Island Pizza

Following a recommendation from a fellow staff member, we thought we’d give Island a try. This was our first stab and trying to find a new favorite pizza place after moving to this area. Well, the service was great, the beer selection was fabulous but the pizza was meh. The trek for the best pizza continues BUT will take advantage of their great beer selection!

I pass this place often and always see cars there, so I thought I’d give it a try for lunch. The pizza was tasteless and the French fries were unsalted and bland. I will not stop here again.

Not quite sure why there are so many negative reviews. My family and I have been here 5 – 7 times in the last year and have never had any issues. We usually order pizza, cheese steaks (or chicken cheese steaks), fries and wings. I have two MINOR complaints; 1. Orange juice is not the good kind 2. for the price of the cheese steaks they should come with chips or fries. Other then that love it!

Pizza good. Use them for a quick six pack of some hard cider or hard Ice tea. Convenient, just wish they didn’t run out of items so frequently.

The food is too expensive and not as good as it used to be. My son and I ate in and we got a sandwich to go and with a tip it was $ 50. That’s rediculous!

Horrible customer service. The past 2 times we’ve ordered take out, our order has been wrong. My husband called to let them know that there was an issue and the manager hung up on him.

We ordered a plain pizza and fries with mozerella, bacon and ranch dressing then looked at the previous Unilocal reviews. The reviews were all over the place and we began to think that maybe we should have tried a different place to eat. Well, let me tell you the Pizza was GREAT! Melted in your mouth. The fries were good too. Pizza was $ 10.50 and fries 6.00. The service was good, fun atmosphere, and a guitar player. There’s a separate bar area. The place was busy for a week night. Good for families. When we are back in the area, we won’t hesitate to stop in for a pizza!

Went in on a whim for food was pleasantly surprised to see a selection of 25 taps featuring craft beer.
I got a pepperoni stick and a slice of stuffed pizza from the pizza side and had a couple drafts at the bar.
Quick service friendly staff. Highly recommend if your passing on 422

With all due respect to the previous reviewers, this was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Period. A chicken cheesesteak pizza with cheap canned «cheese» sauce put on top? Ugh.
The nachos were disgusting, which should have been a «tell» for what was coming later.
The waitress was very nice, but even her service couldn’t save this from being a 1 star review.
Drive the extra 10 minutes and go to Giovanni’s. You’ll be glad you did.

Great place to eat after climbing at birdsboro! Solid wide-​ranging menu (think pizza, cheesesteaks, fries, etc.), friendly staff, and even a decent beer selection (Troegg’s Hopback was on special last time I believe.)
You can choose from multitudes of toppings on your pizza, and order either whole pies or pre-​made slices. I had a personal wheat pizza with lots of veggie toppings and it was quite tasty. The loaded chicken cheesesteak (peppers, onions, marinara sauce) is good too. And I wouldn’t call this place expensive (maybe for just plain pizza) — i’ve always gotten a meal and soda for under $ 10.
In the city or more populated area this place might only get 3 stars, but out in the middle of nowhere it’s a solid 4.

Pizza is good. A little pricey but you can’t get the toppings at other shops.

Good pizza, but expensive. Try the boardwalk pizza.
Cool little bar inside called Fins. I heard they have some good bands play there.