Johnnys Pizza

Excellent stromboli. Also love the garlic knots.

My favorite pizza place in Carrollton! Can’t go wrong with the buffalo chicken pizza! Service is always top notch here as well. Spend a few more bucks and stay away from the Pizza Huts and Papa Johns. Johnny’s is the place to go in Carrollton!

Not saying the food is perfect as in a $$$$ restaurant, but pretty legit/​outstanding for a chain/​cheap price. My braces doesn’t allow me to try pizza but pizzas on other tables look pretty good. I had lasagna, which is wayyyy better than Olive Garden, wayyy better than a $$$ Italian restaurant in Alpharetta. Actually it wasn’t bad compared to some small restaurants in Italy.
PS: fiancé used to live around this area and would visit once in a while. The food quality has been up and down a bit depending on their chef/​cook change, but overall hasn’t been too bad.
Service was prompt and warm.

Good food overall and a great community environment. But I go out to eat for both food and service. I would easily vote them slowest and least attentive restaurant in Carrollton. I say this after more than a dozen visits. So overall, food is 5 stars and service is 1 star averaging out to 3.

The manager screamed and cussed at a close friend of mine for calling about a pizza he ordered that never came. Good food does not make up for atrocious service. So if you’re looking to be verbally assaulted, this sounds like the place for you!

I love Johnny’s pizza but this location completely misses the mark. My waitress was very nice and friendly, although she messed up my order. The cook on this day, was disgusting. As a healthcare professional I almost wonder how they are still in business. He not only coughed on his hands multiple times without washing them, he also sneezed on the place he was preparing the food… twice! Each time he DID NOT wash his hands, he touched the dough and toppings with his contaminated hands.
On to my food, my knots were already precooked when I ordered which was strange because A. It says to allow time for perfection right on their menu and B. There was one other table when I came in and C. This is the first time I’ve ever had this happen. I shrugged it off, when I tried them they were half cooked and I couldn’t eat them. My pizza, after being corrected, came out undercooked as well. I am extremely disappointed.

Best pizza in town.
Plus they have calzones, stromboli’s, subs, and awesome salads.
Make sure to order the garlic knots!

Can’t believe there aren’t more reviews! Staff is friendly and beer is ICE cold. I sat at the bar and was promptly greeted. Prices were fair. I will be back when in the area again!

I travel for work and eat out for every meal. I wish was staying in Carrollton another night just to eat here! It’s hard to find good pie unless you’re visiting a large city when the competition is so high.
I ordered a couple slices of the Buffalo and Deluxe. Each slice was piled with delicious toppings! I also ordered the caprese salad and it was also delicious!
The delivery didn’t take too long at all. They forgot a fork, but luckily I’m staying at a hotel and there are bigger issues in the world than a missing fork.
Keep up the good work Johnny’s!
Also, I attached some pictures of the menu for easy viewing.

Johnny’s definately has the best PIZZA in town and the waiters/​waitresses are very friendly and go out of their way to be helpful. They are extra busy on the weekend so be prepared to wait a bit. At the moment they are very short staffed & they are overworking their best, hard workers it seems. Maybe this will change in the future…

I always come here for a sandwich and a calzone when I’m in town. They’re the only place in town I know of that does all the classic menu items every pizzeria should, and they have a proper Italian sub. :)