Cape May Peanut Butter Company

If you’re a PB fan just like me, you will love this little, quaint shop.
They have all things peanut butter but not limited to it. They also carry: coffee, dog treats, cocoa, brittle, preserves, candy and of course organic peanut butter.
You can try samples of pretty much everything.
Worth a stop in if you are a PB fanatic.
Prices are reasonable. 3 – 5 bucks for 8oz.
Friendly staff. A little crammed inside when it’s busy. ENJOY!

Honey Roasted Peanut Butter is amazing! We ordered on line & delivery was very quick. I will definitely recommend Cape May Peanut Butter Company.

I had been on the hunt for a local nut butter place in NJ after moving back from Colorado. I stumbled upon an ad for this place in Edible Jersey and immediately checked out their website. They have a great selection of flavor and sized and are VERY reasonably priced. Everything that I have gotten is very good. I even ordered dog treats for a friend of mine, as well as some jam they sell. They are very personable and call when there are problems/​delays with your order. They also ship very quickly! I recently bought my largest honey roasted peanut butter ever — 32oz! This stuff is addicting. I hope to be able to take a trip down to Cape May soon to visit the shop!

Fun place to check out. We love the peanut butter selections and our dog equally enjoys the peanut butter biscuits. I always include a variety of snacks in my holiday boxes to mail to family and friends. A cape may staple

DELISH!
This is a hidden gem! They have a bunch of homemade peanut butter and little testers so you can try all the flavors. My favorite is the honey roasted… OUT OF THIS WORLD! Oh and they have peanut butter marshmallow which is the BOMB DOT COM!
The staff is so nice and helpful!
They have a ton of other knick knacks as well.
You can eat there as they have a bunch of peanut butter sandwich concoctions and a little seating area out back. I have yet to do this but can’t wait to try it out! I have also heard about their homemade hot chocolate which is on the list of things to try. Don’t miss out on this spot!

Little shop of yummy peanut butter with samples. Oh I love samples especially when they are gluten free which 75% of the peanut butter is. What a great idea and man can this place get crowded, because it is so popular. They have have tons of goodies from healthy to naughty depending on your mood. I love how they gave you samples as you helped yourself at the sample station with disposable paper spoons. All the samples are labeled above so you know what flavor you are trying. Feel like a sandwich they will make it for you! Perfect for the kids. Cookies, candy and even dog treats. What a great idea and wonderful additional to the area.

They have every base covered, including the best tasting/​sampling experience you could ask for.
Family-​owned place has the right ideology, sourcing supplements to their core nut butters from craft producers all over the country (e.g. jellies & jams).
You have to try the peanut butter hot chocolate!

The butterscotch peanut butter seems to be a favorite. And it was delicious– probably packed with extra calories though. :-O
It was tight inside with lots of people– but don’t let that deter you– it’s a cute shop. I wish that we could sample some jams they sold. They had sandwiches they could make and I think thats a great option for those who want to picnic on the beach.
The small garden out back is also a nice sit-​down spot. Their coffee selections seemed to be pretty unique although when you go in there is only two large coffee canteens to the left and some cold brews to the right.
Only issue is that they were staffed with three people but a bit slow. Also, while there were 15 people waiting to try to the butterscotch, someone was stocking the shelves beneath it when I’m sure they could have done that at a slower time when there weren’t 15 people on top of her, and (im)patiently waiting.
Lastly, someone mentioned tons of flavors to taste– I only recall maybe 6 – 7, but I could be wrong.
I recommend stopping by though!

This store is tucked in the back if the shopping area but a def must visit. I got a tip from a coworker to go and try the honey roasted pb. Delish!!! Ended up buying two tubs — for my dog of course. Interesting flavors like butterscotch, cappuccino, and sunflower. Lots of baked goods like dog treats, biscotti, and scones. Also an impressive selection of jams and teas. We got the coconut vanilla. And the Moroccan mint. Both very good and did not have any sugar added.

Really cool small shop serving up fresh and unique peanut butter flavors.
The staff here is very friendly and helpful, and you’re welcome to try out all their locally-​made peanut butters. Everything from traditional, to hazelnut, to cappuccino, to butterscotch. They have multiple container sizes as well, so you can get as much as your little heart desires. I liked the cappuccino flavor the best and got a tub of that.
They also offer up baked goods made with peanut butter — the peanut-​butter cookie is pretty dang good.
Check it out if you’re in the area.

This shop is a block outside the main strip of shops that I normally visit. If you are a peanut butter fan this is the place for you. You have the opportunity to sample all flavors of peanut butter and often other concoctions. Yesterday, they had out the nonpareils. Not my cup of tea but only because I really only like peanut butter as is. There are a number of baked items, jams, and even treats for your canine friends. The staff was very pleasant. I left with a small container of butterscotch pb, cookies, and a giant espresso pb cup. We already tried the cookies and can’t wait to dig into the other goodies!

If you like peanut butter and don’t mind receiving plentiful free samples of peanut butter then don’t miss out next time you are in Cape May. This quaint gift shop centered around all things PB is absolutely adorable.
They’ve got tons of flavors to choose from and every flavor has it’s own tasting station with a large pump of peanut butter that you can try by the spoonful. No one cares if you sample every flavor, that’s what they are there for! I had a few tastings but the honey roasted flavor really stuck out and I ended up buying a small container to take home.
They’ve also got a ton of other peanut butter inspired food items such as baked goods and milked shakes and there is a menu up with different sandwich options. If you are really into peanut butter you can get crazy and buy some of the peanut butter décor… I even saw a pair of peanut butter earrings. Although peanut butter has and always will be one of my favorite foods, I’ll stick to eating it and not wearing it.
This is a cute and funky shop and it’s something different to do in Cape May, especially if it isn’t beach weather!

So delicious. Sampled almost every flavor but purchased the Butterscotch, though I really wanted to take home a few! Also purchased some dog treats for the pups back home! Cute little shop and atmosphere.

Meh. I was really unimpressed. I often make my own nut butters at home because buying fresh, organic ones is so pricey. I’ve gotten creative and make some amazing fresh almond butter w organic almonds, hazelnut spread with real cocoa powder (aka healthy «Nutella»), my favorite salted chocolate cashew butter, etc. So I was expecting something GOOD here.
Firstly, I didn’t see anything organic. I would deal with that if the butters were out of this world. Tried the chocolate peanut butter — barely tasted the chocolate, they needed to add more. Just being dark chocolate in color is not enough, my friends. The almond butter wasn’t anything great. Again, the fresh stuff with high quality almonds is so much better. The butterscotch was mostly just sweet. And the hazelnut — well, I wouldn’t even try that because it said «hazelnut FLAVORED, does not contain real hazelnuts». Huh? What, are we worried about a NUT ALLERGY in a nut store??? I can’t figure out why you wouldn’t use real hazelnuts. Ick.
Even my son was uninterested after one taste. I guess if you don’t make nut butters at home and buy the high quality stuff, you wouldn’t know how good they can actually be and would enjoy the stuff here. But if you, like me, make your own or even spend a lot on the organic, high quality nut butters, then this place is not for you.

What’s not to love about a cozy store filled with all things peanut butter! Get ready to lick ~ taster sample «sticks» that is! Phenomenal flavors to entertain your taste buds. You can even order sandwiches to go or on warmer days, enjoy their café tables outside.