Red Wolfe Inn

I still can’t believe how perfect the food was. The staff was great, place is a ten.

Took my son here for his 17^th birthday and racked up a nice bill. Great steaks and great service. After dinner, the waitress informed me that a random guy at the bar over heard my conversation about the birthday celebration and he paid for our dinner and tip in full. He wanted to wait until he was gone before she told us.
Great first trip to the Red Wolf Inn. Will definitely go again.
Btw, I paid it forward to a young couple w a small child. Paying for their meal would of had meaning, but sending their little boy a box of Automoblox toys had meaning and lasting memories. I’m a partner in the Automoblox company and it was my pleasure to do so.

Place is very small and a bit deceiving. Never expected the food to be as delicious as it was. Service was great as well and food was prepared quickly.

Best place for a delicious steak! Don’t be deceived by the appearance — this place is amazing!

Celebrated my Captains’s 30 th. Birthday tonight. Didt know what to expect. We were late for our dinner reservations. They were very accommodating to our plan changes. Had an
Excellent dinner. And our server Sheila was above and beyond accommodating. She was excellent. We will be back.

64 oz steak to stuffed trout, if you’re looking for creole cuisine and N’oleans ambiance– park in the rear, howl at the wolves and head on in for the best meal on 519.

Great find on RT 519. From the outside not much to look at most times it a pass by. Recommended by friends I found it to be most worthwhile. Top notch menu, decent prices, good service but great food. The ambience — well it’s rural New Jersey not NYC. Carefully when parking there is a real wolf in the back!

Had dinner on a Saturday, total 4 people. You will need reservations and carpool if you are meeting someone. Parking was limited at least in the winter with snow on the ground. We arrived at 6:00PM with 6:00 reservations and seated within 10 minutes. No room at the bar if you plan on having a cocktail while you are waiting or after dinner. Beer selection is large. I had the mussels appetizer and a ribeye steak, steak was cooked to order, nice and thick too. Baked potato was unremarkable. Salad was unremarkable, looked like bottled dressing. We were done at 7:30 and the next reservation was at 7:30. We were not rushed and had a good time. I’d go back again and recommend to a friend if asked.

This is a dive with a 99 dollar steak on the menu and one of the grossest men’s room I have seen in a long time.
I got to watch my date eat her dinner and a half hour later she got to watch me eat mine. Rookie move and caught an attitude when I asked about my sandwich.
2 stars only because of the decent beer selection.

Judging from the outside you would think wth is this place. Go inside and you think yep, I’m scared. This is a hole in the wall kind of place. A lot of locals. But, the food is amazing. Staff is super friendly. The garlic butter added to the steak is very good. This place is a must try.

Never judge a book by its cover. It looks like a dive bar from outside. World class food inside @ great prices!

Love there wing night. However the waitress we had was TERRIBLE. First she tells us they have no more wings ON WING NIGHT then after talking to a manger and getting the wing situation sorted out she NEVER came back to our table. We ran out of water and another waitress who was cleaning her tables asked us if she could get us refills. To top it off our «waitress» didn’t come back to give us out check we easily could have walked out without paying!

Whether we come for date night or family night this place has been everyone’s favorite. The staff is knowledgable and friendly!

This is a pretty cool place. If you’re within a half hour, it’s worth a nice drive through farm country to grab some decent food and cold drinks.
My friend suggested this place because he had recently been here. He said the food is pretty good and I should give it a try. We get there, and I find out that there are actual wolves out back behind the place! Like two real wolves. One barked at me. I was blown away and asked my friend why he wouldn’t tell me about the wolves before he even mentioned that they have good soup. That’s such a bigger selling point.
Anyway, the place looks like a dirty old shack from the outside. I wouldn’t have went in if my friend hadn’t been there before. Once inside, it’s a pretty nice place. It’s a little dark, and the décor is somewhere between a log cabin and a saw mill. Service was great. We went on wing night and the wings were pretty good. ($ 10.95 AYCE). Beer came out in a frozen glass which is a huge plus for me. The other food looked good and I hope I get to come back soon to give it a try. I feel like if I tried some more food, they could be bumped up to 5 stars.

Hard to find a good steak place but this is it. From the outside it looks like a biker bar and it use to be but the inside is deceiving and the food is excellent. I worked with the owner about 40 years ago in the Essex county jail, he retired and opened this place up. You have to make reservations on the weekend cause it fills up quickly but you won’t find a better steak. The other items are just as good but steak is the menu. You might even hear the wolves that are out back penned up. From the outside again, looks like a biker bar but who cares, don’t want too many people to find out about this place cause it will just get busier. Say «hello» to mike and tell him to buy the first beer… tell em that Captain Jack sent you!

They’re on the edge of glory…
Reading the reviews we were expecting great things. They were good but not great. Too much was a near miss. Salad was fresh and crispy but composed only of iceberg, carrots and tomatoes. Rolls were fresh but cold. Onion soup was delicious but lukewarm. NY strip was flavorful but medium to well, not medium rare as ordered. DH’s mushroom-​Swiss burger was perfect. French fries were okay. On the other hand the service was pleasant and accommodating and we were able to get a table for 2 on Saturday night without a reservation. Nice pub atmosphere, clearly popular with locals. Will consider giving them another try.

The best steak I’ve had in Forever !! Great service if I’m ever back this way I’ll be back !!

Awesome steaks with a great selection of bears. You would never know this place is here but I highly recommend it! A hidden gem.

Awesome. A perfect hole in the wall tavern with a great menu. 99 beers available (tap and bottles). Come hungry.

Cocktails are great and generous. The steaks are the best in the area. A lot of beers to choose from. Wolves are out in the cages in back. A local restaurant with extensive menu. High quality meat.