Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza

A gourmet version of Papa Murphy’s… amazing crust, sauce, and toppings, and the staff is the friendliest you’ll ever encounter, period.

The best pizza in town!!! I always get the take-​n-​bake, that way it’s hot and crisp. Also, can’t say enough about the owners, great people.

This pizza place hits all the marks for our family– crust not too thin and not too thick, great topping options, price is good and we can either take it home to bake on the grill or in the oven! Service has always been 5 star.

I’ve been going to nick n willys since high school and am excited to see it still going strong!
They have kept up with the trends, gluten free, etc.
Love the fast service!
Large menu you can customize and even get a take and bake pizza
Yum

Haha wrong location, this is for Hattie b’s not nick and willies pizza.
Well when in Nashville, not rome, do as the nashvilians do. Lol. Go to Hattie bs and wait in the long line. It’s the Tennessee spicy fried chicken that you’ll find here. Great flavor and all the sauces you can add is what makes it fun. Not the healthiest but good southern food.

I like having the option to get a personal size pizza because my wife and I like different toppings. I took away a star because it took quite a while to get our pizzas, which is something I typically wouldn’t criticize at a pizza place but they have a pretty quick set up where they throw toppings on pre-​formed dough and send it through a conveyor-​style oven. So there’s really no reason a pizza should take longer than 20 minutes with that method.

Good pizza. Great menu. Love the white sauce on the pizzas. Service is always spot on. Great alternative to delivery. Clean restaurant. Pricing is reasonable.

I’m a health nut and really dislike the prospect of getting a little chubs. I generally stay away from pizza and it’s kin; however with nick and willy’s I have no problems as I know what’s going into each glorious 6.5inch pie. The dough is freshly made, the vegetables look like they were freshly picked off of whatever plant they came from, and the meats look wonderfully colored. I’ve been making my way down the list of their array of pizzas and so far they’re all amazing. I’m always tempted to eat more (until I remember the whole chubs thing).
The service is fantastic — you’ll never meet a nicer person (s) than Dan and Carla (except for me!). They’re wonderfully cheery people and will accommodate whatever reasonable request you have. ¹⁰⁄₁₀ would recommend to anyone on a pizza-​free diet.

This is a great place for pizza. Small seating area and a couple tables outside. They also offer take & bake. Service was very friendly.

We absolutely love Nick-n-Willy’s! The pizza is wonderful but in addition to great pizza, the staff is friendly and helpful. The owners are wholesome, loving people. They always have a smile on their face and take pride in their work. We love the atmosphere, and chatting with the staff at the bar top while they fix up our pizza! The Big Kahuna is our favorite! Five stars!

Great pizza! I finally tried Nick-n-Willy’s Pizza out this past Saturday night. I’d just flown back to Denver, had traveled most of the day, and I was starving. I walked in wondering if they had pizza by the slice. They did not. However, they informed me they had personal, small pizza’s. I browsed the menu, and they had a great variety to choose from. I immediately chose the Big Kahuna, which is one of their signature pizza’s.
They had a great deal for a personal pizza and a drink for $ 6.50. Can’t beat that! They told me it would take approximately 7 min. for it to be ready. Turns out it took more like 25 – 30 min. for my pizza to be ready. I understand it was Saturday night, and they got a few orders at the same time as mine.
The pizza was excellent! Fresh cheese, and just the right amount of sauce. It was even better then my basic favorite of Canadian Bacon and pineapple! They say that «the mandarin oranges make all the difference.» Well, it was delicious, and I will certainly be getting it again. Only the next time, I’m calling my order in, then picking it up, to avoid waiting.
I know they have a take and bake option, but I still prefer to pick it up already baked.

Love this suburban location. We use them on occasion for feeding our church’s lifegroups (pastor lives down the street), and they never disappoint. Hugely superior alternative to the national chains that abound thoroughout Broomfield.

What is with the pizza places here and severely undersaucing pizzas? It can’t be cost savings, since the toppings and cheese are generous. You could barely find the sauce on the last pizza I got. It’s a shame since their sauce is quite good (when it’s there) and I think they do pretty good pizzas-​worthy of 4 stars ohter than this.
Anybody want to join me in a crusade to combat undersaucing?

Yum!

My calzone was very good and priced better than others I’ve had. I have one complaint. The sauce that they served with the calzone was cold. I don’t recall any other restaurant serving cold sauce. This is the only thing I didn’t like. Very nice place otherwise.

The personal pan pizzas they make are great. There are lots of ingredients for the size of the pizza and the crust is just the right thickness.
The staff are friendly and the manager is very friendly, trading jokes with customers and yakking while they make the pizza.
One of the great eating places in Broomfield.

Awesome! Nick-n-Willy’s is the first take-​and-​bake pizza that I have EVER liked better than already baked pizza! It is so fresh, the crust is perfect, the tomato sauce very fresh and not too intense, and the employees are so friendly!
Highly recommended!