Pizza Shoppe

The exterior of the building is Modern Spanish Non-​descript, but the interior screams 1967. If you are familiar with the West Coast’s Round Table pizza chain, so is Pizza Shoppe. There is even a decorative suit of armor in the dining area. Awesome! The dining area is also larger than one would expect from the outside, and there is a HUGE banquet room with coin-​op games. This is definitely the kind of place you go with your soccer team for the season-​ender.
I arrived near closing time, but the staff remained amiable and outgoing until slightly past closing time. In fact, the manager, who waited on my table, and kitchen workers were still chatty as I paid to leave. They certainly placed the customer first here.
Pink sauce? The workers’ uniforms advertise it; the front counter displays it for sale; and the menu has a nice blurp promoting it as well. Frankly, it tastes like French dressing, but it is a positively non-​food grade of industrial, Pepto Bismol pink. My dining companion likened it to strawberry yogurt, but there is no description that would truly encapsulate pink sauce. It is a phenomenon that you just must try.
As for the pies, Pizza Shoppe is generous with the cheese. You might consider a smaller pie than you are thinking. The specialty pies are slightly askew of the mainstream chains but not outlandish. They are probably the same combinations the chain has been serving for forty-​five years and will continue ad infinitum. It ain’t broke, folks.
I was slightly disappointed with the garlic cheese bread which really is bread; it is mounds of cheese on slices of toast. I would have preferred more garlic. Mileage may vary.
For the price, this place is tremendous.

I had been driving by this place for a couple of years and never really thought of stopping. A coworker recommended it and after reading the good reviews it was worth giving this place a shot. It is a chain out of Missouri/​Kansas and people there apparently love it. I ordered the butcher block pizza and it was great. Five of us couldn’t even finish it. Very dense with cheese and meat toppings that were really flavorful. One of the best pizzas I have had since living in Tulsa. The pizzas are not cheap, but you get what you pay for at this place. Easily a solid four stars. They also have toasted subs and salads.

I love the food hate the service.

We always enjoyed Pizza Shoppe when we lived in Kansas City, and were thrilled to discover the Bixby, OK location. This location appears to be family-​run, and it feels good to support a family-​run operation. The staff were tremendously friendly and attentive to all the guests that came through the door.
Second, the pizza was a classic Pizza Shoppe offering! We had a large king pizza topped with pork sausage. The pizza was perfectly cooked and they did not skimp on the toppings. I suppose the only disappointment, however slight, would be the cheese bread. It appeared to be Texas toast topped with melted mozarella cheese. It is an appetizer that falls short in satisfaction compared to the top-​notch pizza.
It can be argued among pizza-​goers that the décor is dated. While I would agree, I found it nostalgic and comforting. The décor at the Bixby location is very similar to the Kansas City location I frequented as a kid growing up. Knight’s armor, midevel references, arcade games, red carpet, etc. I can just see me and my 5^th grade basketball team sitting at a big table pigging out on pizza wearing our nut-​hugger basketball shorts. Good times.
All in all, a quality product served by a nice, hard-​working family. When looking for a casual saturday lunch to satisfy a serious pizza craving, who could ask for more?.

Good pizza. I was pleasantly surprised. I always do carryout — so I’m never subject to the (allegedly) bad service.

There was a pizza shoppe in Kansas City where I lived, and it’s good to see Bixby has one. Great pizza, better than Pizza Hut, or mazzios, or hide away.

Great pizza, certainly different. Always thin crust, which is okay. Minus 3 stars for staff that just doesn’t give a rip.