Conway Pizza

The dry seasoned wings are amazing. 4 stars for those alone. They are giant full size wings. It was awesome that they packaged them in a paper bag that preserved the crispiness for the ride home.
(A styrofoam container is the place where good take out food goes to die)
Lots of Beaver County joints have great wings (Kendrews, Harolds, Luanne’s) to name a few, but I gotta give the top spot to Conway Pizza. If you’re a dry seasoning fan like me, you have to give these a try.

Little pizza joint with no seating. Never tried the Pizza, but they have wings that taste a lot like Harold’s Inn down in Hopewell. Only difference, they’re bigger and taste better. Wish it was a little cleaner looking. Wings are so good I force myself to overlook it. Oh, and easily the best stuffed peppers I’ve ever had… no joke. Really though, justbclose your eyes, order, and enjoy.

Composite.
I am a fan of this place. Huge indoor oven. Excellent sandwiches (and prepared to custom order). Quick service. Hoagies is all I ever get there. Price is EXCELLENT, and wrapped in foil to keep warm on the way home. A wonderful place to stop on the way home from work. Pizza and Hoagies. Easy access from the street, adequate parking. For the hoagies, I always ask them to crisp them up a bit.
A neighborhood institution for sure.
NOTE — they are a combined PIZZA and HOAGIE place. The name is a bit misleading but then again virtually all pizza places do multiple items. Yes, Unilocal in SF…
f8 and be there.

First, don’t buy the Gift Certificate currently listed on
as they will not honor it.
Second, don’t eat here.
Even though they wouldn’t accept my GC, I ordered anyway, a $ 50 order. Everyone was complaining about how chewy the crust was. My sister who lives nearby says this place is very inconsistent. It is hit or miss as far as quality goes.

I’m new to this area and I really have become a fan of this place. Now, with the word pizza on the sign I bet you’re thinking to try the pizza. Don’t. Ok, maybe try the Sicilian but don’t waste your time on the pizza. Sauce is decent but the crust is just a little chewy and pretty bland.
BUT if you want something great try their hoagies. I’ve had the steak and the hot italian NUMEROUS times and they always impress. Decent size, great price (under $ 7) and tasty as hell.
Tired of those? Try the calzone! Thick and full of good stuff I get these when they are on special on tuesdays (buy one get one half price) and with one exception have been awesome.
I kept hearing this place had great wings but have a rule about ordering wings from pizza places (its like my rule about dating whackadoodles, but sometimes rules are meant to be broken) and recently tried them. They are FANTASTIC and cheap on weds. Try the mild first because either my affinity for hot food has diminished with age or the hot is way too hot. You can’t go wrong with these and you’ll miss out if you don’t at least try them.
Anyway, they are quick, will deliver for $ 6 min order and overall have been consistent.
If there is any knock on them for some reason they close early on the weekends. I called at 9:45 on a friday to order a sub and they were closed. They also close really early on sundays. I don’t get that. Close early on a tuesday, not a weekend day.
I mentioned to the owner that I wasn’t a fan of the pizza because of the crust and his response was «well, that’s because they didn’t cook it long enough…». Ummm, well, that sounds like a management issue, but he didn’t seem too concerned. That’s ok, i’ll just take the steak sub please.

Decent Sicilian pizza, and they will deliver for like a $ 6 order. I really like the fish salads here. They also have a variety of appetizers that aren’t bad for Beaver County food.