Sheetz

This Sheetz location is a family favorite since it’s so close for those of us living on Faith Circle in Carlisle. Since Wolf’s Bridge is closed for construction, it’s a little inconvenient to get to, but Sheetz makes it worth the extra few minutes to drive out for breakfast, lunch, or dinner!
The service is almost always quick here and in all the times I’ve frequented this location over the past several years, I can’t recall a negative interaction with any employees. They’re friendly, helpful if I’m looking for something, and they always greet my son with a genuine smile.
As far as selection goes, this location is typical of what we Pennsylvanians have come to expect out of Sheetz. They do have a soda cave and a car wash, which is a little unique. If you’re looking for an MTO or gas at the average price in town, this location won’t disappoint!

This Sheetz, and the rest of the franchise/​chain throughout Pennsylvania, is a reasonable alternative to the rest stops on the Turnpike. They offer many in-​house prepared fast food options and all the snacks and energy drinks you could desire. The price at the pump tends to be a few cents less per gallon than their opposite number on the toll road.
Most important, if you have a few extra minutes, it allows you to get off I-​76 and explore some of the local spots for a meal, restroom, stretch, or any other diversion. This one in Carlisle is very near several decent restaurants that can calm the road warrior in you, and make you smile again.
At least until you strap in and resume your journey.
Sheetz is on Rt. 11 South as you get off the Pike.

Food was not very good. They took forever to prepare one small sandwich & they still got my order wrong!!! Plus they were arguing with each other behind the counter. Wtf? I asked for a refund & instead was given two useless coupons since I don’t live around one of these places. Avoid this place!!!

Quiktrip has nothing on this place. It’s fortunate & unfortunate it’s a family run business and they have no plans to move west… at least not to Kansas City :(
I ate off their made-​to-​order menu 4 times while in Carlise for just 5 nights. They have it all & it’s semi-​gourmet. I had a turkey wrap with pesto… You can’t say that about any gas station near me.
Good going Sheetz family!

They just recently renovated this place from the crap shoot that it used to be, so I’m definitely fan of this now. Their Made-​To-​Order (MTO) stuff is surprisingly good and this place is one of the few highlights in Carlisle (yes, I’m a little cynical… and yes I can say this because I lived in this town for 7 years).
It’s new and clean and big. What else do you need from a gas station? Oh yeah, at night, you could probably see this place from the space station, it has that many lights.