Peter Pan Diner

This Dinner is close by. gave it a second chance the first time wasn’t a great experience, but the second time I had an OK experience the servers were great but the greeter totally ignored me when I came in so it was a bit of a wait until the waitress notice me. As far as the food the food was pretty good so I gave it a third chance and brought some friends they said the food was great as well try the buffalo wings and the pancakes were really awesome.

I have Been going here most of my life great staff great food clean definitely my choice for #1 diner on Long Island

It’s on my way home from work so it’s easy to call ahead, swing in, pay & keep it moving.
That’s exactly what I did on Friday because anyone who knows me knows (say it with me) against the law to cook on Friday!
The food is always good here & prices vet comparable. I like that they do have daily specials so do try them. My go to meals are the roumanian steak, Pork Souvlaki & Greek Salad, & also Baked Clams.
A good classic Long Island Diner. Solid food.
6-​3-​2016

I have an affinity for diners. Especially when you or the person/​people you’re with cannot decide for the life of you what on earth you’ve got a taste for.
This has been my go-​to diner since moving out east. Fast, friendly service and I’ve never ordered anything I didn’t enjoy. That said, my faves are the make-​your-​own omelette and the mexi-​max burger (with jalapenos and avocado).
I’ve brought countless weekend guests here from my girlfriends to my parents and my brother. Everyone loved what they had. Coffee is good, strong and the waitress always keeps it coming. Best diner around!

Never have I had a bad experience at Peter Pan Diner. I have been there a good 4 dozen times. Their Clam Chowder is phenomenal; there are leeks in it! It’s incredible. Their Breakfast’s are always impressive; best hash on the planet, eggs perfectly cooked, and bacon always crispy, never floppy. Salads and sandwiches are great. Meals; I gotta be honest, I didn’t venture into their meals too far. It’s a diner. I ate «diner food». Chicken fingers with a side of gravy and some disco fries. They rocked.
This place is awesome. Only thing that’s bad is the parking. Their food is so good that they’re always packed. No biggie.

Soggy potatoes and bacon. Had American cheese in the Greek omelette instead of feta. Was not tasty at all.

What a wonderful Diner! Whenever in the Bay Shore area we seem to always pass the diner on Bayshore Road right by Sunrise Hwy. And am I glad we do!
Today we stopped for lunch and BG ordered a Greek Salad with Anchovies and lots of Peppercinis… I had an outrageous Double Bleu Cheese Burger with loads of chunky cheese and Maplewood Bacon, with a nice pile of sweet potato fries… Delicious. Last time there I had pancakes and sausage… also really good. One day soon we will go for dinner and I am confident it will be better than lunch! Plenty of parking, very clean and service is tops!

I won’t grow up,
I don’t want to go to school.
Just to learn to be a parrot,
And recite a silly rule.
If growing up means
It would be beneath my dignity to climb a tree,
I’ll never grow up, never grow up, never grow up
Not me!
Not I,
Not me!
Not me!
I won’t grow up, — Peter Pan
Sing on playboy!
After passing this diner on Sunrise Hwy & hearing hearing good things about it for almost 20 years now — I knew I had to stop in one of these days. Since I was running around from store to store, I worked up an appetite. Not wanting to deal with the Saturday evening crowds– I saw that Peter Pan diner was wasn’t overly crowded, so I made
the detour into the parking lot.
Upon walking in– notices the showcase of all the desserts calling your name telling you to come in & enjoy. Though I didn’t try any desserts I’m sure they are as good as they look!
We were greeted by a hostess and seated quickly. This is a nice diner. The atmosphere has that old diner vibe with the chrome accents but with a cool contemporary décor.
The food — all very good, pretty much is your typical diner food. Though I didn’t try the breakfast (which diners are known for) the table
Next to me did & it looked good.
Service was great! Friendly & attentive. No
Complaints there.
I will be back sometime.
Wendy, Michael, John… TinkerBell — Come On!

We came for lunch. We were a larger party, and the waitress was a bit flustered. but the food was excellent. I’m not much of a fish lover, but I was very happy with my Hawaiian tilapia, moist and flaky fish served with a mild pineapple salsa. Rice pudding was creamy but not cloyingly sweet. Very satisfied.

There’s always great service, even during their dinner rush. The food isn’t particularly expensive for a diner. I recommend the chicken caesar salad wrap with french fries and a chocolate shake.

REAL turkey in their turkey sandwich, not sliced cold cuts. Everyone loved the food, but the service was a tad lacking and the desserts off a smidge, so no 5-​star.
If I lived in the area, I’d be a regular.

