Kenmore Collectibles

These guys are fantastic, exactly what you’re looking for when trying to do business in a domain you don’t know as much about. I went in here to sell some gold coins my father had given me years ago, as well as some older *not* gold coins, which had been part of his collection. I had done my superficial internet research (i.e. Ebay) to find out what things could sell for, but I was really in over my head. These guys were friendly, efficient, not at all pushy, and explained each coin’s value to me (even when that value was almost nothing). They then offered to buy the lot for an extremely fair price. And, they threw in free tickets to that night’s Red Sox game to boot (a patron was unable to go to the game and gave them the tickets, and they couldn’t go either, so they paid it forward to me. They probably don’t get this opportunity every day, so don’t get too excited!). :) I highly recommend selling here if you have coins or collectibles you’d like to unload, and if you’re looking to buy something specific, chances are these guy have it. Great place to do business, great experience, thanks guys!

Wow! This place was amazing. If you have a guy you need to buy a gift for that likes sports (especially Boston sports), then this is the place to find an awesome, unique gift. I will definitely be coming back.

It was several years ago when I went here, but they were fantastic, super helpful and found the item I was looking for with ease and grace and affordability.
I wanted to buy my dad a special birthday gift for his 60^th and that meant hunting for the first ever Sport Illustrated. I didn’t have the time to learn how to find it myself, so I figured this was probably the best place to go. It was. I highly recommend them to anyone who needs a collectible.

We recently sold a group of silver coins to Kenmore collectibles. My experience here was excellent with Mike providing very professional and gentlemanly advice. Their offer was quite fair and I would not hesitate to recommend them. We definitely plan on doing business with them again.

My fiancé comes here every week. No matter who stops in, Mike and Peter are always friendly and welcoming. They are down to earth and really enjoy what they do.

I sold my coin collection here, and they gave me a fair price, and also told me when something wasn’t worth money, and why. The whole collection sold quite close to what I expected to get for it, and I was more than happy to pay a little extra to not deal with the hassle of eBay or Craigslist or selling things by mail. The shop is about ²⁄₃ baseball cards and sports memorabilia, and ¹⁄₃ coins. I’d definitely come back for any future coin transactions.

Mike and Pete are great guys, the deals on coins and cards are all very reasonable compared to all of the other collectibles stores in the area. They also sell paper money and gold/​silver.

The guys who work here are friendly and smart. They also gave me a good price on the silver coins that I sold. I had a good experience and will return.

I needed cash for an emergency and I needed it sooner rather than later. I finally decided to sell my mom’s silver coin collection but I was nervous. I had tried to do this a few times before but each time the amount I was being offered was extremely low. I don’t know much about coins but I knew what I had and how much I should be getting. Based on Sarah A. review, I found these guys and I could not have been more please with my experience!
They treated me with respect and were amiable. They talked TO me not down to me. Best of all, they gave me a fair, market rate (listed every day on their website) and did not try to «nickel and dime» me — sorry for the pun.
I will be back when if I ever need to sell the rest of my collection.

I go here once in a while to buy supplies for my cards. The two guys are very friendly and knowledgeable. I have had some questions about cards and each time they both were very helpful and did not seem to mind spending time with me talking about the cards. Great customer service and a nice little card shop too. They also have coins but I have no idea about coins as I am not a coin collector. I would recommend this shop to people who collect baseball cards and coins.

I have been an online customer of Kenmore Collectibles for many years. Recently I was in Boston and had a chance to visit their store near Fenway Park.
They have a great selection of Boston sports collectibles (bruins, Celts and Red Sox) including game jerseys and great signed photos. Mike and Peter are extremely knowledgeable, very helpful and totally no pressure. I recommend them totally.

A big ripoff. Brought some gold in and wisely decided not to sell. Was offered $ 100.00! Went to Jeweler’s Building downtown and got $ 300.00 for the same gold. Also, the only guy at the counter continued to speak on the phone for about 10 minutes after I entered the store, and the conversation was about the most vapid I have ever overheard. Again, the place is a ripoff. Stay away!

Great selection of boxes, singles and coins. The owner is nice and prices are reasonable. Overall one of the best card shops in Boston.

This cozy shop is near BU and Fenway Park and if you are looking to buy or sell coins, trading cards, or other memorabilia I wouldn’t go anywhere else. The owners are very welcoming and willing to spend as much time with you as you need. I worked with Mike to price a small coin collection, and he was very patient and fair in his evaluation; he’s someone I really trusted to handle the transaction.
Be sure to bring a treat for Dodger the Dog!

I sold some old coins here. They were fair in the sale and gave me just a little less that what I think I would have gotten for them on eBay. I was okay with that since selling on eBay is such a hassle. The staff member who I sold my coins to was friendly and professional and did not have that unpleasant air of «eww, here comes another person trying to sell something» that I’ve experienced at other stores offering to buy items. I would definitely recommend this store if you’re looking to sell some coins.

Sold some odds & end gold, that I didn’t use anymore! Great service & price! Real gentlemen, honest, & nice! Would definitely do business again! Thanks for the Ali S.I. Edition!!!

My boyfriend and I went here to sell some gold and silver, as well as some of his football cards. The gentlemen who worked there were very kind and I trusted their knowledge. The price the gave us for the silver and gold was very good.
As for the football cards, the gentleman told my boyfriend that he would probably get better money for them in a different market (the cards were Miami Dolphins players). I really respected that they were honest with us.
It is a cute, clean little shop and by going here you can feel good about supporting a local business.

This is a baseball card, sports memorabilia, and rare coins and money shop right in Kenmore Square.
The guys who work there are really helpful and knowledgeable. I went in looking for a simple item (a display case for a baseball card) and just wondered if they had a card for a pretty unknown Red Sox first basemen from 1947. The guy didn’t have one (of course. I don’t know if anybody does), but he went through the trouble to look the player up in a reference book and let me know how many cards were ever issued for the guy, when, and by what company.
The other person working seemed equally as helpful. A really nice atmosphere and some pretty awesome stuff for the diehard sports fan.
They buy cards, memorabilia, and rare coins and paper money, and they also buy silver and gold (to melt down) at good prices. They post their prices daily on the website.