The Bexley Coffee Shop

Every drink I’ve had is delicious, staff is friendly & attentive. Love the drink options for kids and the weekly food trucks. Take your kids to enjoy a drink on the patio and some sidewalk chalk (there’s a basket outside).

Friendly staff, wonderful baked goods, community events, and located in an underserved part of town «just over the tracks» in Bexley but near an old industrial working-​class area of Columbus. This is one of my go-​to spots for coffee and goodies. Check them out!

Wonderful local coffee spot that always seems to be getting better! The owners are super nice and welcoming to all. Bright, fresh atmosphere, awesome outdoor seating area with a basket of chalk for the kiddos. Also, some of the best bakery items in the city made fresh every day– excellent scones, cinnamon rolls, and coffee bombs (a must-​have). Espresso drinks are well done, hot brews are nice, iced coffee is delicious and well balanced. My partner and I come here 3 times a week at least and always enjoy it!

The Bexley Coffee Shop is such a chill and enjoyable place to drink some great coffee and even enjoy a delicious quiche. The owners are so nice I could talk to them for hours. I brought my dog and they couldn’t be more dog friendly. The owner kept giving him attention and even pet him while I looked through the menu. This place is a great place to either stop in and get to go coffee or stay and relax while you sip your coffee and read a great book or study for finals. I can’t wait to go back. I love this place! Give it a try! You won’t regret it!!!

Great coffee and very friendly staff. Great to see they have added soup and other lunch stuff. We needed this place in Bexley.

The smell when you walk in the door here is worthy of five stars in itself! This is a cute little place with a delicious iced coffee and lots of seating space. It’s definitely a bit off the beaten path as far as Columbus coffee goes, but it’s a refreshing break from the pretentious coffee scene that can swallow you up closer to downtown.
This would be a great place to meet a friend or settle in to do homework. I’ll be back again soon!

Adorable atmosphere and friendly staff makes this little nugget a go-​to place for sweets, treats, and conversation! The staff and regulars are welcoming and engaging and willing to answer questions or get to know you. The sesame bagel was delicious and paired well with the French Roast coffee that the employee took the time to explain to me. Plus, I got a free refill! A great place to study or go on a date, I definitely recommend it!

Every time I call myself making a quick stop for a cup of coffee, I end up chatting it up with the owners and other patrons. It’s like Cheers but a coffee shop. A chill, cozy spot with incredible cinnamon rolls.

Bexley coffee shop is my happy place! Everyone that works there is wonderful– friendly, warm and welcoming. The grog coffee is my favorite! The owners Nikki and Maria have done a wonderful job. Love supporting our local Bexley community! Keep up the great work!

The iced coffee here is incredible! Some of the best I’ve had — and I drink a lot of coffee! The atmosphere is cute and eclectic. It is a little small so if you are here by yourself working/​studying you may feel a little awkward.

Super great prices and a chill atmosphere. I JUST moved to Bexley and will definitely be back. It’s quaint, with Italian (??) music playing quietly in the background.

I guess I should start with the good – I think the prices are super fair, great baked goods, quality coffee, cute décor, free wifi, great owners/​workers.
BUT DEAR GOD THE OTHER PEOPLE HERE. If I have to hear one more conversation about some upscale wedding/​rosh hashanah recipe exchange/​networking and resume conversation I will seriously go apeshit. I mean, I have headphones on BUT STILL. It’s starting to make me feel like maybe I’m the riff raff the other patrons want to kick out or something.
So I know they can’t help that, but be prepared for a lot of ‘ladies who lunch’ style conversation while you nosh on a great scone or piece of coffee cake.

I liked the old Bexley Coffee Shop. But I *love* the new one.
There might be some similarities between the two businesses (the location, the name), but I can assure you they are very different. The previous BCS was a great coffee shop if you were in the neighborhood. The new one is here to compete with the big dogs.
Here’s what I’m loving:
+They serve Thunderkiss coffee, which is delicious.
+They have a fantastic selection of teas, and they even make their own chai concentrate! I’ve had it, and it’s legit.
+They make their own treats, and they are gorgeous! They are even so thoughtful to make a handful of gf goodies. I’ve tried a few, and they are all really good. I’ve also heard their Saturday-​morning cinnamon rolls are a foodgasm.
+They use many local ingredients.
+The staff is phenomenal. Everyone is super friendly and personable, and the baristas make some kick-​ass drinks.
+The interior is super cute and cozy. It’s perfect for catching up with a friend, having a business meeting, or logging onto their free wifi and getting some work done.
The Bexley Coffee Shop is a local business I’m proud to support: good people, great products, and a comfortable environment. What’s not to love?!
Pro tip: They even have some outdoor seating when the weather is nice!

