Primo Pizza

This pizza was just mediocre… not terrible, but certainly not good. We ordered a plain pie and pepperoni pie… the crust and sauce both lack flavor! My mom loves their salad pie (I haven’t tried) but I will definitely try elsewhere next time I’m looking for pizza. Besides the fact that they are a bit pricey and do NOT except credit cards!

I just moved down here from CT and the restaurant is literally a 2 minute walk from the house. We’ve tried it once before but we figured we’d give them another shot. Now, my boyfriend and I really got our hopes up with this place ESPECIALLY since we are really trying to stick to eating clean at home. Our second time was just a failure. I was halfway into eating my vegetable Stromboli. Thank goodness I cut every piece before I eat it. I came across something new, something blue. It was only a piece of plastic but this would’ve definitely raised a great amount of concern if this bite was for a small child who could’ve choked on this. Maybe it just isn’t for us, unfortunately.

Needed pizza at midnight on a Monday. they came through. Super fast delivery and pizza was really good. Totally recommend them if you need late night pizza!

Two bad experiences and we’re done with Primo’s, and it’s a shame because we’re Brigantine locals. Two weeks ago we were told we couldn’t use a coupon for no apparent reason (because the pizza was already on special?) and then this evening I ordered a salad, the salad arrived missing the dressing. I called and asked for a credit and was told «no, we can’t do that, we’ll deliver it to you.» After 40 minutes I finally called to follow up, and was told they were trying to call me (not sure what for?) and the dressing would be another 20 minutes. At this point I said, can you please just give me a credit for the salad? They said no, we can only credit you for the dressing. Ridiculous. A 50 cent credit. So I told them to deliver me the dressing. After 1 hour and 10 minutes, it arrived.

We visited this pizzeria during a class trip. Joe was incredibly friendly and accommodating to our group. He opened early, gave us a great rate on pizza/​soda combos, and treated our group with a big smile. The food tasted great and was ready so fast! Some of our students have special needs and often times we encounter businesses whose employees stare or just aren’t happy to have us, but not here. This had to be the friendliest place we have visited and we can’t wait to come back! It was clean, too!

We were staying in the area and stop by and picked up a pie. The pizza was good and they were nice enough to provided paper plates and toppings since we didn’t have any of those in our room.
It wasn’t the best pizza ever but if you are in the area and want something quick and cheap this is a good place.

I gave it three stars because it does not take credit card or debit cash only would have been five but over all the pizza is good and the chicken cheese steak was the best.

In my opinion, best pizza on the island! I dinged them one star for only accepting cash. Who does that? At least get square pay or something like that, it’s 2014! In any case, the pizza is great but they don’t have a huge selection of other stuff, but that’s ok, pick one thing and do it well. The pizza is crispy and fairly thin crusted and their pizza sauce is top notch. Plain is just a s good as anything else but I usually get sausage and banana peppers or something like that. They also sent a coupon for a free pizza to everyone in the winter… that was awesome! With 2 toppings, I got a whole pizza for less than $ 5.

It’s a small place but the pizza is great! We also loved the cheese fries. It’s a perfect place to stop in, very kid friendly. Just remember it’s small so seats may be limited during lunch time.

Very good! My boyfriend and I picked up a plain pie here and lugged it to the beach at sunset. we ate the entire thing by ourselves right out of the box! The crust is thin and crunchy. I will always come back when I’m in Brig!
The only negatives are that they don’t take cash, and the store is outdated and falling apart.

The price point is nice but the pizza is average. I had the bbq chicken pizza and a plain slice with a medium soda. It was $ 7.50. The line moved quickly and my pizza came even quicker. The bbq chicken slice was average. The regular slice was actually pretty tasty. The seats are crusty dusty and full of crumbs. Service was just okay. Would definitely go back for the same special just plain slices.

We needed pizza en route to one of the Halloween Phish shows at Boardwalk Hall. The selection was sparse, We had a pepperoni and a white slice. As far as NJ pizza goes it was ok, nothing great but it did the job. We were happy that they were even open considering it was off season in Brigantine. I’d like to try again in the summer before settling 100% on my review stars.

What they do not tell you either when you call to place your order or place it in person is they accept one form of payment CASH! They do have their own money access machine for $ 1.50 … Oh and after you attempt to withdrawn cash and it tells you it is «out of cash» they will inform you to go to Wawa to get the cash and they will just put your pizza right over here for when you get back.
I was not the only person to have such a dilemma as 4 others share in the cash scramble with me. Now I don’t object to cash what I object to is not being told when I called in my order or not having a sign on the door or on the wall. I would have left earlier to pick up my order and taken cash with me instead of my lowly credit card at the beach!
The staff response to the machine was a pleasant laugh and referral to Wawa. When I complained it is not disclosed the reply was well we always only accepted cash… Oh we’ll then I guess It was all my fault for not knowing they only accepted cash and not knowing the money access machine was not going to have any cash!
To the curious employee asking if I was going to go to Wawa and then come back for my order… NO!, And I won’ be back any other time…
Should have known when the sign said McHugh’s Primo Pizza!

We really enjoyed the pizza, perfect amount of cheese. Definitely going back!

Best Pizza in Brigantine.

Stopped in with the family, ordered a large pepperoni pizza and large curly cheese fries. Fries came out first, so over cooked that they were crispier then potato chips, then out came the pizza. It’s was drenched so much with grease that it took approximately 20 – 25 napkins to mop it up before it could be handled, then we bite into it, it had absolutely no flavor at all except for the remaining grease residue, had to dump a heavy coating of Parmesan cheese and garlic powder just to make it palatable… unfortunately your stuck on the Brigintine island with not much else there… id rather eat a WAWA hoagie

The buffalo chicken pizza is amazing! I could eat it every day.

I’d choose 0 stars if possible…
This is the worst pizza we have ever eaten in our lives, and we have eaten a LOT of pizza. Undercooked bread, barely there sauce, bland cheese and flavorless toppings. There are few ways you can mess up a pizza and Primos has figured out how. Cardboard with ketchup on top would have been better.
If you’re going to eat in, don’t forget to bring your own broom for the floors, cleaner for the tables and fly swatter for the flies.
We are truly disgusted by the food and service here, and will never be going back. Take your $ 20 and go spend it anywhere else.

Not a bad Sicilian pie-​unusual sauce with a touch of fennel? I have had better pizza but this did the trick