Pagliacci Pizza

By far the smallest slices at a Pagliacci i have ever had.

Absolutely loved every single thing we ordered! The Pagliaccio Salad with the Dijon vinaigrette dressing is to die for. We ordered their breadsticks and they are huge. They’re very good especially if you dip them in the salad dressing. I still can’t get over how great that salad dressing was. As far as pizza, we ordered half spicy chicken and half the rocket. Although they’re very different flavors, they were both really good. The pie was cooked perfectly and the ingredients were very fresh! Will definitely visit again!

probably the best pizza in seattle, and i love my pizza, try it even just their cheese is great

Pagliacci’s is an institution in Seattle. Probably the best pizza you can get around here. While it’s not on the level of what you can get in NYC, it’s as good as it gets in Washington. You can order it by the slice or sit down and order from a waitress. There’s an upstairs area too so there’s usually plenty of available tables. I dig the thin crispy crunch of their pizza dough and the tomato sauce isn’t overbearing. Conveniently located close to the mall shops and just across the skybridge from Lincoln square. Pizza’s always consistent at Pagliacci’s…

One of the best pizza places I’ve ever been too. My favorite pizza is the margarita the crust is thin but not too thin it’s taste very good not to think like a Pizza Hut. I’m a pizza expert everyone should go here

Pretty good pizza. The customer service is the best part of the experience. Angela went an ice and beyond what we expected when trying a new pizza place.

I didn’t always love you but now I do. Went back by Pag’s on Tuesday when the power went out in our area of Magnolia. The by the slice us my favorite. Tastes better than when ordering a whole pie for some reason but yeah, I love you now. $ 3.05 for a huge slice of pepperoni and a stamp card to boot. When ordering online they have deals monthly. February deal is buy one 11″ pizza, get the second for $ 6.99. Yrs, sir. See you in twenty.

Pagliacci (say it with me, Paul-​eee-​ahhch-​eee) is one of my favorite pizza joints. This is a counter joint where you can order by the pie or the slice, and it’s all self-​service like a fast food joint.
I’ve been to this location before but hadn’t returned in a couple years till last night. They’ve made changes to the service, décor and seating, but the pizza is still great. There are no servers anymore, and you order everything at the counter. You get your own dishes, silverware, napkins and beverages. They had you a cup like in a fast food joint. The only service is they’ll bring out the pie to your table. This is the same way it’s been at other locations, but this particular one use to be a full-​service restaurant.
They’ve also renovated so now there are a couple booths, two long tables with cheap plastic chairs, and a couple high seating booths. There’s also an annoying TV playing sports, but thank goodness, it was on mute so I could put my back to it and have a conversation with my boyfriend.
They’ve added the Coke machine that has 100 flavors that is quickly moving in to all fast food restaurants.
We got the veggie pizza minus onions, and it was on point. The crust at Pagliacci is thin and turns really tough by the last slices, but I’m not much of a hard bread fan to begin with. The toppings are all fresh, amazing, and the cheese was super good. We got the medium for $ 21.49 pretax.
The cashier and also the gal that brought the pizza to us were friendly.
Since this location is at Bellevue Square, parking can be hairy but it’s free and you can also park across the street by QFC or at Lincoln Square.
Food: 4
Service: 3
Parking: 4
Ambiance: 2

This place was good, and authentic. I definitely recommend this place to anybody. We will be returning to this place next time we are around the mall. Their dining room atmosphere is very clean and upbeat. And their staff can make one very good pizza.

Good choice for a pizza loving lacto-​ovo vegetarian who consumes a lot of calories. This became the first place to visit after dropping off the luggage to the hotel when I had to fly in a lot from Europe. It seems that the Pagliacci pizza has special powers in fighting off the jet lag…

We’ve had this delivered a couple times now. I can’t speak much to the atmosphere since I haven’t been there but we’re definitely fans of Pagliacci. The staff is always courteous on the phone and I like that they saved our card info. I know some people would have a problem with that, but any less hassle when you’re busy and hungry is nice. Anyway, they always under promise and way over deliver on time estimates. They’ve been here within 20 minutes every time (we’re in Old Town). The pizza is delicious with a nice sauce. The dough is a New York style, but not as thin as I usually like it. And the veggies always taste fresh. Glad to have found a nice pizza place in our new town!

