Mafiaoza’s Birmingham

I discovered this place in Nashville and was told it was also in Birmingham to my happy surprise. It is tucked away on a side street just to keep it a secret.
The pizza has fantastic crust and great sauce. Servers are on top of things and know the huge beer and wine selection.
Lots of TVs if you want to see a game.
I had The Mark tonight. It was FAnTASTic!!! The sauce was heaven. A pesto cream sauce kept me from having to decide between Alfredo and Pesto. Just smash ‘em together. The Sundried tomatoes balanced the salty sauce with a sweetness that couldn’t tear me away.

Great value if you’re looking for pizza, but there is much better pizza in Birmingham. If you’re seeking pizza that’s absolutely top notch, I would recommend Slice or Post Office Pies. Also, it’s typically very loud. Don’t expect to be heard across the table very well.

We met up on a Wednesday night with some friends for dinner and drinks at the nearby pizza joint down from our street. My wife and I have actually been to this location about 5 times now and each time we like it even more.
One of the best parts to me are the daily specials they have going on. I hear Tuesday is the best deal with BOGO slices, but I haven’t been there for Tuesday yet. I can’t complain however because Wednesday was Wine Wednesday with $ 5 house wine or $ 15 house bottles. It is one of the best Wine Wednesday’s in the city as far as I am concerned.
I would recommend taking the family here as it is family friendly. We will definitely be back! On a side note, only order 1 slice if you are moderately hungry as they will fill you up.
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
Review update:
We went again Wednesday 3÷16÷2016 with a group of 5 of us and weren’t disappointed like always. I already have them rated as a 5* in my book but would go higher if possible. We met the manager, Patrick, and he was world class in introducing himself and making us feel welcomed.
Word has it that they are going to throw a Maf-​fest around May 6^th and will close Dexter down for it. Live bands and such are expected.

Great environment and great food. We came with a large group and they were very gracious in accommodating us. The pizza was terrific. I thought some of the pizzas were a little lacking in toppings, but that may just be due to my preference of topping-​heavy pizza. Overall, a great restaurant. Will definitely try to stop by again when we are back in Birmingham.

Friend suggested going here on a rainy Tuesday night for the BOGO slice deal. I figured folks would be staying home in torrential downpour (ok. it actually wasn’t torrential. but Alabama drivers + any kind of rain = not good). but I digress.
Finding a place to park was a challenge. And given that this place is across the street from an Iron Tribe, i was petrified that i was gonna hit the randos running in the middle of the street. in the dark. in the now misty rain.
But once I found a spot halfway across town (not really. but it felt like it), I arrived and this place was popping! Had to wait a few minutes for a table by the bar.
Waitress was super attentive, and our drinks were always replenished. She messed up my order (forgot the mushrooms), but I wasn’t gonna make a fuss about 60 cents. But just something to keep in mind if you order some of the fancier toppings. Will def. be back here for this special… though I may wait until later in the evening once the crowds die down and parking opens up. :)

First and last time here. Super slow service, over priced beers and pizza just ok. Later…

I have had many great experiences at Mafiaoza’s in the past. But this last experience was certainly below par. There is a chain pizza place near our house that we will typically do if we want carry-​out pizza. But this past Sunday, we wanted the comfort of home and a step up on the pizza game. So we ordered carry out from here.
We order The Tony (Cheese Bread with Feta) and The Associate (pepperoni). The pizza is one of their plain ones. But a good compromise for my wife and me. When I got the pizza home, there was one half of the pizza that looked burned and black on the top. Not the entire half, but a good portion of it. And of course if it is like that on the top, the bottom was very charred on most of the pizza. It was on the brink of inedible. I find it very hard to believe that the person making the pizza looked at this and thought it was up to Mafiaoza’s typical standard. If we were in the restaurant, it would have been sent back. I am really hoping that this was just an oversight and not just sent out because it was a to-​go order. I would much rather have to sit and wait for another pizza to be cooked than a swift in and out with this quality. The cheese bread was pretty good and that is what bumps this up to a 2.5 star review.
With the other experiences we have had, another trip is in order. But for now, this will be my current review after a very disappointing experience.

I went to Mafiaoza’s tonight to indulge in their 2 for 1 special. Little did I know that 1 piece of pizza would cost 10 $. I cannot begin to fathom how you calculate that pricing because in the price point case here the same pizza would be 80 some odd dollars. Really a great way to rip off customers. The food is good but unless you have on the reading glasses of a 90 year old who is legally blind, then you won’t see this absurd covenant on the menu. Our server failed to inform us the deal was only on pizzas that had basically nothing except cheese and tomato sauce. Weird that she did that hmmm… Overall I feel this was a pretty poor experience. She even seemed to lose words when I clearly demonstrated the absurdity of the situation. I would pay $ 31.50 for 3 pieces of pizza in an alternate universe but unfortunately I’m still here. Wow! Diogornio does the same thing for way better value.

Tuesday nights are the best night to visit MAFIAoZA’s. We love the ‘two for one’ pizza slices. They have a nice patio with lots of seating.

