Sinapi’s Pizza Rustica

Coming from brooklyn, in the area to go-​kart, passed by for a quick bite, have to say the food is awesome for such a quite neighborhood compared to the city haha! Food was great, service was great, everyone was welcoming and cool, if you are in town and want some great food with good vibes, stop by here. I found them on here! Haha good luck to the owner.

I give this place 5 stars for the personalized service. We have ordered from here usually once a week (and even more then that when I was pregnant and craving their chicken parm) all of the food we have had has been delicious and the pizzas are great too.
The standout moment for me was late on a Friday or Saturday night when we ordered dinner and my salad arrived without chicken — I called to ask if a mistake had been made by me or by them, and the owner himself showed up at my door within 10 minutes with a container of grilled chicken and an apology. They always seem to recognize us when we call in, and that’s what keeps us coming back.

This is a pizzeria with a nice sized menu and about 8 tables and a counter for another 3 or 4 people. The pizza is really good as are the calzones but the meatballs and the chicken scarpaiello are well worth trying.
The place is run by a really friendly, down to earth family.
The area is filled with overpriced places or fast food chains. This added a much needed option in the neighborhood as it’s good food, at a fair price.

I moved into the area from NYC, so I think I know good Italian food. This place has quickly become one of my favorites. Service is good, place is very friendly. Food is well prepared and consistent.
Easy to park and get in and out of. I also have ordered in as well. Orders are delivered timely and correct.
Known for its Pizza but the entrees and salads are good as well.

Hands down best pizza in the bedford/​Katonah area. The specialty pizzas are awesome.

Excellent food, great family business. Chicken Milanese is the best I’ve had. My wife loves the grilled chicken with vegetables. Place is busy so get there early.

Delicious food, we have eaten her twice this past week, and just had food delivered tonight, every dish is cooked perfect and not over seasoned

You go to a place for 2 main reasons… food and service. Sinappi’s is second to none in both categories. Their pizza is top notch, and there are many different things on the menu I would recommend trying. For example, their burgers are great and their chicken fingers are the best I’ve ever had. Try some of their entrees as well, like the chicken franchese. They also offer the wood fire pizza which is a terrific option as well. The owner is constantly striving to improve the place and both he and his son are always there and always take care of their customers. I’ve gone to other pizza places in the area and have gotten the feeling that they were doing ME a favor by serving me food while I was the one giving them the business. Not the case at Sinappi’s. They know their customers by name and constantly show their appreciation for you coming in. I’ve ordered things they didn’t have or ran out of. The response is always «no problem, I’ll make that for you». There have even been times I’ve gone in there and said I wasn’t sure what I wanted, and knowing me, they would make something up. To me, THAT’S service. If you are in the area, I wouldn’t recommend going anywhere else. Without a doubt a 5 star place for various reasons.

this is a review on their catering. Normally, their catering is pretty good and willing to work with you. However, for my daughter’s birthday in June, I ordered a half tray of chicken fingers (among other things). When we opened it, (and you’re not going to believe it), we literally were looking at 6 FULL pieces of chicken fingers (for 15 girls) and the rest? UGH…“chips” of the batter… I“M NOT KIDDING… already tipped the driver and everything… had no choice but to cut up the chicken pieces… we «saved» the scraps… basically that’s what it was… in a baggie but never had the time to take it down there and show them… totally disappointed in what was given to us, GIVEN the price I paid for a ½ tray. It was comical… my mom, my husband, and I with gaping mouths looking at the tray.

I’m so surprised this place has so many good reviews. I’ve eaten here several times and unfortunately I feel the pizza has gone from bad to the worst in town. My job orders from here sometimes and the last time we ordered was by far the worst pizza ever. First of all the prices on the menu are not what they are charging. We were charged at least 50 cents extra on each item. Now, onto the pizza. First of all, it arrived cold. The bread was hard and almost stale like, the sauce is so sweet and there’s not enough cheese. We ordered half meat pizza that literally looked like dog chow. Not trying to be rude, just honest. The salad looked good but I didn’t have any, so I can’t say anything about it. I feel bad the pizza wasn’t good because the ppl on the phone are always so nice. Two stars, one for the customer service, one for the appearance of the salad. Zero for the pizza. Ughhhh

The food is excellent and the staff friendly. They are very involved with the community.

Always a favorite. Staff is so nice and willing to adjust the order as needed. Very helpful

Really good pizza and friendly owners. Recommend the nonnas pizza as its a really thin crust and taste like homemade.

The staff at this place is outstanding, the pizza is old school brick oven wood fired. I can not give this place enough praise. If you are in the northern Westchester area stop by and give these people your business you will not be disappointed. They love kids too.

Really good Philly cheesesteak, french fries, onion rings, and garlic bread.
Good pizza (it would be great if they consistently cleaned their ovens, sometimes the bottom can be a little charred). Their burgers are good, again it would be better if they consistently cleaned their grill because they can get a little charred.
They do dine-​in, take out and delivery (you can even order online!). Free parking lot. You usually get coupons with take out or delivery.

Best pizza I tasted in northern Westchester! Great staff and great pizza selections here. :)

White pizza slice was ok, but garlic knots were burnt and dry with no evidence of exposure to garlic.

Got there a lil late, 8:30 on a Thursday night and was fed as if I was a dog. Stale, old, smelly– that old nasty chicken scent (like dog feces) chicken roll and veggie slice for $ 9.00. That’s the first and last dollar I spend at this fraudulent establishment! Afterwards I checked their website and chicken rolls are $ 4.50 NOT $ 5.00 as I was unethically told and speciality slices are $ 3.50 not $ 4.00 as I was told.
UNREAL!

Ordered delivery from here the other night as I was feeling under the weather and not wanting to cook. Man who took my order was great, very accommodating with the substitutions I wanted to make and all the questions I had.
Food arrived in a timely manner, still hot and huge portions.
I would order from them again if I’m in the area for sure.

Love at first bite. And it only took two or three visits to conclude that Sinapi’s is my new favorite pizza place. That’s coming from a total pizza snob who knows the indisputable truth: anything made outside of a 50 mile radius of the Bronx simply isn’t pizza.
Sinapi’s wood-​fired brick oven yields a thin, crispy crust that makes you want to eat an entire pie by yourself. The sauce and toppings are Genuine Italian Tasty™. It’s best if you eat it there, but it’s good at home too.
Can’t wait to try the other things on the menu!
Another big win is that they have online ordering. I love being able to key in my order as I’m about to leave the office, and then when I get to Sinapi’s the order is ready and paid for.