Keystone Bakery

(3÷26÷2014) Got a batch of Potato Jalapeño Pierogis from a friend who lives in the Pittsburgh area. Pastry was very nice, smooth, even flaked a little after a boil/​fry in butter. Filling was savory and had a surprising amount of heat. Would def love to get again and try other fillings.

Keystone Bakery is one of my favorite places to visit when I am back in the BVA. While the bakery changed hands a few years ago you really can’t tell a difference, which is a good thing.
Atmosphere — Sweet smells, busy, narrow room, with clean and basic decorating as to not detract from the large glass counter/​case of tasty pastries.
Food — My favorites items here include the pecan rolls, Bunker hill rolls, Paska bread, dinner rolls, raisin bread, apricot Kolache, and walnut Kolache. Oh, and of course I like their cake. I like it in sheet form with the marble batter and white icing. The cake icing (Regular Butter Cream) here is a little dense than say Bethel Bakery, which uses a very light in texture French Buttercream. I can’t say one is better than the other, as it just depends on my mood or the event. If it is a graduation, baptism, or confirmation… a Keystone sheet cake please! If I am picking up a small round cake, I may prefer the latter.
Price — Reasonable! Appreciate what you have here BVA. In the South we only have fancy bakeries that think it’s cool to charge you $ 5 for one stinking brownie… no wonder I never stop.
Overall — If I still lived here I would be fat… but happy. Till then, I will continue to stop by when I am in the area. Keep up the good work Keystone!

Keystone has been a family favorite for years. Our b-​day cakes always came from there and they were always so cool with everything from a Cabbage Patch Kid doll to The Hulk to The Smurfs (I was a child of the 80’s you know:)!). They have added a location in Greensburg. Nice and a little bigger than the BV location but still the same awesome sweet treats. I love their icing however if you don’t like sweet, stay away from the cake because their icing is sweet. It definitely suits me to a tee because I love sweet. Cookies are great too. Like the strawberry logs as well. Hubby likes the cinnamon rolls and the cream horns. And the bread is fresh and soft and terrific! Oh and don’t forget their ravioli… meat and spinich, delightful!

Been a customer for 30 years! Keystone has great variety of baked goods, and there is almost nothing you will be unhappy eating! Bunker hill rolls, coconut cream pie, cream sticks and white cake are our favorites… also the fondant cookies. Great breads and pizza crust too! We love it!

Came here as a little girl. It’s still the way I remember it.