Godmother’s Pizza & Subs

Hands down my favorite pizza in the area! Their sauce is the best! They also make a killer Stromboli. Always consistent and delicious.

Quick, delicious and great price. Ordered 2 of their subs for delivery. They arrived very quick and they were large enough that I had one half for lunch and the other half for dinner. Tonight I tried their pizza and wings and happy I did. It was $ 10 cheaper than my alternative and only a 15 wait. Oh and delicious. One thing I will recommend for people like me who like a more saucy pizza is to request it, I will next time! Overall two very good experiences!

I’m a fan of their bottled pasta sauces and I always wanted to try out their pizza place. Well today’s schedule accomodated this. Tried some wings (hot), breaded mushrooms, an eggplant parm. sub. and a pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and green peppers. Rest assured if you want to wrap up the review here, I’d definitely recommend this place. Everything was very good!
I was impressed with the wings which I just picked up as a simple «add-​on» to my order. They were very good as were the breaded mushrooms.
My least favorite of the group was the eggplant parm. sub. While it was good, something seemed to be missing — it’s straight breaded eggplant, cheese and sauce on a sub roll. I guess for myself it could have used something else (pepperoncini, tomatoes, etc.) but, overall it was decent.
The star of the show though is the pizza. Good amount of toppings and the cheese they use is excellent. Only thing I ordered extra sauce on the pizza and paid for it. There was no way I could say there was extra sauce on the pizza. Not a single drop of sauce fell onto the plate or was left in the box. None the less, I would venture that this has to be one of the best pizzas in the Parma Heights area.
Note the store is in a Discount Drug Mart complex at York and Ridgewood Drive. It’s takeout only!
When I am in the area I will definitely go there for takeout. It’s well worth it!

Great pizza! Have been ordering it for the past 6 years since moving to Parma Heights. They have great sauce and my family loves their bosco sticks. They also sell their sauce and have their own organic bottled tea. The only downfall is the delivery time, normally an hour to an hour and a half. If you want it quicker definitely pick it up! Besides that, the pizza is great, the prices are reasonable, and we haven’t been able to go back to those chain pizzas since! Haven’t really had any of the other food but I wouldn’t hesitate to try it!

I do not live in Parma, infact, I live about 20 minutes away from it. My coworkers told me about Godmothers pizza and how good it was, so after work one day I stopped by to try it. I didn’t know at first that it was a carry out only place, but when you walk in, you figure that out pretty quick, no tables or chairs. So I ordered a medium mushroom pizza. All I have to say is AWESOME! I have not had sauce like that in a long time. Plus the cheese combination is different than most pizza places, heavier on the Parmesan side, which is delicious. Needless to say, when I got home, I had already eaten half of the pizza in the car and wife was not to happy… Oh well, it was to good to wait.
Since then, I have been back about 7 times and loved the pineapple and jalapeño pizza! Even though we live out I the way, whenever there is a talk of pizza, I drive out there to get it.
They really need to open more locations or change spots. If they were on the west side, they would have so much business… Definitely worth the drive. Try it for yourself.

I have been living in Parma for three years and have tried many pizza places. Godmothers is by far the best pizza in town, I always recommend it.