I need to re-​return soon!

Don’t let looks deceive you. Everybody’s Pizza doesn’t look like much from the outside, but we had an EXCEPTIONAL dinner experience. Once you pass through the non-​spectacular entrance, you notice the nice, rustic wood interior.
We were greeted right away and seated outside (at our request) on the patio off the back. Here, we got to enjoy a great dinner outdoors in a quiet, shaded surrounding. And our server was very attentive and friendly, making it an even more enjoyable experience. We were going to order a large pizza for three kids and asked our server if he thought it was enough. He suggested we just get a medium as their pizzas are pretty big and thick. He was SO right, and it was just enough… or even a tad too much. Unfortunately, we didn’t think to ask him if the other entrees were big, too. My partner ordered the Everybody’s Hero pizza sandwich. I decided to try the unique «pizza salad,» which was a salad on top of a pizza crust. Both were ENORMOUS. Delicious, but enormous. Unless you’re a really, REALLY big eater, be aware that anything and everything is definitely shareable! When you know that, it makes Everybody’s a great value!
I’d definitely recommend this casual restaurant for a get-​together with friends or family. It’s right for all ages. And everything is SO full of flavor, that you can’t possibly be disappointed in any choice on the menu.

Part of the Eat It, Atlanta Pizza Days (pictures using link):
The other night I headed over to Everybody’s with Foodie Buddha to give it a go. If you read FB’s blog (which you should) you will know that he is a tough critic and I was looking forward to having his opinion as part of this series. It wasn’t hard to grab a table, in fact, I was surprised to see how empty it was, though it was a weeknight.
Everybody’s has two sections of pizzas — the regular and the «Pizza Crisps», which are their very thin 13 pizzas. While the latter option sounded intriguing we ended up going with two medium regular pizzas — one cheese and one «Everybody’s» (aka supreme). This was plenty of food, so I ended up having a lot of leftovers.
I am not a huge fan of this style of pizza. The dough is very thick and cake like, and it was slightly undercooked. The sauce was sparing and unmemorable. There was more cheese than is usually necessary, but it kinda worked out with this size/​thickness of slice. The plain cheese was the better of the two pizzas to me.
While I don’t have an extremely positive opinion of the pizza I tried that night, I must say that an affinity to this pizza may be purely stylistic. One of the blind tasters of my leftovers was actually a big fan of this style of dough, but the dough was the largest complaint from two others. Also, I tasted one of the reheated slices and I think the dough got a little bit better after some more time in the oven.
I’m not extremely eager to go back, though I don’t want to paint too ugly of a picture because I think there are plenty of people that could get down on this pie. You just have to like a very thick crust and lots of cheese, and I think there are probably plenty of people that are happy to accommodate that request. For those of you like me that like a thinner, crispier style, maybe the Pizza Crisper is the way to go. Anyone have any comments on those?
Regardless of scores, Everybody’s is a pretty fun atmosphere, is in a great location, our server was very friendly, and I enjoyed the company so I ended up enjoying my visit.

After years of pizza joint hoping in Atlanta, I landed on Everybody’s some 15 years ago. Another place my father had never frequented, so we headed there before the Georgia game one Saturday to enjoy a pie.
I insisted on ordering the Fresh Baked Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks with Cheese. It comes with a side of marinara sauce — nice and hot. While we nibbled, we checked out the Tech game (rooting for them to lose, of course) and waited for out pizza pie.
We decided on the Everybody’s — which is mushrooms, pepperoni, green peppers, Roma tomatoes and extra cheese. We had them add black olives for a little something extra. Once the pizza came out of the kitchen, we forgot about football and enjoyed the piping hot slices.
The beauty of Everybody’s Pizza is how crispy the crust is on the bottom and how perfectly cooked the topping are. The pizza was delicious as usual and I also ended up taking half of it home… as usual. As we ate, I flagged down the waitress and ordered a personal size pizza with mushrooms and onions to go (for Mom). It took a bit too long to get the to go pizza, but at least we had something to watch on the TV.
If you want good pizza and are in the area, Everybody’s is the place. Just be sure to place your to-​go order early enough so you aren’t stuck waiting around too long.