New York Pizza

Best Pizza in Charlotte. PLAIN AND SIMPLE! They Do it right. Great owner and operator.

Price went up will not be buying pizza here anymore 30 bucks for a large pizza crazy!!!

The five star is for their tasty food. I have always gotten food delivered so never been to their restaurant… Yet.
I am super bummed out that they took off the combo pie (a pizza with any 4 toppings of your choice). That was my go to all the time… This might decrease the frequency I order from then now. :(

Nasty! I was so excited to check it out after reading all the great reviews. Just went to NYC in Oct so wanted to compare. Sorry not NY style pizza.

One of my close to home «Go To» pizza spots. It’s good. Traditional, fast casual, New York Style pizza. Family owned and operated. It’s got your standard Pizzeria menu with subs, salads, some pastas, apps, and of course pizza. They are reasonably priced and the owners are friendly. They used to have it set up so you could see the pizza being made, but now there’s a high counter blocking the view. Too bad, I like being able to see the dough being stretched and the skill of the kitchen workers. Everyone should have a pizza place like this close to home!
One of my favorite things about the pizza is the crisp crust. This is easy to find when eating a reheated slice, but not so easy when you order a whole pie. They make one of the crispiest fresh pie crusts in Charlotte. There’s always a nice snap. This pizza will fill you up, it can be heavy in the belly, but comfort food does that. This is better pizza than most in Charlotte.

We ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza and garlic knots. Everything was fantastic! This will be our new goto for delivery pizza. Can’t wait to try other items.

The Margherita is pizza pie perfection. Never an issue with delivery. Highly recommended!

First time here. Food is good and hot, staff is friendly and clean. Resturant is clean. I will be back.

This pizza is so awesome!!! I am so excited that they are in Charlotte…
I am a NYer and this is the best pizza I’ve had in years!

We are SO grateful to have a good pizza place so close to home. Consistently great service and delicious pizza. Not a big fan of their sausage pieces, but other than that, we’re always happy to grab a pizza to go and share it with our family and friends.

Let me start that I really wanted to like this place. Being in town for 1 night in a hotel with no car, and reading the great reviews on Unilocal I thought for sure I’d have a knockout meal that’d be delivered to my door. Boy, was I disappointed. Try as I might I just couldn’t enjoy much of this meal.
I wanted to try a bit of everything so I ordered a regular slice, a stuffed slice, a side salad and some buffalo wings. Here are the pros/​cons of this meal:
PROS:
— friendly service, from the person taking the order to the delivery guy
— quoted delivery time was met (45−1hr), delivery guy even gave me a ring to give me a heads up he was about to arrive
— salad was good and fresh
— portion sizes definitely match the price, the slices are BIG, toppings were plentiful
CONS:
— wings were a bit overcooked and tough
— the stuffed slice was dry, almost like a pressed panini
— holy salt lick batman, both slices were so incredibly salty that my mouth and tongue were left numb. You can barely taste the toppings, especially in the stuffed slice which probably had an entire shakers worth of salt in it by the taste.
Maybe it’s much much much better if you dine in, I can only hope so. But based on my experience, once is enough for me.

I’m from Brooklyn, NY so when I say the pizza is good, the pizza is good. I was lucky enough to move to Charlotte and find New York Pizza. I always order from here and it’s always on point. Keep it up New York Pizza! 5 stars! The sauce, the cheeze, the crust… mmmm!!!

This is probably in my top 4 favorite pizza places in Charlotte. Its as close to real New York style pizza as you can possibly get in this city. It’s very unassuming as it sits in a strip mall but go in, and you know its going to be legit.
They have a pretty extensive menu too, past just pizza’s they have wings (that we’d like to try), entrees, and desserts. Other than just their regular slices, they have this one called a «Stuffed Slice» and seriously, one slice is enough for a family! Its stuffed with pepperoni, meatballs, sausage, and bacon and its a meat lovers dream.
My only downfall with this place is they clearly get a lot of delivery or pick up calls or something because when we go in, we definitely find ourselves waiting for a pretty decent amount of time before we get our food. Also, they’re closed on Sundays, which is just ridiculous for a pizza place, but, it is what it is. If you’re looking for New York style pizza, come here.

As far as casual pizza joints go, this is def a top contender. Cleanliness, service, prices, and food are on point.
Their New-​York Style pizza is delicious. The crust is baked well, the cheese is great, and the toppings are… so good. It’s pretty amazing that they can deliver a tasty slice at the right price.
As for atmosphere, it’s a clean restaurant that is thoughtfully put together. What really please me was that each booth had a paper towel rack installed with seasoning right below; once I’m chowing down on my pizza, I am not getting up for anything! So with everything I need is conveniently placed near me, I enjoyed every bite without having to move.
Service is nice and friendly.
I would return here for lunch or for a late night snack. Def worth a try!

My friends and I are coming back from a trip to Florida. It’s an 11 hour trip and we’re exhausted so we decide pizza is gunna be the way to go.
I’m a big fan of New York style pizza. It’s probably my favorite. I’m no connoisseur but I definitely know a thing or two about good pizza. We ordered a large pizza that was half pepperoni and half spinach.
Once we opened the box, I was mesmerized. It was so neat and the toppings were abundant and evenly distributed. The pizza was also delicious! It was nice and cheesy just the way I like. The crust was also just the right thickness for maximum foldability.
They do New York style pizza right. I was not expecting that from this little pizzeria in South Carolina. If I didn’t live 1000 miles away I would definitely come more often.

This is my go to pizza joint in the Queen City. The pizza is delicious and the boneless buffalo wings are on point! When I’m in town I make it a point to stop in once or twice, usually twice.

Ordered pizza from New York Pizza the other night, and I was quite satisfied. Pizzas are large — we ordered two larges for eight people and had plenty left over. The garlic knots were amazing (as everyone else has mentioned), and the pizza was tasty as well. We got the «two larges with one topping each» special for $ 25, as well as wings and garlic knots. Wings a little small and not anything special, but garlic knots were great. Only downside with the experience is that the delivery boy must have tilted the box when on his way here — pizzas were smooshed on one wall. Otherwise, perfect experience!

Delivery at a Hotel on ¹¹⁄₅
Garlic Knots were some of the best I had every had — seriously good!
Side Salad added cheese and asked for Caesar Dressing (extra) — and it was much bigger in size than I thought it would be. Lettuce was crisp & fresh.
Got a medium pizza with Pepperoni, Onions and Sausage. I was debating on adding banana peppers and the gal said, why not just get them on the side. it was prefect — that way they were crisp and fresh and not cooked.
All this food and delivered for less than $ 29. Great value, quick service and great food. Cant go wrong here!

Great place, tasty food! Went hungry and ordered so much had to take the rest home.
Single slices are huge like 2 pieces in one. The stuffed pizza was great and not chewy or greasy. Got the tuna sub, very good. Slice of pepperoni and the Sicilian way better than any other place. Fuel pizza in town can’t compare, wish there was one in Rivergate!

Attn all Northern imports! Get cha pizza here!
No seriously. This is authentic New York pie that I’ve been searching for awhile now. They deliver to Southend too. Quick! Doesn’t get better than that. Fah get abou itttttt