Felcaro Pizzeria

Convenient location. The pizza is decent. Nothing to write home about. Literally the only thing in Beacon Hill with any kind of late night food though.

Unbelievably rude. That’s the only way I can describe our interactions with their employees. We were long time customers, and when my significant other asked for less cheese and more broccoli on her pizza, she was practically verbally assaulted over the phone. We thought this was a one time event, and then it happened again. Once is a bad employee, two is bad business.
If you want a pizza place that values you as a customer, don’t go here. Felcaro pizza doesn’t care about anything other than your money.

After club hours spot for pizza. This place is pretty hoppin. Best thing to do is call ahead. You gotta try their bbq pizza it is delish, margharita pizza also delish with fresh ricotta. You cannot come here for the plain old cheese pizza cuz once you’ve had their specialty pizza’s u won’t even think about the plain old boring cheese. Forget about it «Robert Dinero voice» looking at the reviews I’d have to say your special !

Ordered delivery during our stay at the Marriott Long Wharf… just a random selection based on Unilocal reviews and location. What a great decision, absolutely the best pizza! The price was right but more importantly the pizza was perfect.

This is some great pizza. I lived just up the street from this place and they became my go to. Upper crust is good too, but after all their management kerfuffles I have decided not to give them my money anymore. Besides, Felcaro makes a better pizza AND has pretty good sandwiches too. I really wasn’t expecting much. There is a «boston style» of pizza that in my opinion is just terrible. Basically bad bread with sauce on it. So I expected more of the same from Felcaros. NOT SO. Felcaro delivers a pizza slice that would make most New Yorkers proud. There isn’t too much oregano in the sauce and they don’t skimp on the cheese. It’s just super delicious. AND they make an extra large, which is enough for at least four meals.

Great late night pizza !!! When you first walk in looks like a dive, but I must say the pizzas really good and not greasy. We got a large Greek pizza and a cheese pie. Both were good.

The pizza here is solid. The crust is medium thickness, not paper-​thin like a cracker and not «pizza hut”-style thick. Pizza here is cheesy and gooey but not greasy, and the sauce is great. I highly recommend it, and the price is reasonable!

Pizza by the slice is quick, cheap and yummy. The pizza was definitely on the oily side, but I don’t expect this place to be super health conscious

Good bbq chicken sub. First time trying this place and I enjoyed it. Reasonably priced.

My go-​to pizza spot, and not only because it’s down the street from me. The pizza has good dough, the right amount of grease, and some good sauces; the sides are a good bang for the buck, but every extra topping is $ 2 even if it’s just simple garlic or onions. The guys who run the shop are all good people, though.
Overall this place is nothing fancy or special, but what they make they make well.

We called and asked about delivery, which is supposed to be offered (staying in a hotel 1.6 miles away) and were told it was far, they were busy, etc. so my husband said we would pick it up instead and the employee said that’s good, and hung up. Without taking our order. At that point I would have called somewhere else, but given the time there weren’t many options. I called back to order and the person asked me to wait, then he was talking to other people, I couldn’t tell when he was talking to me and when he wasn’t. I said what I wanted, he said 20 minutes, and hung up. Didn’t ask for a name, confirm the order, nothing. When we got there they were busy with the bar crowd, they do sell pizza by the slice when you go in. The food was ok. Nothing great. The curly fries were dry and didn’t taste very fresh. The buffalo chicken pizza was good. I don’t know if I would order from here again.

This place hits the pizza spot. Great to bring back to your room after doing the tourist thing.

We ordered food for delivery via their OFFICIAL WEBSITE. Our card was charged & we received a confirmation email. 1.5 hours later we called to see why the order was taking so long… And we were told they did not deliver «to Dorchester — too far». WTF
We are on Dorchester Ave in South Boston less than 2 miles away from the restaurant!
We asked them to refund our credit card since they would not deliver it even when we explained we were not in Dorchester. Why they couldn’t call us & tell us in the first place or design their website to only take orders from their bizarre range — who knows.
Additionally, it has now been 2 weeks and our credit card was never refunded. Time to dispute the charges with Discover.
Two thumbs down!

I give you as many stars as I can give you I would love to give you some more. I’ve been coming to a pizza place for years and it’s always tasty and delicious. You want to good piece of pizza or pie make sure you check this place you will love it

I don’t get to go here often because of the distance, but it seems like the ownership has changed hands since the last time I was in here (maybe a year and a half ago).
The new owners are very friendly and happy to help so I have no qualms with that. Unfortunately, they used turkey bacon on my bacon cheeseburger sub which just isn’t cool with me. This is the third different place that has done this to me in the area now. Only in the city have I encountered this. I like turkey bacon, but just not on subs, it has no crisp texture and the flavor isn’t fully there. It belongs next to eggs and hash browns, not on subs or pizza.
Anyways, my sub is mostly okay, but a bit on the pricey side. I understand since the area is expensive though. I plan on going back and re-​trying the pizza, but for now, this place is just okay in my book.

Oh my god the best pizza!!! Get the buffalo chicken pizza when it’s the slice of the day :)

Feeling stressed and going through pizza withdrawals, I decided to cheat on my diet and get a slice [okay, two slices]. I work across the street at MGH, so this is one of the closer pizza joints in the area. I haven’t been here in almost a year, but I’m pretty sure the pizza was better last time.
Today I got the slice of the day, buffalo chicken, and a slice of plain cheese. The buffalo chicken pizza was really greasy and didn’t taste like buffalo sauce at all. It was drizzled with ranch or blue cheese dressing. Couldn’t tell which because everything was just «blah». I ate half of that and moved on to the slice of cheese.
I was annoyed to find that most of the cheese was stuck to a paper plate that was used to hold the buffalo chicken slice. I wish I had the foresight to ask for the slices to be packaged separately. However, I think they should have known that would happen and packaged it separately to begin with. The slice of cheese was a combination of blah and meh. I ate half of that one as well and then threw in the towel.
This pizza is okay in a pinch, but not worth sabotaging your diet over. Next time I’ll ignore my cravings and wait until I get home to order from my favorite shop.

Quick, convenient, cheap. Open super late. I’m not one to judge pizza, but when I’m starving at 3am this is the place.
Right across from mgh. Right around the corner. Decent pizza.
The slices are big. They heat up the pizza slices for you. Plenty of options, including calzones, are available to go.
Not my first choice for pizza, but definitely a good one based on ease.

We were at Liberty Hotel for our Spring Formal and wanted some food! A friend suggested this place so we walked over. There were a decent number of people here around 1 but as it got later more and more people came in.
I had a slice of the pepperoni pizza. It was 3 something but I just tipped the change it cost me $ 4. This pizza was NOT WORTH $ 4. It was cold, greasy, lacked flavor, oh and did I mention COLD? This place gets a decent amount of traffic through late at night and I get served a $ 4 slice of cold pizza? Disappointing… I’ve def had better. Not sure what everyone is raving about.

Cheese cheese cheesey cheese goodness. One of the greatest things about Felcaro’s s
Felcaro’s is its one of the few places in Boston open late night on weekends. Comparatively it’s also one of the worst things about Felcaro’s. On a regular weekend night it has a line out the door with drunken mobs and only sells slices and full pies, a smart way to keep the line moving quickly.
Outside of the hectic weekend nights, Felcaro’s is a pretty average pizza joint. Nothing too fancy on the pizza menu and they also do some gigantic grinders and cold subs. Their standout dish is definitely their calzones. If you love cheese, this is your haven. Order a cheese calzone with ricotta and parmesan and thank me later.