Romeo’s Pizza

While I am a pizza snob and totally favor the Chicago pizza styes– deep dish, stuffed, and thin, I do love Romeo’s. The sauce does it.

Let me just say, I’m a pizza fanatic. I’m constantly trying new places and I have officially hit the Jack pot.
I was rather confused when I first opened my box and saw sauce on top. I thought they mixed up my pizza with someone else’s. I then noticed the cheese and was like hm… This is a perplexing pizza. I took a bite and said a few astonished profanities at the awesomeness that my tastebuds had just experienced. By far, the best pizza I have had in the area. (and I’ve had about 10 or 12 places in the Cleveland area) seriously, check this place out. Even if you’re anti-​chain. You are missing out on phenomenal pizza.

Ordered delivery from the Holiday Inn Express and was so pleasantly surprised! Everything was delicious, hot, with great ingredients and big portions. We got spaghetti with meatballs (huge meatballs), garlic bread, seasoned potato wedges with bacon and cheese, a side salad, and the club sandwich. Everything was so good and very well priced for the portions that you get. Delivery was about 40 minutes like they said but it was a weekend night so I’m sure they were busy. Great place!

Great pizza, the prices are very reasonable. Great service on delivery and carry out. I couldn’t really tell you what’s my favorite food item here because we order different stuff each time. What i can say for sure is the steak topping should be everyone’s go to topping if you’re not sure, its soo good! Not far from home, just simply good!

I ordered online and received the most delicious meatball pizza in only 20 min. It was hot and fresh with lots of cheese and was a well balanced flavor. The sauce is sweet but I liked it. The meatballs are seasoned nicely for flavor. It was also not overly greasy like some pizza places can be. The crust is thick and tastes like homemade bread.
I gave them 4 stars because although the pizza is delicious… The pizza I had in New York City will always be the 5 star one. But since I live in Ohio it’s my new favorite pizza place!

You either love sweet sauce, or you hate it. The people you hate it, should just steer clear of this place and stop hating on the pizza itself, because Romeos has the best pizza ever! If by any chance you don’t like sweet sauce, you have GOT to try the Great Ranch Potato pizza, it has a ranch bacon sauce with sausage, potato, carmalized onion and ranch dusted almonds. It is the best pizza I have ever tried! I’ve been going to this location for about three years and they never disappoint!

One of my favorite pizzas. I’ve been ordering from the store since it opened. On the whole, most of the staff are friendly and try to do a good job. The only negative is that I’ve had a few errors, relatively minor, on my orders over the last couple years, and they (not just one individual) seem resistant to making it right. I don’t have that issue with other places, typically, and certainly not consistently. Fix that and it’d be 5 stars. I still go back because I like it, but not everyone will be that forgiving. They are good at having it ready when promised.

We love the pizza. My wife is from Buffalo and says this pizza is the best in Cleveland. The sauce is sweeter but that’s what makes it so good.

Few things shut down my appetite like witnessing someone vomiting or even seeing puke. I don’t know. Maybe it’s just me but I find it really objectionable. Even the smell is troubling.
Other reviewers might say Romeo’s Pizza is too sweet or has unpleasant off-​flavors associated with their pizza, but after a long hot day dealing with people fighting airborne pathogenic infection, it really can hit the spot. I stopped by the other day on the way out of Broadview Heights and decided to grab a large pizza.
Or two.
You see, they have some interesting and unusual offerings including one called ‘the butcher shop’ that has a lot of meat on it (cooked) and another called ‘the ranch lover’s chicken pizza’ that replaces cheese with ranch dressing and comes with a generous amount of little nubs of chicken. It has a shiny glaze to it that you would not expect from a pizza slathered in salad dressing. I got one of each.
I know what you’re thinking. I ordered too much and we’re going to come full-​circle on the clever vomit intro, but hold your literary presumption. The pizzas were awesome! The meat pizza did in fact evoke thoughts of a place where meat primals are broken down into component cuts and I really did find myself loving the idea of a house without an upstairs while gutting down slices of the salad dressing pizza.
Both types were tasty and worked well to trick my hypothalamus into forgetting the day’s wretchedness. When I finished my meal, everything smelled like pizza to me instead of smelling like vomit. I even had enough for leftovers the next day!
If I can enjoy it after a day like I had, no one grinding through the day in day out horror of postmodern social and environmental degradation within the constraints of Broadview Heights could look up with mouth full and not say, «This pizza tastes great!»

We stayed at the Sheraton at the airport and couldn’t muster the will to leave again, so we ordered delivery from Romeos. It arrived 10 minutes ahead of schedule (in 40 minutes, not bad) and we tucked in. When I am out trying pizza, I normally stick will plain pepperoni or pep and mush. On this trip, I had my mom with me so we went for the traditional crust (not too thin, not too thick) with ½ pep & mush and ½ grn pep, onion and mush. The pizza was very lovely. Nice and brown. Upon picking up a slice, I smelled… something…smoke? Now I don’t know what this is coming from. Is the pepperoni smoked? I don’t know. And I think that is what got the 3 star review from me. I am not a fan of smoked meats or whatnot. I feel like that smell/​flavor is phony. I would also say that they are a shade stingy on the cheese. If I had to do it again I would get a cheese pizza with extra cheese. Moms side with the veggies was good, she said. It is often a problem with getting the veggies done, and she said they could have been a little more cooked. The breadsticks were ok, but we ordered with cheese and we couldn’t tell if the cheese was on there, maybe another instance of the stingy cheese disease.
BOIL IT DOWN: it was ok for whatever we could get delivered to the hotel… not bad. Sweet sauce, good crust, GET EXTRA CHEESE.

Who dumped the sugar bowl into the sauce pot?

Perhaps I was wrong to give Romeo’s such a bad review, because even though I left my leftover pizza in the work refrigerator too long and had to throw it away, when I went to toss it I had discovered that some sneaky food-​stealing co-​worker ate about 2/​3rds of it already. To risk: 1) eating pizza that could have been weeks old 2) eating pizza that could have had gross I-​dont-​wash-​my-​hands-​after-​I-​go-​to-​the-​bathroom germs on it (for all they knew) and 3) the possible embarrassment if I had caught them… suggests that this pizza must actually be damn good.