Your Pie

Awesome. The pizza cost is thin and crispy and not too bready. Loved the toppings. We wants Gelato but was way too $$ for our taste lol. You will not be disappointed!!!

First time my sin and I went, the service was great and the food was good. The second time, my salad was wilted, good thing I still love the pizza.

Whenever I get tired of my husbands and daughter choose of pizza, I head to Your Pie. I love that I can have whatever I want on my pizza and enjoy every bite all alone. Brick oven pizza is the best and they deliver it just right.

Love the food and loved the vibe. I made my own pizza that consisted of bacon, spinach, pineapple, artichoke and sundried tomatoes. It was different but delicious.

So we absolutely loved this place ! It’s a bit pricey as you order individual sized pizzas only which makes feeding a growing family of 5 a bit on the pricey side but it’s worth trying Atleast once as the quality and tastiness is so good! Parking is a bit difficult during busy times but cool atmosphere and we will most definitely going back!

I loved the quick, casual walk up counter and build your own pizzas! I wish we had one in Orlando because I think it would do very well. When you walk up you are greeted by a friendly employee who gets whatever dough you choose started for you. Pick from original, whole wheat or gluten free and watch as your personal bit of dough is tossed into a pizza pie. I chose the great white and added mushroom, spinach and fresh garlic. There are a large variety of toppings available! From your typical sausage and pepperoni to less common ones like broccoli or corn. We also tried a seasonal pie called prosciutto and peach with a balsamic drizzle. The serve beer in bottles and some local brews on draft.
After paying you sit and your pizza is brought to you as soon as its ready. The pies are little so they don’t take long. These little pizzas were really good! My favorite was my great white– the added mushrooms and spinach gave it a rich flavor. The prosciutto and peach was different– sweet and salty, but was not something I’d probably get again. If you’re looking for thicker crust or large pies to share you won’t fin them here. It is fun to play with ingredients without committing to a big pizza you (and your friends) won’t enjoy. The employees were all very friendly and even though it was busy no one waited long. It was a good experience and everyone at our table enjoyed their our pies.

This pizza is awesome! It’s like subway for your pizza. Fast and affordable. They also have healthy options as well. All pizzas are made right in front of you so you know they are fresh. Will certainly be returning again!

Very good pizza! Thin crust, which I like. Customizable, which is customer-​friendly. Took «The Nat» pizza & subbed sausage/​meatball for chicken & added green olives — delicious! They will cook 1 – 2 min longer if you want crispy. Tiramisu gelato was yummy. Breadsticks are good, but didn’t care for their marinara.
Friendly staff. Greet you w/​a smile & show flexibility. Clean dining area, but a little small. BONUS: they do give Military Discount.

Highly recommended and plan to go back, real soon! Staff is extremely friendly and everything is made right in front of you! It is all fresh and ultimately scrumptious! The Lineage was so delicious! This place brought back memories of my first real pie in Verona, Italy… not exact but very close! Look the menu over before going and re-​look when you arrive, you will do a double take!

Great food great service a lot of options would definitely recommend checking this place out. Will come back for sure!

Interesting concept; like Chipotle but for pizza.
You pick the crust, your sauce (including hot sauce?), your cheese and finally your toppings, of which they have many.
Then they bake it in a brick oven (thin crust) and bring it out to you when it’s done.
It really doesn’t take all that long either.
This was my first visit and it was pretty good. I get the fresh mozzarella and mushrooms and it was as good as anything in Columbus.
The place isn’t fancy strictly fast-​casual. But I think a pizza and a drink cost about $ 10. They don’t charge you by the topping so go crazy.
They do serve limited wine and beer.
Worth a visit.

This is the best pizza in town. Customized pizza — the way you want it.

Believe the hype. Why are there no1 or 2 star reviews for this place? Because it is awesome! The pizza was fresh and good, service prompt and a great value for the money. They are a small chain but will hopefully grow. If this is an example of what a standard Your Pie is, they are destined to be the next big thing. BTW save room for the gelato and all you mil peeps, they offer a 5% military discount.

Amazing food, amazing staff, amazing toppings. I go here way too much than any normal person should. I usually get the same thing and the workers definitely know my order to the T. For someone who has issues deciding on what to get, this place lets me get just about everything I want in one pizza!

It is hard to mess up a pizza and even harder to separate yourself from the crowd. This place is the latter… I was impressed. There are a variety of salads, panini, and pizzas… All cooked items are done in a brick oven. The ingredients were fresh and the service was stellar. If you like a little spice, I suggest the Southern Heat Pizza consisting of chicken, hot sauce, jalapeños, red onions, and mozzarella cheese. You can even add any non-​meat ingredient for free… I threw on garlic and spinach that took the pizza to the next level. The pizzas are 10″ with white or wheat flour.
If you are looking for a nice casual place with some delicious pizza, this is the place!

$ 9 for pizza and its 10inches only.
If you eat like a horse like me, it is not enough. The pizza itself is very good ⁴⁄₅. Made Fresh. They cook it up for you in the oven and have to wait a few minutes. It’s like the chipotle of pizza– where you pick the ingredients you want. Id come back but not as incredible as some of the ratings Ive read.
I orderEd a side of their pesto sauce which made it better… Up to a ⁵⁄₅.

First time getting a pie here yesterday. I think I’ve found my go to pizza spot. Small pies with my choice of toppings, and didn’t feel disgusting hours later after eating a cheat meal. Yay!!! Not to mention I can add in as many veggies as I want with my decent proteins. Winning!!!

First time in Columbus so I consulted Unilocal.Based on other’s reviews we decided to give it a try. Very helpful website, we have dietary issues to consider with one in our group. The service was great and the pizza was delicious. The «design it yourself» concept allows everyone to get exactly what they want. I gave it four stars instead of five due to the pricey topping additions. We are already planning on stopping again on the way home!

Where do I sign up to invest in this thing?
Simple, accessible and with great ingredients, both of my meals here (pizza both times) were impressive. Can’t wait til the next time I’m in town so I can start trying the paninis.
Hoping they keep up the great work… just fantastic!

Discovered this late in our time in Columbus. Wish we would have found it earlier. You can eat as healthy or unhealthy as youd like! You can even get nutrition facts for every item!