The Good:
Quality ingredients, quality preparation. I had a slice of 12^th man, Quatro Primo, and Margherita. My partner had the White Bean soup and Paggliacio Salad.
Celeste H was our waitress and she gave great attention to detail when asking about gluten free options. The whole staff was very willing to change gloves and use fresh utensils and bowl when preparing the salad. They had no problem looking up ingredients used in the salad dressings and soups in order for me to make a safe choice.
The Bad:
Other customers. Big name pizza joint brings in screamers in the families that flood the place.
The Ugly:
The mess those loud kids smear on the tables.
Conclusion:
Will definitely go back. My partner can get a safe tasty gf meal and the family can eat awesome pizza all in the same place.

Nice location, great loft space to eat in. Servers were happy to divide pizzas for our large picky group. Always love pagliaccis!

It’s pizza! What could be better? And I always know what to expect from Pagliacci’s. Consistently tasty slices of yummy pizza.
This was my first time at this location but just as I thought, I got exactly what I expected. I really like the chicken primo but on this visit, I ordered the 12^th man pizza with an order of breadsticks. It was all delicious. I was surprised that the breadsticks were so fluffy and soft. I could have eaten those all night!

One of the perks of living in my apartment in West Seattle. I totes just give them a ring (super friendly peeps) and my pizza gets to me at my door within the hour. How amazing is that?! I’m pretty sure that I call them at lease once every two weeks. What can I say? I love pizza!

I am always looking for great pizza and Pagliacci has been voted best pizza in the area several different times. With so many different types of pizza, I try to judge a pizza based upon its type. With that said, the key parts of a pizza that I rate are: crust, sauce, cheese, toppings. Pagliacci did very well in 3 of the 4 areas. The sauce, cheese and toppings were VERY good. The crust by my accounting was bad to horrible. Way too hard or tough for my liking. Also, it is a quick serve restaurant instead of a full service restaurant. I do like that they have put in the new soda machines that allow you to mix syrups with your soda of choice.

I have ordered a number of pizzas from Pagliacci which are normally great and today i tried the new improved Lasagna and the Sicilian salad. The salad was so heavily seasoned with pepper I only took a few bites and threw it away. The new lasagna reminded me of a microwave dinner. It was just kind of like something you might get from the grocery store for $ 5. For $ 17 I guess I was expecting something else. Seriously bummed. Pizza 4 stars… they would be 5 if they weren’t so expensive. A small 1 star for new lasagna and 0 stars for the Sicilian salad. One of the worst things I have ever ordered.
.

Ordered The Original, a cheese pizza and a Brooklyn Bridge, a combination with pretty much everything. The pizza is a thin pizza with a thick chewy crust on the edge. I like all types of pizza but a crispy thin pizza and crust is my preference. That being said, I enjoyed this pizza. The Brooklyn Bridge pizza has plenty of toppings and tastes wonderful. The cheese pizza was terrific and the sweet and saltiness of the cheese came out. As I said earlier, I prefer a thin crust; but I enjoyed alternating bites of the chewy crust with bites of the topping filled center of the pizza.

Not a lot of the food options in Bellevue/​Lincoln Square appeal to me very much and I am not trying to wait 30 – 45 mins for a table at one of the sit down restaurants. So Pagliacci it is! I do like this location a lot, its very convienient for me if I need to get something at the mall or if I am seeing a movie. There’s never really a line the times I’ve been and always had seating for us. Easy process… order when you walk in, they are quick to get your pizza in the little oven warmer, easy to order a salad or other menu items, pay your bill and find a table to sit down.
Dining room has a good amount of tables with a few larger community tables, an upstairs area, hi-​top tables etc. They also have the neat soda dispenser machine too. (didnt know Coke made all these different flavors).
Pizza has been good each time, we usually just get a few whatever slices they have available and order a salad. It does take a few extra minutes for them to make the salads and they will bring it out to you. My favorite is the spicy chicken salad, love the spicy peppers they put in it with a good amount of chicken and a light dressing.
Remember to bus your own table! Service has been friendly up front, they are quick to wipe down tables, pick up the bus tub bin if it gets too full and all that.
Overall, I really like this place.

Maybe it’s because I’m a tourist in Bellevue, but this place was hard to find! Did anyone else have this problem?!
We had 2 adults and 1 kid, and got the cheesy garlic flatbread app (don’t know the actual name) and 2 small pizzas: the brooklyn bridge and super pepperoni.
Surprisingly, the brooklyn bridge was the winner here. The super pepperoni was tasty, but too oily and ultimately got too salty. The cheesy bread was good too.
Extra points for the coke freestyle machine and playing the Warriors playoff game!