Nick’s Pizza

I ordered for the 1^st time from Nicks on a boring Saturday morning at work. (I just started a job in the area)
I placed a delivery order online around 10:45am. They don’t open unit 11:00. It said I’d get my food at 11:45. At 11:15 the driver shows up with my food.
It’s cooked exactly the way I requested, piping hot, and nice portions!
Great customer service, great food!
The only place I’ll eat at when I’m down here from now on.

The Buffalo chicken stromboli is my favorite! It’s cooked to perfection every time! They’re wings are pretty awesome too! (Can you tell I’m a hot sauce fan?) I get the curly fries with almost everything I order and they’re great as well! I’ve had their cheesesteaks too and wasn’t disappointed but there wasn’t anything that really stood out about it. Service is good and delivery is pretty quick! I’m only giving 4 stars because I’m not a huge fan of their pizza, but I’m also really picky about my pizza.

I grew up using Nick’s in Elmer but that was closed down a few years back so I decided to start using the one in Clayton. I really like this Nick’s. main reasons being that you can place your orders online without having to call in, plus the price and quality of the food. Pizza is pretty good. not greasy and gross like a lot of places. Has a good crust that isn’t flimsy.
Sicilian pizza is also very good– crust isn’t crazy thick either — something I have always appreciated with Nick’s pizzas. Burgers are good, chicken parm is good, fries are delicious, onion rings, salads (which ARE huge and they also have a good raspberry vinaigrette dressing), BLTs… everything I’ve had from here has been up to standard for the price.
Another bonus with online ordering is that you can earn points towards a $ 10 off a $ 15+ order coupon for every $ 100 you spend. You also get to take advantage of the online coupons and the delivery tracker. Delivery does take a while. but I don’t hold this against them. I’ve never waited more than 1hr 15mins for delivery and I’m two towns over. Delivery people are always courteous. and beings I’ve never actually called in to place an order … I can’t complain about the rest of the staff. I’m happy with this establishment.

Very rude and disrespectful. Waited an hour and a half for a delivery that never came. Even after the charged my credit card, they tried to blame me for their delivery driver never knocking on my door. I’m done with Nicks, their customer service sucks! A bunch of rude kids that don’t know how to speak to someone who is spending their hard earned money to keep you in business!

Nick’s makes up the plaza that is the center of Clayton, NJ (hometown pride!!). They are best known for their large, square shaped, party pizza. I personally am not much of a fan as I find it to be too doughy. Their sauce is good –people can get really picky about pizza sauce in these parts– and like all Southern NJ pizzerias their menu is expansive, including sandwiches, salads, Italian-​American home-​cooked meals, and appetizers. Overall it’s pretty good if you just want a slice or french fries.

Pretty good service. I love sicilian pizza so if thats whats your into i deff suggest going here.
I personally really like the hot roast beef they fill it up with nice hot roast beef and i like .that the condiments are put underneath the filling its easier to eat and it wont fall off?
This is personally a great place to go for a nice evening with the family or friends. But remember its still just a NICE pizzeria do not go there wanting to be waited on or anything!

Count your change. Pretty blond hair girl at the register short changed me.

When I read one of the previous reviews, I though to myself that the salads can’t be THAT big. They are gigantic! I’ve never ordered a small anything for a complete meal, and a small greek salad with chicken was more than enough. Tasted good, though it was still just a salad. The spicy chicken salad is nowhere near as good as the greek salad, but it is ok.
The pizza was Sicilian style. I had a slice of plane cheese. It wasn’t bad, kind of chewy crust and the sauce needed a bit more spice, but I have definitely had worse.

One of the best deals around! You get huge portions of food, and if you join their point system (by applying for a free Nick’s card), you get discounts after every certain dollar amount spent. The sandwiches, pizza, salad, pretty much everything there I like. You can feed a family within a totally reasonable budget, so it’s totally worth it. They recently revamped the inside, so it’s very clean and modern looking. If you get the salad — make sure you get the smaller size because even the small is HUGE. You won’t be disappointed!