Y’all know the story of the chicken who crossed the road? But have you ever heard of the chicken that plucks her way into a coffee shop? So here comes a chicken (of course in a fake costume) who plucks her way into the Bexley Coffee Shop and the owners make nothing of it.
Little did we know she was coming to profess her love to my friend! She was so hilarious I would hire her to come do a party for me soon! First I give props to the Bexley coffee shop for making nothing out of this since it was hilarious! Next I would like to say how impressed I was with this girl in the costume who braved coming in here for us to entertain us for 5 minutes. We found out she’s a fashion designer and this is not her only costume she dresses into.
Thank you Bexley Coffee Shop for not only having the best coffee and beverages in town but area to openly have entertaining meetings!

A wonderful coffee shop with yummy drinks and house-​made baked goods. A perfect example of why we love living in Bexley!

Another good coffee option here that got tested today. Just right. Also had a brownie type cookie, not actually a brownie which was quite good. Neat little café with good food options.

I adore the reboot of the Bexley Coffee Shop. They carry Thunderkiss, one of my favorite local coffee roasters, and their own house-​made baked goods. They usually do something extra special on Saturday mornings — like cinnamon rolls — so even if you don’t live in the area, it’s worth the drive out to try them.
The owners are delightful people who obviously care a ton about the community and customer service.

The old Bexley Coffee Shop was already pretty good, but every time I come here under the new ownership, it just seems to get better.
There used to be a vague cafeteria feel to the space, but it’s been getting cozier by the month, with homey art on the walls, just enough couchy type seating, soft not-​quite-​pastels in the color scheme. And Nikki and Maria bring their own warmth to the business.
The last time I was there, Nikki was baking up some fresh-​made granola, and when it was done, she brought it right to my table, still warm, with soy milk on the side. I mean, it’s not like I didn’t order it, but it was just like this place to be getting it straight out of the oven.
There are a couple of gluten-​free options among the baked goods. It’ll be nice if they’re able to accommodate more vegan options, as well, as they feel out their clientele (the day I got the granola, I had ordered oatmeal, but they said they’d just stopped carrying it because it wasn’t selling; granola was actually my fallback… but mmm, what a tasty fallback).
If you come in and sit down for a while, expect to be surrounded by conversation, if not with you then all around you. The atmosphere is friendly and inviting but not intrusive; I’ve gotten hours of work done there.

One of the best local coffee stores in Columbus! Love it love it and love it!
Anyone visits here must try the bakeries!
And the owners are super friendly and enthusiastic! Definitely make you feel you’ve been friends for a long time!
Strongly recommend to visit!

This was my first time visiting Bexley Coffee Shop, and I loved it! If you want a relaxing, welcoming place to stop, this is the coffee shop for you.
My husband and I tried a regular coffee, one medium, one dark roast. Great taste, very smooth. We had our toddlers with us, and the woman behind the counter thoughtfully offered us to go cups with lids in case we had to make a quick exit.
My kids chose a chocolate chip cookie bar. They loved it. I tried it and thought it was rich, buttery, and tasty. Not too sweet. Just right. Mmm! (There was also a gluten free variety.) Best part of it all though? The owner went and grabbed a plastic plate for our cookie so our kids didn’t have to worry about breaking anything. Awesome!
I’m definitely a huge fan. Stellar, friendly service, delicious treats, great coffee.

Cute little place! I love their new look and logo. Columbus needed a coffee shop with a feminine touch. I ordered a soy latte and it was very tasty. Very friendly staff as well, I’m going to try and make it a point to stop in more often and try some pastries!

The «new» Bexley Coffee Shop is awesome! Super friendly owners, great food (the coffee bombs are the Bomb!) and smoothies, and the atmosphere is small town and cozy feeling. It’s our new go to spot for after school snacks and a knitting hang out.