Slice of Brooklyn Pizzeria

My family and I had just arrived to our hotel after a flight from Florida and we were hungry. The clerk at our hotel recommended Slice of Brooklyn because it was nearby and well priced. I am so glad we went because we would have never had the great experience we had there.
The pizzeria was empty, but it wasn’t surprising considering the time. We all had pizza, which was good and hot, but we were still hungry, so we asked the owner for a recommendation. He made us chicken wings, fresh, and they were the BEST chicken wings we’ve ever had. We even had a second order. To this day, two years later, we still talk about those wings and how nice the owner was. I’m still craving those chicken wings!

Gross. I’ve never not finished a slice of pizza until I came here. My slice had zero flavor and it was as if I was eating a paper towel soaked in grease.

Ordered through seamless (restaurant themselves do not accept credit cards): Pizza was ok but it took an unacceptable 90 MINUTES FOR THEM TO DELIVER! We had ordered a lot of pies (too many for them to handle?) & needed them for set staff dinner break time so I phoned restaurant to confirm/​explain and was told no worries, 30 – 40 minutes: if you can’t meet time deadlines don’t string me along! Significantly impacted our workers and event and they are going to miss out on our sizeable repeat business. But as I said the pizza was good. Just so annoying.

If I could give no stars I would. I ordered from a 3^rd party site and when I received the food it was not what I ordered. I called them and they told me I was looking at the wrong menu. I asked if they updated it on there and they kept telling me wrong menu. I never got a clear answer. They said what wanted was actually more than what I paid even though the price was set. So you see that my order comes with the extras and I was undercharged, you call me to let me know. He called me to ask if I wanted sauce in my food but couldn’t relay that message that I could not get a Stromboli that came with pepperoni, ham and cheese because I did not pay enough? I would have no problem paying the up charge. He was yelling at me telling me to call eat 24 (even though it was not their fault because this restaurant did not update their menu on the site) and That I should have called him before I made the order. The whole point of online ordering it to eradicate that customer restaurant ordering hassle. He hung up on me twice and yelled at me asking me if I have a brain. I lost it and we exchanged words. You are not going to insult me because you cannot own up to your mistakes. Completely rude. The food was nothing above terrible as well. Extra soggy and wet. No bite whatsoever. I am in customer service so I am really forgiving because there are a lot of things that go wrong but this, I cannot forgive this.

Tried delivery from a few pizza places in the area. So far this is the best deal and quality of pizza. We get the grubhub special –Lg cheese pizza, garlic knots, and 2 liter soda for $ 13. Have yet to have a bad experience with this place. Delivery is prompt and food is good and affordable.

Don’t waste your time!
I ordered through the EAT app. They took over an hour to notify EAT that they couldn’t deliver.
Their service lacks professionalism.

I am a pizza nut and I try every place I can in and around NYC, this place just made its way into my top 5 maybe top 3. 100% awesome!!!

Wanted to get some good Italian food so I ordered baked ziti and fettuccine Alfredo from here, was really disappointed to find they both tasted awful. The pizza was average and the food was over priced for what I ordered.

The BEST Pizza in BK… hands down. The décor-​clean, relaxing and spacious. The service-​friendly, helpful and happy. The pizza-​nice large size, good cheese, flavorful sauce and nice crust… I would of liked a little more sauce on the pizza but still tasty. The prices-​not bad.
**Note: If you want to impress your date, a true New Yorker would come here to eat!!!
So, check it… I ordered a slice with pepperoni and a slice with cheese and both were Really cheesy, full of flavor and good… but the one with the peperoni kinda added a little somethin’ somethin’…you feel me! Anyway!-next time I am in Brooklyn… I’m stopping here… Much propz!!!

So, I had the best slice of pizza (old NY style pizza) here last night. I walked in and noticed an enticing aroma. «What smells so good?» I asked. «Garlic pizza» both men answered. Another patron had just sat down with the last slice, so the pizza maker offered to make a new pie so I could have my own slice. I agreed. And am I glad I did! The flavor was stupendous: white pie and the flavor of mild garlic: not sharp, raw garlic, which I love in the proper context, not sweet cooked for hours garlic, but just a mild but uniquely delicious flavor. I brought my 1 slice home to eat and was in heaven. Now, my Greek salad? Not a knockout… my tomatoes were not ripe, the lettuce was iceberg. This I will not order again. But that slice…

I like this place for consistent delivery. Yes, its not the best pizza in NY. However, it may be the best pizza delivery in sunset park. :) All in all, its pretty good.

