Palermos Pizza

Food is just as remembered, good but not great. The girl behind the counter was borderline rude. Obviously wanted to be someplace else. If my wife wasn’t a fan of this place i wouldn’t come back

We just moved to the Buckeye area I’ve had this pizza near my work and loved it!!! And it’s just a good here we’ll be back!!!

I love that there is a Palermo’s less then 5 mins from my house! We still order it to be delivered once in a while when we are just too exhausted to leave the house. My favorite pizza topping is sliced tomatoes. Palermo’s is the only pizza place that slices fresh whole tomatoes for my pizza. Fresh tomatoes makes such a huge difference, it is delicious. They’re crust is thin and easy to bite/​chew, but still sturdy enough to not fall and drop all the toppings. I like that they offer oregano along with parmesan for your pizza. We always order either the pizza and wings special or 2 cheese pizza special. You can’t go wrong with 2 XL cheese pizzas for $ 24, it’s such a steal. They do offer pastas, and a few other dishes, but I’ve never tried them. We go just for the pizza and wings and we’re never disappointed.

This is the best pizza I have ever eaten!!! The wings had the right amount of sauce. The girls are always cheerful, when I walk in. I’m a regular & I think it’s about time I wrote a positive review. I don’t like some of the reviews in here. I’m from New York and this is the closest New York pizza you’re going to get in Arizona. My favorite: special pizza & extra hot wings.

Fresh salad, great bread and turkey sandwich.
But the Spaghetti was ⁶⁄₁₀.
They delivered under an hour to the RV park and the driver was friendly.
Thanks!

So rude!!! I’m visiting my family from out of town and I always loved to have palermos wings when I come to town and I called for delivery at 950 (keep in mind it’s a Saturday night) and they said I’m sorry we can’t deliver we close in 10 min… THOSE ARE STILL BUSINESS HOURS IF YOU ARE OPEN TIL 10… Get your $h:t together Palermos!

Their wings are pretty good. Usually my wife and I will get pizza from another place and order wings from here. Their pizza in the other hand is pretty gross. Not sure if it’s the cheese they use. But the smell, texture and flavor of their pizza is pretty bad. Hope they change their recipe on the pizza to make it better, since reading others reviews, I’m not the only one who thinks that. Another thing I’ve noticed is the smell of dirty mop inside when picking up my wings.

I’ve always liked thee food. Customer service– way better than most around here but nothing special. Who care because is eating there most times.
Gd prce s for wings. dam I love their beings. Just like LNG wongs. Order and eat!

Finally a pizza I reeeaaaalllly enjoy! This is the first review I’ve ever written. I just moved here a few months ago and I’ve tried quite a few
Pizza places and I’m happy to say it was delicious. Just the right amount of sauce, cheese and toppings. The crust is not too thick and not too thin. Oops, almost forgot to mention the mild wings were delicious also!

A decent slice. Wings arent bad either. Again, it wasnt the cleanest place but I was willing to over look that. The taste of the soft drinks though is what I have issue with. With poor water quality in Buckeye, the hard water adds a funky flavor to drinks. Most restaurants have added filters to their systems and that may be something that Palmero’s will have to invest in. Dont be put off completely though, Palmero’s does offer ice cold beers as well.

Palermo’s has IMO the best wings for a pizza joint in Buckeye. Their pizza is great, they are always courteous and the prices a great.

Large size slices, great meatball subs, and decent pasta selection. They get a Plus that they deliver locally. I would give them five stars but as a couple other people noted it is not the cleanest place in the world.

Good, best around anyway. Good pizza, wings are a bit small, dinners are satisfying but not great. I would and will go again. I might be harsh being from NY and of Italian heritage but its better than «fast food pizza»

Meatball sub and garlic knots are very good, pizza is ok. My biggest gripe is that the restaurant always smells like a sewer. Either the people there don’t notice it anymore, or they don’t care. What little décor exists feels sparse and out-​of-​date, primitive like a school or hospital cafeteria. With a little work, this could be a better place.

I think the guy I met was either the manager or co owner. I just moved here from San tan and this was the first place we visited. It was pouring down rain and my kids were craving pizza and wings. We had been moving all day and so many things were left in boxes I could not dare cook. I watched this man make everything from scratch and as I was asking him questions he actually answered them with enthusiasm. The food is great but the customer service is incredible. I placed a phone order and was given the wrong food. When I called in and explained the problem the same guy was very apologetic and offered to replace the whole order free. He said the young lady was new so I totally understood. No one is perfect but the fact that he cared so much about how I felt was amazing. I am a lifetime customer!

Ordered a pie and medium wings from here today for us and some out of town guests that we had. The service was great and very friendly. The food was hot when we arrived to pick it up. When we got home and opened it up it looked amazing. When we bit into it it tasted great. The wings had just the right amount of spice, and they were cooked perfectly. The pizza had just the right crisp on the crust. My guests were really impressed with the food choice. I personally have always liked the food from here, but today it truly was awesome. The only flaw that I have with Palermo’s is they are a bit pricey. That is why we do not order from there too often.

Flavor? Nope.
The pizza was a bit larger than I expected, and that would generally be a good thing, but there was almost no flavor art all.
I am originally from Chicago, and I therefore come with reasonably high standards when it comes to what makes a quality pizza. This place didn’t come anywhere near meeting any of them. The sauce was really bland. The sausage was in very small pieces on the pizza, and it had virtually no flavor. The parmesan and Chile flakes were at the counter to be taken to your table, but I didn’t notice that they were there until I was done eating.
The service was pretty decent.

Not good pizza.

The worst pizza I ever had ice tastes like sewer. I ordered a sub the meat was old and bread was stale. Service sucked don’t it here unless you want a stomach ache.

I’ve gone a few times, ordered something different each time, hoping that something stood out as good. No such luck.
Lasagna, manicotti, and of course pizza. Nothing was that good.