Gina’s Pizza

Pretty good NYC style pizza. Sauce was good and the cheese was amazing. I would recommend this place to anyone and they seem to be doing good basement. It is a bit pricey, but still a great place to grab some pizza.

Top notch NY style pizza with good crust and lots of fresh topping choices, I’m a plain man myself.
Pesto sauce is not to be missed.
Outstanding salads with wonderful homemade dressings.
Good eats, great service from friendly people who make a quality product, what else could you ask for?

Wonderful newer pizza place! Love it! Fresh fresh fresh ingredients. We order a pizza with basil sauce, ball mozz, tomato, spinach and mushrooms. Amazing!!! If you want thin crust it’s excellent. Salad is crazy good too. Romaine and spinach. Recommend the ball mozz for cheese. $ 7 for a big salad it’s a deal! Highly recommend the sundried tomato balsamic.

I felt like Gina’s was not anything too special… 3 large pizzas was $ 50, which was more than what I wanted to spend but fine. They didn’t have black olives, either, which is weird and deal breaker for me. Pizza was fine, I didn’t hate it but for the price I think I would definitely go somewhere else next time.

For me Gina’s has some of the best tasting pizza in the metro Cleveland area, that I have had. Yes there are many styles of pizza out there and many different pizza preference and so I understand that the way you are brought up may determined your likes and dislikes in food that could be different from others. For me spending a good portion of my life in the northeastern region of the United States, Gina’s got it right on as far as that New York flavor profile that I personally love. For me there are three major components that make up a good pizza, the crust, sauce and cheese. The crust at Gina’s was the star for me, it had that slightly charred flour taste on the bottom that I love, that can only be produced by a pizza being cooked directly on a hot oven deck, whether it’s coal, wood or gas fired oven. A taste you can’t get in some conveyor belt type oven. The crust was crisp, yet pliable, with a nice tip sag that naturally could be folded when picked up. The sauce was well balanced without being overly sweet with just a nice natural tomato flavor to it. And the cheese I would be guessing was a mixture of a couple different kind of Italian cheeses with nice natural salty quality coming from either a good quality Romano or Parmesan cheese mix in. Can’t wait for my next pizza from Gina’s. I’d like to also positively point out when picking up my pizza the entire place was noticeable very clean and fresh inside. As a side note I would question the Thomas R. negative review, the only review every written by him.

Never crispy when asked, like any other pizza place they don’t cut the pizza and when kids dive in the cheese pulls off.
Great single pieces when re-​heated though…

I have to say one thing, Thomas R you must have been at Pizza Hut and not at Ginas pizza. Growing up on the east coast and now living in Cleveland I have been searching for a pizza that delivers the true taste and quality of NY style pizza. Well, I have found it at Ginas. The pizza is amazing and her salad dressing made fresh are truly addictive. I had her lemon oil dressing and can’t wait for Gina to start bottling it. So glad to have such a great pizza place here on the west side in Bay Village!

Love this pie. Not thick but not thin. Perfect medium between the two. Have had a pepperoni mushroom and the cheese. Both great, cooked with a crisp. Will be going back again.

What a FIND this place is! FINALLY, my long search is OVER! Gina’s Pizza is, hands down, the BEST tasting pizza pie in all of Northeast Ohio! It reminds me of some of the very best pizzerias where I grew up in the NY and NJ area before I moved out here 20 years ago. Crispy thin crust, authentic ‘NY style’ baked to perfection, foldable, flavorful, well-​balanced, and oh so fresh tasting! Pizza perfectionists and purists can judge a truly great pizza by simply tasting a plain cheese slice without any toppings. Gina’s is simply amazing even just plain. I won’t mind taking the drive to Bay Village from North Olmsted when i’m craving the very best tasting pizza. This place IS ‘the real deal’!

Family joint located on the West Side. Fantastic homemade pizza which is worth the price (higher/​mid range). Carry out only.
Crust is homemade and authentic (thin crust style) and is just as good as some of my fav. spots in Little Italy. Sauce is smooth and has good flavor but doesn’t stand out enough compared to the other elements which is why I only gave ⁴⁄₅. Tons of toppings to choose from and everything is fresh. Other menu items besides pizza include salads & calzones.
Service is fast (15 min) for pickup. I am looking forward to trying their pesto. Overall I would much rather support the local businesses out there like Gina’s vs Dominos or the other chains.

Great pizza. The crust is as good as I have ever had and the many toppings are fresh and plentiful. A good value for the mobey. Reminds me of the NY style pies I had as kid in Boston. Gina, here is wishing you much success– from two big fans in this household — in addition to the 6 other family members in town for the holiday!

Best pizza on the west side. Great caprese salad, home made dressings, fresh toppings and lots of options for vegetarians and vegans.

This is the best pizza for the price! They don’t charge extra for vegan cheese which is unheard of. They have lots of toppings & specialty pizzas & calzones. I like the crust. The pizza’s ready fast & the staff are super nice!

Great pizza is hard to come by on the West side of Cleveland. Westlake has Sweet Basil — which is above average — and used to have Casa Vella at Crocker Park (close to NY style) until it went out of business. The rest is all «Midwest» style full of dough and slathered with cheese. No good authentic NY or Neapolitan style pizza left (though Tomoris in Lakewood shows promise).
Gina’s makes a solid pizza that is fresh and better than the rest in the area (definitely better than any regional or national chain here). The sauce is a bit tepid (can get lost in the cheese and toppings). The crust a bit basic (not enough chew or flavor). The plain cheese is probably their best.

The best pizza in Cleveland. I owned a pizza shop at one time. I know pizza. This is legitimate. Get the tri color.

We actually stopped here on a whim one Wednesday evening. You know that moment when you ask your girl what she wants to eat and she says, I don’t care and then you give 5 options but something is wrong with all of them, welcome to that moment. We ended up driving around and just parked in the lot that the small hometown shop was in and finally agreed that something new was worth a shot. Behold Gina’s Pizza.
We were welcomed by a high school kid and a middle aged woman who seemed to be manning the shop on their own. They were super friendly and welcomed us by highlighting the menu and saying that they could have a pizza done in a few minutes. As with all new pizza places, I was a bit skeptical but the woman (who may or not have been Gina) whipped us up a medium sausage and pepperoni pie in less than 10 minutes. I have to say, the personal touch of a small business chain compared to a corporate Papa John’s really shined here. You could tell the people working really valued our business.
We said our thanks and arrived home and our mouth was watering from how good the pizza looked & smelled (I devoured my half before I could take a picture). It was more of a thin crust style pizza (perfect chewability), lighter and tasty sauce and loads of cheese. The ingredients were FRESH and I could not get over how good the sausage was. Whoever this Gina lady is, she has made a GREAT establishment. My only complaint is that this place isn’t open more than it is (it has small business hours, not really open super late). One of the best pizza places on the west side and one of the best finds of 2015! Hats off to you Gina’s, you have earned my business and I hope you succeed.

Great pizza, I loved the sauce and crust! Like other reviews, it tasted like the authentic NY pizza!

So happy to have found this excellent local pizza shop as we just moved into the area. Pizza, salads and dressings are wonderfully delicious and fresh. Perfection!

Excellent little independent pizza shop serving about as close as you can get to New York-​style pizza. Tried both their original and pesto sauces. Both were great. Crust is crispy and then chewy, and the pieces are made for folding over. I wish them all the success in the world.

Pizza is really good! I like that they have a simplified menu with fresh options. Def the best option for pizza in the Bay Area. The caprese salad was great too. I do wish the hours were a bit longer. 8pm on a Friday night seems a little early.