Attardi’s Pizzeria

This is by far the best pizza in the area. Some of the negative reviews on here are idiotic. I will say that they struggle to cut even slices. Everything is noticeably crooked but the taste is there and it is pretty great.

I so wanted to like this place, being as it is close enough to the house to warrant a good take out place but I am sorry to say I won’t be going back.
Even though the owner is very nice, the pizza and sub just wasn’t up to par, it was more like I got the food from a pizza joint in Ohio.
I didn’t try a reg pizza, I wanted a good Sicilian pizza but what we got was flat and average taste-​almost 7 – 11 store style, nothing outstanding. When I buy a Sicilian, I want it to be fluffy and thick! It was as they took a regular pizza dough and turned it square.
The sub we got was a large Italian but the bun was not fresh made, store style and stale. The tomatoes were orange and ehh. I had to put my meat on a burger bun to eat it.
My suggestion would be to get a new dough recipe and make fresh sub rolls to give them a chance because like I said, the owner is a nice guy!

Pretty good pizza for Florida! On the thinner side with nice crispy crust reminds me of pizza I would find in NY. Will return.

Really nice people. Great pizza and best of all a truly great tasting meatball! Not sure where Rich is from but the jar sauce has long copied the original, not the other way around. A compliment, really :)

You are welcomed by the owner the minute you walk in the door, unlike many restaurants where you get ignored. Nice to enter a friendly place! The waitresses have been a bit «lost» on our visits, but nice girls none then less.
Very tasty salads and dressings, and fresh! You can tell the pasta and pizza are freshly made food (not canned crap). They have a decent pizza and toppings, we prefer the Sicilian over the thin crust, but that’s our preference. The thin is pretty good and the crust has a nice crunch to it. Tasty «large» side of meatballs too.
Ask for your Lasagna or Ziti well done and you’ll be happy, otherwise it comes just warm and a bit soggy for my taste. The homemade sauce is pretty good, and you can tell right away it’s not from a jar or can.
Even a few big screen HD TV’s to enjoy your favorite games if dining in.

Quaint local family owned Pizzeria. Better pizza and food than any of the other Pizzerias in the area. We had the meatballs and a pizza, which both were very delicious, as the ingredients were all fresh. I will be recommending this place to all my friends and family

Amazing ambiance, great family atmosphere and absolutely great quality pizza. It is good to see a small family operated restaurant genuinely caring about each customer. If you enjoy a hidden gem, I would urge anyone to try their pizza and atmosphere.

Sauce tasted out of a jar the pizza was ok nothing like the ny he pretends to be though I will not return

This is a very new restaurant, so it helps to have a little patience when you eat here. They have order ahead, delivery, and eat-​in, but limited staff to accomplish all of the tasks.
It is a nice addition to the neighborhood (Tara). The pizza is fresh; dough is made daily. Sauce is homemade. We’ve eaten here twice and the pizza is the best in the area. Yes, its better than Erbelli’s or Michaelangelo’s.
There are sandwiches and pasta dishes on the menu. Pizza is probably the best bet. Beer and a couple of wines available.
If you are in a giant hurry for delivery — order Papa John’s. If you are a considerate person who wants to see a small local business succeed — try Attardi’s.

I had just got off work and noticed a new pizza place had opened in the twelve oaks plaza in Bradenton. It honestly looked like it was going to be good, but eating there was a HUGE mistake. The waitress was terrible, forgetful, lazy and rude. She had no idea what she was doing, easily some of the worst service I’ve ever received. Got a creepy, weird unpleasant vibe from the place to begin with. The mozzarella sticks I ordered for an appetizer were extremely small, and only about 6 of them, all cold in the center. Disgusting. Once the pizza came out I knew for sure I’d made a huge mistake. It was greasy as all hell. And tastless. Truly awful pizza. I didn’t even want to bother writing a Unilocal review because I know before too long it will close down with food and service that bad anyway, but I was so dissatisfied I had to vent. Please, for the love of god, don’t eat here.

It’s the real deal. Perfect Brooklyn NY pizza. The crust, the sauce, the cheese all what they are supposed to be. Our young waitress was trying hard but was in the weeds with 3 tables. A few growing pains but you should give it a try.

Excellent NY style pizza. The sauce is like a Sunday gravy you can tell it has been cooked for hours simmering. The meatballs are homemade and perfect. And they deliver. Finally a place just like NY. The owner was friendly and working hard, his wait staff was the only problem. They were young and lazy. While the owner was running around the teens were complaining every time he asked them to move. But what gave the owner more points in my book is that he was patient with the staff and tried to kindly educate and motivate his young staff. If he can inspire them the entire experience would be a 5.