Casper’s Pizza

We treated ourselves to Casper’s Pizza last night. It was amazing! Spend the few extra dollars for delicious, hot, flavorful pizza. I’ve read complaints about the wait time when dining in. We called ahead and it was ready to rock n roll when husband showed to pick it up. We dined in the restaurant a few years ago and I found that it wasn’t necessarily a long wait time, but the wonderful smells and anticipation of yumminess can sure make it seem like a long wait. Real ham on the Hawaiian, don’t be afraid of the red onions unless you’re a sissy. if you like blue cheese try the turkey-​bacon-​blue cheese pizza. I think this is a respectful restaurant which honors the craftsmanship of making a meal rather than assembling some food.

Love the pizza, salad bar, the people and the bulldogs! Everything is fresh, real and delicious.

Seems to be a local favorite for some reason. We’ve eaten there a few times and nobody in our house cares for the pizza.

I love their Pizza!!! The BBQ is real good as well.

Wow… just… Wow! I rarely give a 5-​star rating, but hands down this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust was crispy without being overly bready. And toppings? Omg they piled the toppings on! When it comes to mass-​market pizza (Papa Murphy’s, Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, etc) I can polish off 4 pieces pretty easily. This pizza, 2 and I was stuffed!
For our first try, we got a 16″ half Casper’s combo and half Bosley’s Bleu cheese. I had the Casper’s combo. The best part of this pizza is the small round pepperoni slices. Like baby pepperonis. They were actually crispy! What a delightful surprise!
This is now our go-​to pizza joint. You will pay a little more, but trust me — you will get what you pay for!

Stopped here on our way through because of the variety, pizza, BBQ, salad and burgers. Salads were crisp and full of variety, kids said the burgers were great, some had different pizzas. They said the regular pepperoni was there favorite. I had the chicken BBQ sandwich with Mac n cheese as a side. The sandwich was good with plenty on it. The homemade Mac n cheese though was AWESOME! I always try Mac n cheese at different locations and this was the best. The only complaint out of 19 people was the deep dish bulldog pizza had to much cheese and we love cheese
Definitely worth the stop though

We had the margarita pizza. It was absolutely delicious, just needed a little garlic on the crust. Previous reviews I read complained of a dog being in the restaurant. Well, there is. But he is in a leash in the back and not in the immediate cooking area. I wouldn’t have known he was there if he didn’t want to play with all the kids running around. I would definitely eat here again.

«Yay! I’m a fan» — this place gets my vote as the best pizza parlor in Belfair, as I would choose Casper’s if given the option between them, Seabeck Pizza or Papa Murphy’s. As far as I am aware these are the only pizza choices in town.
Their bleu cheese chicken pizza is so yummy. My husband took me here after having the same pizza with some of his fellow co-​workers, he really wanted me to try this place! We had called in the pizza order about 15 minutes before arriving, so the pizza arrived on our table very shortly after we seated ourselves.
It was dead on a Seahawks game day, I’m sure they have more crowds on Saturdays and weeknights. We didn’t mind this as we had choice seating :) But it would be nice if they had more of a football crowd (group specials? seahawks themed pizza?) during Sunday afternoons!
Comfortable, pleasant employees, delicious food. I got a salad from the salad bar, and while I totally understand that most people don’t get salad at a pizza place, I did find myself wishing that they had some more options in there. If you’re looking to make a salad, head over to the salad bar first to see if there’s something you can make with what they’ve got.
We will certainly be back sometime in the future, and I’m confident that we won’t be disappointed.

So Much Wonderful Food! The BBQ Is Awesome! The Pizza Can Not Be Beat! This Pizza Is The Best In The State!!!
And Just So You Know. .. I Read This On The Casper’s FB Page & Wanted To Share!
Our health department inspector Ben Schenk dropped in on us today. Casper’s got another 100% from him. We have never gotten one mark against us in the 4 years we have been opened. We thank our employees for there hard work to keep up with our tough standards. Ben also mentioned that he has received two complaints about Stoney along with pictures that they took of him. He told us that he replied back to both of them that we have their permission to have the dog in Casper’s. On that note people love having Stoney in here as do we. We follow the rules that the health department has given us so we don’t jeopardize having our boy with us.

This place is awesome! So warm and homey inside with great solid wood tables and log siding.
The pizza we ordered was half Margarita and half Veggie. Nice thick crust and sooooooo yummy. It was gone in a flash. The pizza took a little while, but it was well worth the wait.
Can’t wait to come back.

I love this place. Every time we go here either at lunch or dinner the owners are amazing! The beer on tap is served in ice cold cups, the salad plates are chilled as well, the salad bar is a full meal all its own and the BBQ or pizza menu is simply above all other meals in town.
The large pizza is plenty to feed a family of four especially if you get a salad, so don’t buy two unless you just want to spend the money for lunch tomorrow!
But their pizza cold is awesome also…
Visit Belfair and have a great meal… See you there!

Pizza was good but not the best I have ever had. Atmosphere is LOUD. The hood fan is so noisy you could hardly hear the person sitting next to you. Would eat here again but not my first choice.

They say they have pizza by the slice (=fast) but they don’t tell you that when you order a slice you have to wait 30min for them to make a pizza from scratch to give you a slice. Missed the ferry waiting half hour for a mediocre slice of pizza. Terrible, F.

