Me & Tommy’s Bar and Restaurant

This place was amazing. You must get the rice balls — they’re amazing in a pink vodka sauce. Don’t even bother asking for recipe bc it’s secret they will not give. The rock shrimp appetizer also amazing. I had the chicken Murphy it was dead on perfect. Salad came with meal, creamy balsamic I had. Get pitcher of red sangria too
I highly recommend this place

I have been going to Me and Tommy’s since they opened and the food is exceptional, the service is great, and the atmosphere is welcoming. We recently had our work holiday party there and there was no variation in excellence. They put just as much effort into a table of two as they do a table of 12.

A cozy little place, at an interesting out of the way location. Parking lot’s a little tough but no matter. Service is very nice. The steak smothered with sausage, peppers and onions was fine. Nothing bad but, nothing to write home about. Reasonable prices. We will go back.

Amazing stuffed pepper and rice balls in vodka sauce! Awesome staff! Everything was delicious

This is my «go-​to-​spot», nothing on the menu will disappoint, cozy, friendly staff,. I have relatives begging for the Pasta vodka sauce «to-​go» when I inform them I’ll be dining here. Some of my favorites are the stuffed cubanelle peppers and balsamico style calamari appetizers, Pork chops are hearty and the skirt steak with wasabi mash potatoes are a grand slam. Enjoy…

After moving to the neighborhood I am thrilled to have found this restaurant! The vodka sauce is to die for, with rice balls or pasta you will find yourself licking the plate. The menu has a lot of stuff but it’s not overwhelming and the staff is so friendly and always can offer a recommendation.

I love Me & Tommy’s, it’s a small place but a great find! the food is awesome and the rice balls I recommend trying to anyone, friendly staff!

Great portions, delicious food and excellent service. The place is small and cozy, but you can tell they focus on the quality of their food and attention to customers! Ill definitely be back!

Your typical Jersey Italian place but even cooler because it’s hidden and was previously a train station!
You have to go. Eat the rice balls and signature wings for sure. Bring your friends and family. The waitress is the sweetest.

You must try the rice balls its delicious and the best I’ve ever had. I love their vodka sauce and the waitress is very nice.

Great food, great people, reasonably priced! Rice balls are out of this world. And this is coming from someone who never orders nor likes rice balls. This place turned me around on em! I live an hour away and still make a point to come here as often as possible.

My husband and I eat here regularly. It is a MUST to stop by Me & Tommy’s. We have never had a dish that we didn’t like! Make a reservation and ALWAYS get the rice balls.
Service is great, the server even knows my favorite drink as well as my husbands. We stop by once every 2 – 3 months.
My sister and parents all love this restaurant as well.

Well I have already given me and tommy a review a few months back but I was back again on Father’s Day with my in-​laws and 5 year old daughter. All of us enjoyed our dinner, even our daughter ate an entire order of calamari! That’s how great it is. If a 5 year old polished off a plate of anything you know it had to be awesome. We are going back again tonight. Can’t get enough of this fantastic food! Oh; side note. I read someone’s review that service was a little slow… you can’t rush perfection! I love that they do not rush you out and food is spaced so you have time to relax.

You have to have the smothered rice balls!
Small place but the food is great
Service is sometimes slow but make sure to make a reservation, especially on the weekends.

I stumbled upon this spot while I was cutting traffic I drove passed it and loved that it wasn’t a big spot. Looked welcoming. I put it on my places to check out list and bam. Now I’m writing about it So parking is great I made reservations at 8 pm on a Saturday and as my sister stated it looked like the inside to someone DINING room I loved that it was a laid back spot. We ordered the buffalo tomato mozzarella and the rice balls for app. Generous portions. My sister loved the rice balls and I loved the salad more. Both were great. As a meal she had the Alfredo linguine and I had penne w grilled chicken. Her was spot on, I think I had higher expectations from mine but it was still tasty. We ordered desert and wrap our food to go I promise you the best teramu and cannoli u will ever have lol. Oh I ordered a bottle moscoto wine. Service was spot on and the bill was about 90 bucks .
I will definitely come here again and try something different

Well found me and Tommys just out of sheer hungar. Working not familiar with the area so I Unilocaled restaurants and called spoke to Ernesto the owner very accommodating… since they have no delivery but I drove 5 minutes to my surprise beautiful quaint quiet clean environment! Ernesto introduced himself shook my hand and gave me a deliciouse famous known to the area a rice ball with vodka fresh mozzarella smothered in vodka sauce. It was very very good, the salad was like it was just picked out of a garden green and yummy. The main entrée was penne vodka steaming hot and mouth watering. I would come again and would recommend highly.

Me and Tommy’s gets 5 stars only because that is the limit offered. This place knocked EVERY dish out of the park aps and dinners alike. It was so good in fact that I called my 75 year old parents who are big time foodies and woke them up to tell them how good it was when I got home. I have been to over a thousand restaurants in my life and have never experience a place where EVERY SINGLE DISH WAS PERFECT until last night at Me and Tommy’s.
Funny thing is that I have lived only 5 blocks away for the past 5 years and never even knew about it as they do not advertise save for a small tree obstructed roadside sign that I happened to catch while waiting for a fender bender to be cleared ahead of me the other night on the way home from work.
Hands down the BEST food flavor and quality restaurant I have ever been to and 2^nd place is not even close.

OK food for a decent price and good friendly service. I would avoid the chicken parm as the chicken is low quality and it is mostly breading and chewy chicken parts, and the spicy shrimp appetizer was good but tasted way too fishy. The rice balls are not authentic and were a bit bland and too small.

3.75, maybe 4 stars.
Me & Tommy’s is a quaint little trackside Italian joint in Belleville. You’ll find a tiny bar and a small dining area packed into what may have been an old train station. Through the kitchen window you’ll see the staff busily at work in a postage stamp-​sized kitchen.
Rice balls. The raison d’etre. If you’re a fan, well, they don’t get better than this. Rice balls, lots of cheese buoyed on top of a wonderful blush sauce. If we stopped here this review would be 5 stars. Easily.
The rest of the food is really good, too…
Saltimbocca, veal or chicken, is proper, tasty and memorable. Pork chop lovers will love the various presentations.
Bread is crusty and delicious, but butter is presented in little plastic, foil-​topped containers. Meh, and not up to par with the rest of the food.
Service by «G» is homey and terrific, though other servers/​buspersons may not be as polished. Parking is tough, so allow a few minutes to find a nearby on-​street spot. Make reservations, as Me & Tommy’s fills up fast!

I cannot say enough good things about this place! It is a small Italian restaurant which makes me love it even more! The rice balls with vodka sauce are amazing and the sauce was so good I had to order the raviolis with vodka sauce! I heard about this place from a friend and I plan on sharing it with everyone! Like a previous reviewer said — It’s a hidden gem!
On a side note — we ordered the food to go one night since my boyfriend and I were craving the rice balls and when he picked up the order, the owner thanked him because it showed him how much we enjoyed the food. To me that meant a lot! Thanks Tommy!