Destination Unknown Beer Company

This brewery has a nice tasting room that is gradually growing to meet it’s potential as more people discover — they discover «Destination Unknown»? That’s confusing, I need a beer.
Whatever, that’s not important. Inside, it’s typical brewery (bare industrial) with lots of finished wood to soften it up. It’s basically the kind of place that makes the kind of guy like me feel right at home — whatever that means. There’s a few tables and stools, as well as an upstairs which is (as of my last visit) still mostly off-​limits. The big bar (with stools in front) houses the taps and a double chalkboard of what is being offered (along with standard information like ABV and what sizes they’re available in).
There were about 6 beers on tap (I think they had room for more on the board), and they also have a rotating «guest brewer» tap which was explained to me as a way to keep the craft culture alive on Long Island by expanding the availability of further-​flung (yet still «local») breweries into more areas. Over the summer, a Moustache (out of Riverhead) keg was on tap and it was especially nice to be able to pick up a growler there instead of driving all the way out to Long Island’s cloaca for it.
As a «farm» brewery they have to get a certain percentage of their ingredients from New York, so you know that buying beer here is definitely helping someone in your state*. I love supporting New York, it’s my natal state! (WORD OF THE DAY ALERT)
There’s really not any place to get food here on the regs, so stock up at a deli or order a pizza delivered or something (probably don’t get spaghetti, that’d be weird). Popcorn is available, and they also sell Beer Soap in case you were wondering «does this place sell beer soap?»
Yup, yup they do.
Destination Unknown: Best Beer Soap in Bay Shore
(Also, VERY good beer — I enjoy the Dubbel Rainbow and I can barely stand Belgians. Probably my inner-​German at work)
*as long as your state is at least 20% NY. I guess the other 49 states can share that measly 80% remainder of the ingredients**
** that sounds snarky, I really do like the idea of incentives for locally produced stuff like the Farm Brewery law does. By 2018 it’ll be 60% and after 2024 a whopping 90%. BOOM! Who else gives you facts like this?

Finally got a chance to give this hidden brewery a try and it was excellent. All of there beer was exceptional l, there honey doo and brown tide as well as the stowaystout was amazing. The Brewers and staff are all awesome. Just a great place to go to grab a pint and get your growlers filled. Give this place a try!!!

Awesome place! Cures what ails you. Great brewmaster. Knowledgable and friendly. Good variety of brews.

This is a great new brewery with new beers every week. The Dominick is a good white IPA and is a mainstay at the brewery. This is a great place to hang out and is a casual place with free popcorn, good beer and chill vibes.

This is the newest brewery on Long Island. It’s really great beer. My favorite was Dominicks. It’s hoppy and very aromatic.