Big Pauls TNT Pizza

My husband and I just tried TNT for the first time last night. We ordered pizza and wings and were very surprised with how delicious the food was! We’ve tried every pizza place in the area and haven’t found anywhere nearly as good as TNT. The wings were perfectly crispy and the pizza was hot, extra cheesy, and cooked just right. My husband mentioned how friendly the staff was when he picked up the order too. It’s refreshing to be able to get great service and great food at a local restaurant. We definitely found our new favorite pizza place.

My wife and I pretty much only get pizza from here. It’s a sweeter sauce and has the spicy pepperoni cups and a great dough, without costing you a lot of dough. ;) :)
We often get wings with the pizza (usually medium), I prefer them to be more red and Frank’s red hot looking (saucy but not so much butter). I’m indifferent about them. Many restaurants make them like this around here, so… what can you do. It’s no duff’s but they aren’t bad.
It’s been a long time since I’ve had a sub from here, but I’m a steak and cheese sub guy. I didn’t care for the sub but didn’t hate it either. I prefer ribeye chopped up with little noticeable fat strings or pieces. The sub here wasn’t like that but it wasn’t bad. I’ve had a lot of good and a lot of bad. They are decent with subs.
All in all, this is… without any question, my default pizza place in the Tonawandas. Lockport is big on sweet sauce pizza too, but none of the places out there do it as well as TNT.
I am pretty snobby an unreasonable when it comes to wings and steak subs but try out TNT for yourself and make your own impression. Sweet pizza sauce isn’t for everyone but most times I have people over, they love this pizza. It’s a really good pizza place.
My only complaint is that there have been times I’ve wanted to order this pizza later at night and they are closed but that’s just me being selfish… and a credit to them for having pizza that I want at all times, lol.

I never write a review. The pizza is the best in town. I ordered the pepperoni and cheese pizza. Absolutely the best sauce in town. I usually go to Francos Pizza but they where too busy to get my order out so decided to try TNT Pizza and found a winner. The pizza sauce is sweat but is a great taste. And probably the best I have tasted. The pepperoni wasn’t too greasy and had great flavor. I hate greasy pizza so this was a perfect match. The cheese you can tell is real mozzarella cheese. This review is by A Best PCS.

I really want to like this place. Its right down the street, and I have had a few fantastic pizza’s here. But they have done EVERYTHING in their power to turn me off to this place.
My last 3 experiences here have been truly horrendous.
1. I ordered a simple Cheese and Sausage pizza and 20 wings, half hot, half BBQ. I picked up my order and got home only to find that my pizza was Cheese and Pepperoni, and my wings were undercooked and ALL hot. I assumed they gave me the wrong order, but when I called to complain, I found out they simply screwed up my entire order.
2. I figured this was simply an off night and thought I’d give them another chance. I ordered a steak pizza and 10 BBQ wings. I was very clear and specific that I can not have mushrooms on the pizza (My stomach does not handle mushrooms well, and those gross canned mushrooms take over the flavor of the entire pie), and I only want banana peppers on HALF. When I got my order home I found peppers and mushrooms COVERING my pizza. Not only that, but the wings were severely overcooked and they forgot my extra blue cheese.
3. After the last horrible experience, I swore I would never go back, but alas I found myself hungry late at night during a pretty intense snowstorm and TNT was the only relatively close place that was open. So I called to order a Chicken Finger pizza for pickup. I got my pizza home and, unbelievably, found that they screwed up yet ANOTHER order. The third in a row!!! To start, the pizza was absolutely covered in grease. There was about a ¼″ of grease covering the bottom of the box, and dripping off the pizza itself. In addition, they clearly pulled the dough right from the fridge without proofing it, as the crust was paper thin, chewy, and burnt. Not the usual light, fluffy, crispy crust with just a little bit of chewiness. This is the kind of lazy, unacceptable behavior only done by a third-​rate pizzeria. As someone who spent nearly a decade working in a pizzeria, there are often times where you do not proof enough dough for the evening and have to pull from the fridge, but it only takes about 25 minutes to get the dough proofed enough to give it the right texture. I would rather have waited an extra 25 minutes to get a good pizza than have yet another terrible pie.
It is always unfortunate when a nearby local place turns out to be terrible, but not even the convenience of their location could possibly get me back to TNT. I will never order from TNT Pizza again. The worst part is that when they actually get the order correct, the food is generally pretty good. However, it is simply not worth the time and money to gamble on whether they are going to make your simple order correctly.
Long story short, there are better pizzeria’s in the area that are far more consistent.

Awsome food. Pizza is fantastic and wings are good as well. Very consistant, haven’t had a bad experience yet.

Amazing what you can get for your money here! Their pizza sauce is sweet and addicting; their wings are never undercooked but crispy and you get a pile of french fries with the fingers. Try the honey barbq sauce (regular barbq not so good). Plus — they deliver — ON TIME.

You won’t find much TNA at TNT but that’s TMI, IYKWIM. Actually it’s a clever play on explosives, and Tonawanda/​North Tonawanda, the districts that this Pizza place straddles (minds out of gutter). There’s nothing explosive about the food, but it’s good.
TNT Pizza is fantastic. It’s one of the better Pizzas in WNY though it’s not Imperial and it’s definitely not Wiseguys.
But regardless of whether you love TNT’s Cheese and Pepperoni as much as I do, make sure you try Wise Guy’s aka Zips on Hertel. It will change your life.
Buffalo actually has the best Pizza in the world — it’s not quite like New York’s, and not quite like Chicago’s, it’s an entity unto itself and it’s the best I’ve ever had. This place isn’t really a good example of just how good it can be. Instead, I recommend trying one of the big 8: Bozanna’s (Clarence), Avenue (Broadway & Bailey, East Buffalo), Bob’s Poplar (Cheektowaga), Blasdell (southtowns), Imperial (South Buffalo), Zip’s (North Buffalo), Francos (Eggert location in Amherst), and Yogi’s (Akron). The last one is more Brick-​Oven style than typical Buffalo style, but all 8 are better-​than-​sex slices.
I went back to TNT a few times, and the most recent time it was not as good. I’ll have to try it again at some point soon to see if it has re-​discovered its former level of glories — I certainly hope so. Maybe I’ll stop by tonight.