So let’s deal with the animal in the room first — yes, there is a dog at Casper’s. He’s a big old bulldog and proudly wears his Seahawks jersey on game days. We love him — but if you don’t like dogs, then consider yourself forewarned.
So let’s get to the good stuff: the pizza. We’ve tried several pizzas from Casper’s surprisingly diverse menu, from the basic Pepperoni to the crowd-​pleasing deep dish Bulldog to the unexpectedly delicious Reuben pizza. All were piled high with cheese and toppings, supported by a crust that’s thick but not too thick, and all around delicious, from the first bite to the last. The hard truth is that I have a tough time stopping when there’s a Casper’s Pizza in the vicinity, even when I know I’m already full.
Though it’s not on the menu. you can ask for cheese bread as well — and it’s also delicious.
Casper’s is a clean and friendly place, with a fun atmosphere. There’s a salad bar with all the usual salad makings and a few good beers on tap if you’re of a mind. Sure, it closes earlier than most pizza places, sometimes they forget to pick up the phone again after putting you on hold, sometimes the pizza takes a while, and sometimes the dog gives you a long, baleful look while you’re waiting for it. Frankly, it’s all worth it.
It’s worth it because of the pizza. Not only is Casper’s the best pizza in Belfair — it’s a pizza worth making the trip to Belfair for. In fact, after writing this, I’m hoping I can talk my way into one tomorrow night.

I was in Belfair late February 2014 for a company event with my state manager. We arrived a little after lunch time and were starving. I did my social media mobile thing and checked out the restaurants in the area and Casper’s kept showing up and with favorable reviews.
I had the BBQ’d chicken breast and corn bread. Yum! The chicken breast was done just right and their homemade BBQ sauce is absolutely wonderful! They should bottle it and sell. Also the cornbread was homemade and Dave said they put a little cream of corn in it. Whatever they do, it’s the best cornbread I can remember. A great place, friendly service. I’ll be back!

The food is ok. Nice atmosphere. Parking is alright.
I called my order in advance. I got there 30 minutes later and it was still being prepared — but that is ok — because they gave me some extra chicken wings.
Friendly staff.
Kinda pricy menu… I’ll post a bunch of pics I took — of the menu…
3.5 out of 5

By far the best pizza I have ever had in my life. I will go back for pizza again, I enjoyed the dog in the restaurant, it made if feel cozy.
The ribs were under cooked and tough. They needed to cook for a few more hours, and the chicken tasted strange.

Great pizza and barbeque with a small-​town friendly atmosphere. This Belfair restaurant deserves your business!
The place is immaculately clean, with a casual atmosphere well suited to the city and the menu. The beer taps feature a local brewery, and the beers are excellent.
We’ve sampled several of the offerings here, but we keep coming back to the Grapeview Garlic Chicken… amazing.
Although we live many miles away, we detour in order to stop here. Pizza’s can be ordered to go, and even take-​and-​bake. We recently stopped and picked up one for home, and baked it that night to watch the Seahawks beat up the 49’ers. Perfect!

Two stars on Unilocal means «Meh.» I kinda feel that way about Casper’s Pizza, but I like «them» too, hence the three stars. I’ve eaten in once and ordered take out once. The staff is friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere is fine. The one time we ate in it was so we could watch football and drink beer. They have good beers on tap there and a big flat screen or two.
The pulled pork I ordered the first time was pretty good, though be sure you specify if you want a sandwich because what I got originally (by accident) was plate heaped with pulled pork. I requested a bun and received one. My husband ordered a burger, as he usually does and he reports that he was not pleased with it or its accompaniment of fries.
Recently we ordered a pepperoni & mushroom, extra cheese pizza to go. They tossed in a side of ranch for free for me, but I was asked to keep it on the D.L., so you didn’t hear that from me. The pizza was delish, decadent, greasy and bread-​y. I loved the mini-​pepperonis they use. Do they make thin crust? The hand tossed was typical American bread pizza, not that I have anything wrong with that.
Yes, they are way into their bulldog. No, he should not be in the restaurant. I hope they make it though. Belfair needs the new lifeblood they represent.

DOG ALERT!
My family rented a lake house for a week this past July and this is one of the places where we ventured out during our stay. We had a pizza craving that could not be met by me and a frozen pizza.
On entering Casper’s, it appeared clean and cute. The floor was bright with black and white tiles, and my daughter was enamoured with the big dog statue near the front. We ordered our pizza and drinks from a nice woman at the counter and found a table. Pinic tables lent it a fun atmosphere and the manager/​owner very nicely brought us some hot pita like bread and a dip similar to tzatziki, very creamy and yummy. We were happy.
And then we heard «woof»! My husband was sure it was the oven, some kind of funky timer??? I thought maybe there was a noisy dog outside, but it was definitely a «woof». My mom and kid didn’t really hear it. Then again, another «WOOF», and I leaned to the side and craned my neck so I could see the open kitchen, and sure enough, there in the area where they were prearing our food was a big old bulldog. He was cute enough, true, but, um, hello, health codes??? and my husband, sadly, HATES dogs, and will only tolerate them under certain conditions… and it was NOT a helper dog for the disabled in any way, it actually appeared that this Casper’s Pizza was named for this particular dog. And he hangs out there in the food prep area. SIgh.
Our pizza came, and it was delicious, honestly. One pizza had just the kid’s usual double cheese light sauce, crispy and good, and the other had a white garlic sauce and spinach I think and chicken… it was tasty too, but really, all we remember is that there was a dog in their kitchen, and we think that’s kinda nasty. And we saw the counter people petting the dog and then going back to food prep without washing their hands, That kind of killed it for us. We won’t be back.