Longbranch Pizza

It was good. Ordered a 3 topping medium pizza which was perfect size for 2 hungry people, had a couple of pieces left over. We were taking a motorcycle ride, so we also got an italian sub to share later down the road. The sub was actually really good cold, so I could just imagine how it could’ve been hot. We seem to always ride pass this place when we ride East, so we may need to stop again for a hot sub.
Keep in mind, looks like this place may be family owned, & they only had 2 people working during lunch time on a Saturday, but everything was still pretty prompt & they were still really friendly & helpful.

Wow, I was really surprised at how good this place is. Apparently there is a vicious rivalry between the two local pizza places in town — Pizzaburg being the other one. In fact, I was told this one was going to be mediocre by comparison.
I’ve had just cheese pizza from here because that’s what I prefer. The service both on the phone when I ordered and in person when I picked it up was friendly and welcoming. The price is reasonable and it feels good to support a local place.
I was a bit worried that the crust would be too thin, or there would be too little sauce or cheese. So I have to admit, I ordered extra sauce and extra cheese both times I’ve ordered from here just to be safe. And that order made my pizza just right!
I say, if you’re going to Centerburg or just passing through, give this place a shot!

Good, but not great. I prefer my crust to not be soft. Service was quick. Nice dining area with sports on the television.

Some of the BEST pizza Ive had… EVER!!! The pepperoni is my favorite! Try the Bosco Sticks too, they are cheesy bread heaven! :)

I went to this pizza place while driving my friend back to Kenyon/​Gambier/​Mount Vernon, AristoCrap City, Ohio and BOY were we hungry. We drove around a couple of grain silos talking about how much we wanted pizza (and I don’t even LIKE pizza unless it’s in a chicago-​pie-​dish) and LO AND BEHOLD, Longbranch Pizza appeared out of the wildersom darkness. They were playing Looney Tunes cartoons on a giant TV in the corner and they delivered the finest thin crust mushroom and bell pepper pizza I have ever laid tongue to. Also, the retro décor made our poor starving asses feel right at home: wood panelling, Elvis memorabilia, a pinball machine, the works. I like that there are no servers: you order from the counter and wait in the restaurant for your food. More or less how every pizza place should operate! PIZZA OF MY LIFE. I would go here every day if I lived in Centerville, good thing I don’t!