Sunday’s

The hard ice creams were ok, but the softserve, I guess it’s frozen yogut, tasted smoky or like plastic, or burnt. My grandaughter mentioned that she hated to say it, but the vanilla softserve was very bad., she was right. I definately won’t be going there again

Way Overpriced & My Ice Cream was Old!
I went there for the first time tonight with my boyfriend. He got a large cup of coffee ice cream which was good. I ordered a sugar cone of Double Chocolate Almond flavored ice cream and it tasted like freezer burn. The tub was probably sitting in there since last summer. I threw the cone out the window on the way home. It wasn’t worth the calories. Hopefully some hungry birds ate it. Lol. The price was ridiculous too! $ 8.5X for a cup and a cone?! We could have bought 2 half gallons for that price. I will never return.

Sunday’s is a brightly painted ice cream parlor/​sandwich shop that sits on northbound Rt. 206 in Bordentown, NJ. On a hot late September afternoon it seemed to call me as I drove back to the office after a late lunch nearby.
Inside it felt like I was in Candyland. So many pastels that it slightly distorted reality, much like being in an arcade in a carnival. I did not see anyone at first which added to the sensation, but I soon heard a female voice toward the back of the shop telling me she would be ‘right with you, honey.‘
This gave me a moment to bend closer to the ice cream display under the glass of their refrigeration units. More color literally melting into each other. When the owner/​manager arrived she was friendly and solicitous. I asked if the ice cream was made by them, and learned that it was produced by Richman’s Dairy. There was also a premium label that was gluten free.
I asked for a small cup of Pumpkin and Peanut Butter Ripple which came in under $ 5. They weren’t big scoops, but certainly enough for a pleasant afternoon delight. The taste was pretty much middle of the road. The Peanut Butter was somewhat creamy with amply streaks of peanut butter mixed into the vanilla. I liked it. The Pumpkin was a bit too cold and had the texture of tiny pumpkin flavored ice crystals. It clearly needed more defrost time from whatever deep freeze it has been in before going into the display. The flavor was there, but the creaminess had not returned. I guess I was a few hours too early.
Sunday’s is a pleasant place, and kids must certainly love all the colors. Lunch is also prepared there, as is soft serve ice cream in summer.
I could see myself stopping in again to sample both.

Ice cream for breakfast? Sure, why not. It was the small size, and I do mean small. As the only customer here at 11 am (they open at 10) I think they could have at least filled up the small cup. Two flavors were sampled, chocolate which was indistinguishable from Breyer’s and a salted pretzel caramel that was slightly better. I asked who makes the ice cream and the person at the counter did not know. That pretty much sums up the place. This business does food catering and they probably use this location to prepare the food. I would only recommend it if you are unfamiliar with the area and are driving by before noon. Barely 3 Unilocal (because it is ice cream after all)

I wanted to like this place, I really did. The exterior was adorable and inviting from the highway. Unfortunately I was disappointed by flavor and price. I ordered a small vanilla soft serve with sprinkles. The service was fast and friendly (giving an extra star). However, the cup was $ 5, which was surprising. This is Bordentown, not Manhattan. I was hoping to justify with the taste but unfortunately the soft serve was not creamy at all but rather gritty.

Very nice place with decent ice cream. They sell quite a bit of «other merchandise» in the store which kind of detracts from the ice cream side of going here, but with other choices relatively nearby they need to make money somehow. I like the place and will continue to go here, but just won’t go out of my way to go. Have to be in the neighborhood to stop.

Sunday’s is one of the best ice cream stores I have ever been to. I always feel bright and cheery when I go there because of the funky décor that Debbie has used! Every time I go I love that she has something new whether it be fruit smoothies, new sundaes, or better yet new merchandise to buy! She always has the cutest little gifts that I can pick up on a whim for a birthday present or whatever I might need!
You definitely need to go!!!

This place has been around for a very long time. Ice cream is good and there are endless choices. It is, however, located on the side of a major road. not exactly your neighborhood ice cream paler.
If I am in the area, I do stop by. Otherwise I stick to the ice cream shop closer to home.