Matt’s Pizza

I went to pick up a pie, was told it would be a couple mins, waited 20 mins only to find out they had forgotten it and it was sitting there getting cold.

Went here based on Unilocal reviews and wasn’t disappointed. Good pizza at a good price. If you are looking for fancy, go somewhere else. I f you are looking for good pizza, give Matts a try.

Great pizza… not salty like many other places. Have never tried food entrees but hope too soon. I like that they deliver too.

Decent pizza. Food terrible. Yes, the crispy crust is good… get over it already! I’ve tried the food several times. Cheap on portion and quality.

I love Matt’s Pizza! I’ve used them several times to cater a last minute dinner party (literally like an hour before) with my in laws by getting a half tray of chicken francaise, my favorite. It is always accompanied by extra sauce so I can make my own noodles as well as a tray of nice warm fresh bread. In addition, their pizza is great! The crust is just the best! Love them! Definitely recommend!

awesome food! free delivery too!

Like another reviewer, we live across the street from Matts. Their pizza is always good. Their crust is like no other I have ever tasted. Even the toppings are fresh and tasty. It’s just a plain unpretentious pizzaria… nothing fancy… but you can’t miss with their pizza. It’s just always really good!

Always good pizza every time I go! I love the crispy crust that they have and it’s all real pizza! They have a little dining area where you can eat and they also have Italian ices. You can never go wrong if you get pizza from here!

Always pleased with Matts! We get this pizza once a month and it’s always good. The crust is one of a kind and like others eluded to, it’s no frills, just pizza. So good!

Good place to eat for a quick slice of pizza.. Which they had more selections of pizza. Prices are reasonable. I recommend the mozzarella sticks

Best pizza in Coram, Selden, Port Jeff Station area. You can’t beat their crust. It is simply the best and trust me I have had them all. If you want a specialty slice this is not the place for you, but their plain, white and Sicilian is awesome.

People on the phone were very friendly and the pizza wasn’t that bad. I love the crust but seems a little dry. Overall it was a good experience

This place is surprisingly decent. We got a coupon for a free pizza when we moved into the neighborhood so we decided to give it a go. The pizza is decent… they use semolina under and on the crust so it has that extra crunch, the sauce is good and the cheese is not super greasy. They deliver fast and their prices are super reasonable. They don’t have alot of choices in toppings, but it is a good option if looking for an affordable, tasty pie.

Great Pizza! Love the semolina crust. Crispy, crunchy. Pepperoni is good. Mushroom is good. Chicken Parmesan hero is also good!
I will definitely go there again!

Great food, new menu, affordable, great taste and great value

Ok… I’m gonna chime in here. Some mixed reviews, but I decided to try it since it’s practically across the street from where I live. I figure… If I can’t get a fresh, hot pizza from this joint, then something’s wrong.
It showed up fresh, and hot… and probably one of the best pies I’ve had in a long time. Crust is thick, but not too thick — covered with that rustic crunchiness I thought I’d never find anywhere again — crisp on the very bottom, but soft and chewy. Good quantities of toppings, and a flavorful sauce.
Loved it!

I remember when this place opened. It had great pizza. One of my top three places for pizza on long island. Then after years things changed and the pizza was horrible so I stopped going. A few weeks ago I went back cause there was a coupon and was shocked to find they are back to the way they first were. The pizza is amazing again! I will be coming a lot again!

I feel compelled to write this review after I saw the 1-​star rating.
While I still lived in the city I came home from spending the weekend at my summer cottage on Long Island and and took a new route home. On our way home we stopped at a pizza place late at night and I remembered that slice of pizza for years but couldn’t remember the name of this little gem of a pizza shop or how to find it again.
When I moved out East I found this little diamond in the rough again by accident — and it and it was Matt’s! Since living out here I’ve ordered (for delivery and pick up) several times and I’ve always been very happy with their pizza. It’s simple, nothing fancy or gourmet, and I love the thin, crunchy crust. I usually go for their Neapolitan pie but once I tried their Grandma, which is my second favorite type of pizza. It was basically their regular 18″ round pie with cheese directly on the crust and sauce (loads of it – too much of it) on top of the cheese. No garlic, no basil. I was disappointed so I just wouldn’t order it again. Next time I think I’ll try their Sicilian…
One little tip: If you call for delivery at around 1:00 p.m. the soonest you will get your pizza is about 2:30 — something about not having a delivery person between 12:00 and 1:00.

nothing fancy or amazing but the pizza is quite good if you like those simple thin crust gooey fold over and eat style pizzas, great prompt delivery if you live in the area, plus it’s cheap

this place served probably the all time WORST pizza I have ever tasted in new york. the sauce was a step up from ketchup… the cheese was undercooked and the crust was covered in burnt semolina… gag!