Grading the pizza here. The pizza that I got was not particularly good, but I see the potential here. Ordered it late and had it delivered by grub hub, so I suspect they did a rush job on it. The crust is paperthin, which is my preference. Probably will go with the extra cheese next time. Also got the dry wings. Decent, but nothing to write home about.

Great dinner at MAFIAoZas. I think one of the best outdoor dining areas in Birmingham and covered so if a stray rain storm hits, you are good! Plenty of TV’s inside and out to watch your favorite game. Service was excellent with nice servers and bartenders.
Food wise, you really can’t go wrong. I have been here multiple times and never been disappointed. Plus you can get one slice with any topping rather than a whole pie if it is just two of you. Great wine selection too!
Kid and dog friendly. Definitely one of my favorite dining destinations. Highly recommended!

This is a great pizza/​pasta place with a fun atmosphere. The Davinci pasta was piping hot and delicious. My husband went with pizza and got the Teamster, which was pretty much perfect. The meats were cooked perfectly and the crust was crispy. We also shared the Tony for an appetizer, and we will definitely get it when we go back. It was everything that cheesy bread should be, and you get three dipping different sauces to try.
We went on a Saturday when they were doing $ 5 margaritas, which was nice. It could’ve been a little stronger, but we were happy with it for $ 5.
Finally, our server was friendly and we didn’t have to wait on a table, so we’ll back. You can also enjoy sitting on the patio if it’s not too hot for you.

My cousin brought me here when a friend of hers suggested it because of its gluten free pizza options. I’ve had the same GF crust at other pizza places (not sure what brand) but it was really good with «The Greek» toppings.
It has a good sized patio outside, great for cooler weather. The interior has an open view of the kitchens pizza oven and a very clear «mafia» theme and décor. Great place for families or groups.

I love the neighborhood and family friendly vibe going here as well as the location. It’s really nice to stroll around Crestline Village after dinner! The pizza is always delicious and I’m a big fan of their salads. We have watched a sports game here on a few occasions and had a lot of fun.
That being said, the service has always been the downfall. On two separate occasions it has taken us nearly 15 minutes to get our drinks and our appetizers took nearly 45 minutes. I understand the wait for the pizza but not a side salad and garlic knots.
However, I would still recommend Mafiaoza’s for large groups, families, and a great place to eat on the patio because theirs is huge! And all of the pizzas I’ve had have been fantastic.

Love the pizza and the atmosphere my family and I eat here often. They always have drink specials happy hour and a great selection beers (which I dont drink) Every pizza I’ve tried has been extremely delicious! Their fried ravioli and salad are great. Staff is very polite and friendly. Have seen families eat here in large groups during sporting events. If you love pizza you must give them a visit!

Just came for daughters birthday dinner. Amazing food, good service and incredible atmosphere. Feels like family.

Mafiaoza’s is a fun Italian restaurant located in Crestline Village. On Tuesdays they have half-​priced pizza and beer which is especially nice. In fact, it’s so nice that those are the only times I’ve visited Mafiaoza’s. It is clear that I am not the only one who enjoy’s going on Tuesdays because there is usually some waiting involved, however this waiting isn’t so bad when you consider they have a two man soft-​rock/​jazz band and a bar to kill some time. As for the pizza, the slices are large and tasty and I always end up leaving with leftovers. Also, most of the items on the menu have mafia names such as the informant, the associate, etc.
Perhaps one day I will visit when its not half-​price pizza and beer, but until then I will continue to enjoy my Tuesday night tradition.

After living in Birmingham for over a year and searching high and low… I have finally found the REAL New York Style Pizza!
Mafiaoza’s is tucked down a side street in Mountain Brook and well worth the ride from Hoover.
I decided to get the plain cheese pizza to get the real flavor of the pizza and I was amazed how much I felt like I was back in New York!
Everything about the pizza was delicious! I had to stop myself at 2 slices.
Mafiaoza’s just go 2 new customers!

Been in Birmingham for two years.
FINALLY!
Found the best pizza in the area. The quest has ended.
Over two years of sampling conveyor belt pizza,
pizza made on pre-​formed dough, with sauce from a can… ugh
THIS IS NOT THAT PLACE!
They have the right ovens, the right dough, the right cheese.
Oh Pizza Gods thanks for bringing MAFIAoZA’s to Birmingham!
I have suffered so, pizzas cut into postage stamp size squares. UGH!
Pizza with burnt cheese oh Lord!
MAFIAoZA’s pizza is as close to any pizza you could get in New York.
They use Bakers Pride deck ovens, heated to 600+ degrees with the right cheese.
Soft thin crust rescues me from the garbage that is passed off as pizza in this town.
Lightly charred crust, oh how I have missed you!

There’s a lot more than just pizza here! However, that’s what I came here for and got half Thompson and half All Hail Caesar but with alfredo sauce. Don’t get the All Hail Caesar. There’s not much going on here. However, the Thompson is carb hell made in a pizza pie. They had the nerve to cut up steak fries and use that as toppings. It’s delicious and needs to be eaten fresh.
The atmosphere of the restaurant is really lovely. It’s way nicer than any pizzeria I’ve been to. Their outdoor seating is what had me sold.
Refrigerator Test: Absolutely tasteless. Don’t do it.