Graeter’s

Graeter’s really does make some of the best ice cream ever. It’s a truly Midwestern old-​fashioned ice cream shop in the best way possible. Everyone who works at this location is super friendly and helpful. The Buckeye Blitz is especially delicious!

I love (d) a few specific flavors from Graeter’s, most of which did not contain the «chocolate chips,» that Graeter’s is certain everyone loves. They have done-​away with several flavors, and replaced these with even more flavors with chocolate chips. So now, a majority of flavors are heavy chocolate chips. Chips is a misnomer. These are huge chunks of chocolate that are very hard, because they’re frozen. I really enjoy eating the ice cream, and have to pull large, kid-​you-​not silver-​dollar sized chunks of chocolate out of my mouth, so I can move on with more ice cream. Not my thing. I have moved-​on to other brands, now, as a result of this.
Compared to the TriCounty Cincinnati store, this location is missing bakery items, as well as the nice chocolate and candy selections. Beyond that the place was operated by a group of high school students. They need a bit more guidance on cleaning and customer service.
1 of our group decided to pass, since the flavor he wanted was unavailable. 1 of the group settled for an alternate flavor. 1 of the group was totally satisfied with their visit. So of 4 people, only 50% were satisfied with their visit, and that 50% influences the 3^rd, making a 25% return rate from the group.

This is thee thing to do in Centerville on a warm evening. I’ve never had Graeter’s ice cream before, but I knew it was expensive because I’ve seen it at Costco for $ 12 for half a gallon. Parking lot is a bit congested as it shares with the also popular City Barbeque. Wife got the black raspberry chip and I had the Buckeye sundae. Verdict — black raspberry chip in a waffle cone was the winner; and probably one of the best ice creams I’ve ever had (although almost $ 3 for a single scoop, plus a $ 1 for the cone). The Buckeye Sundae comes with peanut butter ice cream — single scoop almost $ 5. This place is definitely quality over quantity, but I’m a fan and foresee several hundred visits on warm evenings.

Graeter’s you have GOOD ice-​cream! I’m a fan.
I always feel a little hurried when I’m here because the line is typically out the door and people are craving that ice-​cream. You can see them salivating in line! The Graeter’s employees are nice, but they too, seem a little harried. (Probably cause they’re dealing with all the salivating ice-​cream customers.)
The aren’t a TON of flavors here, but enough to make you go hmm… what do I want? Graeter’s also offers sorbets and sundaes. My brother-​in-​law swears by their sorbets (pronounced sore-​bet by him.) You can get your ice-​cream in a cone or a cup. The cone selection is almost as good as the ice-​cream selection. My only beef… no cake cones!
On my latest visit I ordered the mocha chocolate chip ice cream and their dark dutch chocolate mint gelato. Oh my… heaven.
If you’re in the are and screaming for ice-​cream, scream at Graeter’s.

Best. Ice. Cream. Ever! Graeter’s Ice Cream is made using the french pot method and is still hand packed. Ask to taste their flavors and you’ll receive generous bites. The chocolate chunks in the ice cream are sometimes large, and are so good!
Favorite flavor? Black Raspberry Chip. During the Christmas season ~ I highly recommend the Peppermint Stick ice cream. You won’t be sorry! We’ve had this ice cream shipped to us many times with great success. One time they forgot to put dry ice in the container. I called and without hesitation, they shipped another container to us. We moved to the east coast and last year we were so excited to find pints of Graeter’s Ice Cream in some of our local grocery stores! Thank you Graeter’s!

The flavors of ice cream are always outstanding! If there are any drawbacks to what they serve, I’d say the overabundance of chocolate in their «chip» ice creams might be just a little bit too much of a good thing. That’s really the only knock I’ve ever had against them. The have a gorgeous variety of flavors and their toppings are really good.
Flavors? The black raspberry chip is classic, as well as their peppermint stick, summer peach. There had been a tangerine flavor that was over the top. Don’t know when they will have that again. For the new gelato flavors, the hazelnut truffle gelato is a force to be reckoned with.

I am a huge fan of fruit and chocolate, so this line-​up of flavors was insane! Black cherry chip, black raspberry chip, banana chip, etc!!! After some generous samples, I settled in on a double scoop of BC chip and BR chip. The chocolate is plentiful in huge chunks and the fruit flavors are rich and on point. Good quality ingredients here. Great surprise on a business trip to the area!
I’ll be back tomorrow to pair the banana chip with peanut butter chip ;)

Bottom line: Graeter’s is a Dayton-​must-​try… Over and over and over again.
Best flavor? Black raspberry chip (see photo). It comes packed with big chunks of chocolate for those of you who are looking for a fix. Make it a double threat by putting it in a dark chocolate waffle cone. *drools*
Graeter’s is truly one of Dayton’s best. Unfortunately that’s why they can charge so much per scoop. I can’t complain though since I keep going back for more. Maybe one day I will try another flavor… Maybe.
Tip: Sign up for a Graeter’s Sweet Rewards card (no charge) and get a free sundae on your birthday!

I really loved this place because the ice cream was delicious but when you walk in, it had a comfortable feel to the place! Also there are benches outside so we ate ice cream as we watched the cars go by… Yes I’ll be back!

Graeter’s was one of those places everyone told me to try when I moved to Dayton. After some procrastination I finally did. The ice cream is pretty good I just don’t seem to love it as much as others. Personally I just don’t find that they have much variety in flavor of the actually ice cream. They have a variety of sundaes and milkshakes but the actually ice cream not so much.
I definitely go to Graeter’s whenever I am in the mood for something that isn’t Diary Queen but there are still better places in my opinion. Definitely check it out if you are in the area though.

This is good ice cream. I liked it. I’m not sure I like it as much as most people, but I’ve never heard anyone speak ill of it. It didn’t totally knock my socks off, but then again, it was really built up for me.

What’s better than delicious cookies & cream ice cream? Eating it on a bench with friends on a quiet summer night in Centerville. Add to that a little people-​watching and some cute dogs, and you have a little scoop of heaven.

Graeter’s has been in business for something like 150 years, and you don’t last that long if you’re not doing something right. It’s basically the best ice cream you can get around here.
I think the secret is in their chocolate chips, which are soft and rich like a ganache or chocolate truffle. And often, they’re the size of small candybars. If you’re having a chocolate craving, one of these bad boys will take care of it in no time.
My favorite flavor is the black raspberry chip, but my kids (and I think my husband) would definitely vouch for the Buckeye Blitz, which is chocolate ice cream with peanut butter chunks and chocolate chips. They make a mean waffle cone and also have pretzel cones for that salty-​sweet effect.
It’s not something you’d want to eat every day, but if you’re gonna splurge on some ice cream, this is the place you want to be. Not that overrated place that rhymes with Mold Bone.

Having tried famous ice cream shops and brands all over the nation, Graeter’s is still my favorite, AND it’s founded in Cincinnati, OH! It was also featured on Oprah and named one of the top 10 ice cream shops in the nation in an article featured on Yahoo!
Graeter’s French pot process of making ice cream churns out smooth and creamy ice cream that is to die for on a hot summer day! Locals love it so much that we frequent Graeter’s in the fall and winter as well! The store provides a homey feeling and this one in downtown Centerville provides outdoor seating.
I would say the most popular flavors are those that include Graeter’s homemade chocolate chips, which are by far my favorite of any chocolate brand and just melt in your mouth! Must try flavors include Mint Chocolate Chip (my fav!!!) and Black Raspberry Chip. Those are probably their two most famous flavors! If you have more of a sweet tooth, go for the Mocha or Toffee Chip.
You won’t be disappointed!