Good Day ,
Everyone,
I went to the Peter Pan diner this morning in off Sunrise Highway .
been there previously, months back
The place is well located, have never
been disappointed.
So here I am today .
Sat at the counter, generally faster service.
I kept breakfast simple, 2 eggs scrambled sausage, well, home fries well.
Rye toast well done, some extra butter.
like ordering egg meals at Diners, you receive a variety of different Tastes.. home fries, sausage, bacon, toast, eggs.
It’s a great meal to evaluate a restaurant.
The meal came out very quickly, 6 minutes. coffee was at the table with in a minute, coffee was really good, fresh, love good coffee keep the refills coming.
The meal was presented beautifully
(see photo) sausage was well done as requested. however, was warm.
Not hot. like the rest of the meal ‚
no big deal.
I mentioned the sausage to a young lady ‚
she immediately rectified the problem .
the sausage was returned to the plate, piping hot in 2 minutes.WOW.
Everything else about the breakfast was just fine, eggs seem fresh, full of flavor .
Home fries had small amounts of onion and pepper in them (properly cooked) to enhance the flavor. The home fries were also well done the way I like them .
That is … The home fries with some shortening was put on the HOT grill and allowed to get nice and Crispy.
The first coffee refill I had to ask for,
then the refills came plentifully after that.
(Good coffee).
Took a a few photographs …
Classic neighborhood, Long Island family-​run Diner
Paying the check, I mentioned to the young lady at the counter, I came alone,
couldn’t spin the wheel, as it is a required $ 20 purchase, breakfast, lunch for myself never gets to be that.
She said go ahead spin the wheel
I Won a free dessert at a future visit
Which is smart, because it will get me to come back and get that GREAT BIG brownie that the place is famous for.
Overall I was satisfied with my visit to the Peter Pan diner ‚
and like the way the management and wait staff rolled with the circumstances to quickly fix any issues.
Uncle Roy used to say,
If your pants catch fire… don’t use your beer to put them out.
Good Morning I Came back.. 2.11.16
AM Breakfast I ordered the short stack of the BLUEBERRY pancakes. ABSOLUTELY FLUFFY, and wonderfully delicious with a rasher of bacon well done… came out to perfection ‚
(, see NEW photos.)
My server JOHN. .was on the spot with the coffee. ASK FOR JOHN. .
(the server can MAKE the Experience)…
I travel Long Island all of metro area and This is I’m on my TOP BREAKFAST places to sit down, and relax with the newspaper & coffee.
JD.

They let me have a short stack of pancakes instead of toast or instead of potatoes with an omelette. They have while wheat pancakes and a bunch of selections including banana and nuts! Coffee is good too!

This diner was such a nice find. I was in the neighborhood and found this gem on google maps and decided to give it a try. Boy I’m glad I did. I ordered a jumbo burger steak fries and after had a banana pudding shake. Everything was on point. The burger was juicy and the fries were cooked perfectly. As for the shake, that finished off the dinner just right. Great place, super clean and great food.

The go to spot in Bay Shore! Great staff and never a long wait to be seated. If you can’t decide where you want to go for lunch or dinner check this place out.

Visit Date: September 10, 2015
My husband and I came here for our monthiversary. I wanted to take him to Coyle’s but despite their hours being listed as open til 12 am, they were closing when we got there. So we decided to come to Peter Pan diner.
We had a fourth meal, or elevenses in hobbit speak. We split an order of mozarella fries which were typical diner fries and of course pretty damn good. We also split a dessert they had called death by chocolate which was absolutely amazing.
The staff was very nice and we discovered something called the wheel of discounts. Basically it’s a game the diner runs every night. If you get a certain check number you are entitled to spin the wheel and receive the discount or free option that the wheel stops on. I think that’s a very good idea for customer loyalty and an added fun bonus to the diner as well.
We would be back here again if we had the opportunity.

Very good diner with great food. It’s a nice place to come for breakfast or late nights with friends to grab and bite and chat. The waffles are mouth watering! The prices on everything is really good.

Peter Pancakes: Banana Nut + Whipped Cream! Fantastic choice: P

So this is the 3^rd diner on Long Island that I’ve tried and I’m yet again disappointed. Aren’t diners around here suppose to be good?
We went for breakfast and opted for an egg white omelet and was told i can substitute the home fries and toast for fruit. My omelet was over cooked and I was charged for the fruit. Also, the blueberries in the fruit were previously frozen making them dry and stick together while i chewed. I’ve never eaten blueberries and had that happen.
My fiancé got the pancakes with eggs and bacon and a side of home fries. His only complaint was the lack of eggs.
Service was okay but we won’t be returning. Also found it way over priced for what you’re getting.

A typical diner that is what you expect. The pancakes are lights out and so are a few other things on the lunch menu. Gyro salad. pastrami sandwich are great options also. The waitress and staff are very nice and if you are a regular will take care of you.
The pancakes are fantastic… but why do you give your customers Aunt Jamima’s syrup in the Aunt Jamima’s plastic holder??? IHOP has how many types of syrup? and you give us this?
Lack of care on the owners part.