I wanted to like this place so bad, especially because it’s right around the corner from my apartment. Unfortunately, this place tried to scam us on our seamless order… TWICE!
The first time, we ordered on seamless for pickup (not delivery) because it’s so close. Order was confirmed via e-​mail as per usual. It said approximately 20 minutes. I showed up to pick up the order 20 minutes later, and they hadn’t even started making it. I had to wait, so I decided to sit at one of their tables. The order was ready 15 minutes later. I walked up to grab it and the girl at the counter asked me how I was going to pay. I replied that it had already been payed for through seamless on my credit card. She copped a huge attitude with me and said «that’s not how it works, we actually have to charge your credit card on our machine.» To which I replied «No, I’m not stupid, I use seamless all the time and you already got your money». Then she asked to see my credit card. I refused of course, because I’ve never heard of this in my entire life. She told me to wait a minute, went and whispered something to her boss, came back and said «Ok, never mind, you’re good to go.»
The second time, a few weeks later, we ordered on seamless for pickup again. Thinking the first time was a fluke, I gave them the benefit of the doubt. I showed up 20 minutes later to grab the order and sure enough… THE SAME EXACT SITUATION is happening. Order wasn’t ready, and she tried to tell me AGAIN that she needed to see my credit card. I refused, explaining to her that she already tried to double-​charge the last time. Also included with my order (which was clearly written out on my receipt) is a free 2-​liter of soda. She argued with me that the soda wasn’t included, that it was seamless’s fault for advertising that. I was so fed up at this point that, I told her to keep the order and I’d be calling seamless for a full refund. After hearing that, she went and whispered something to her boss again, came back and told me «Never mind, you’re good to go. And you can have the soda, but next time you have to pay for the soda» to which I replied that there wouldn’t be a next time and that they better get their seamless issues sorted out.
What a SCAM! Two times within weeks of each other, they tried to double-​charge for my order. I highly recommend NOT ordering through seamless. Cash only is definitely safer with these guys.
I gave 2 stars because the food is actually really good. The pies are big and the toppings are not shy. It’s such a shame, because I really wanted to give this place my business.

Compared to most pizza spots in Sunset Park this place is a dud. I wasn’t too happy when I ordered online and my order took over an hour to arrive. My food was completely cold! Pizza cold, garlic knots hard and cold, chicken also cold. Only the soda arrived nice and warm. I would never order here again. I passed the place one day walking down 4^th ave and it’s not that clean either. I guess it’s because they are in a location with no other pizza options they get away with it, and these rave reviewers have nothing else to compare it to. Take yourself to CTown and pick up a Red Barron or Digorno, it will be a lot fresher than this place.

Solid slice for when you’re in a pinch or on your way to the subway. Make sure they heat it up extra hot, or else it’s barely lukewarm. Yummy, crispy — a solid slice!

Ever since the new change in ownership, app. a year ago, this place has stopped making edible food. I used to hope that my pizza would come out delicious like it used to, but no… SAVE YOURSELF THE GRIEF– GO SOMEPLACE ELSE. The slices taste like cardboard with wayyy too much cheese. Everything seems old. Yuck.

ARE YOU KIDDING ME?! Ordered food on Seamless. They charged us but forgot an entire salad and a bottle of soda. We call them up immediately after and nicely told them that they forgot a couple of things. The guy on the phone said we could pick it up if we wanted and then HUNG UP ON US. NEVER have I experienced «service» like this, ever. Do not give them business! If you don’t deliver something, offer a refund, credit or something!
UPDATE: Called Seamless directly and they gave us a refund for missing items. If something similar happens to you, consider calling Seamless customer care and complaining. They should know if the restaurant is habitually shorting their customers.

If you are in Sunset Park and looking for a solid slice of Sicilian or regular pizza, look no further because this should be your spot. Everything you are looking for in a slice of pizza can be found at Slice of Brooklyn from the delicious blend of cheese and sauce to the crunchy, yet sturdy crust. If you decide to come here, consider it dough well spent.

Yo, seriously?! Chicken Francaise slice? INSANE!
Just what I need to ruin my workout after training at Ardon Sweet Science (a few doors away).
LOL You gotta try this place!

A solid 4 stars. Out of all the top rated Brooklyn pizzerias here on Unilocal, this place serves the best pizza in Brooklyn.

A