Cirello’s Pizza

Best pizza I’ve ever had. I don’t get the bad reviews. The pesto sauce is amaze! And they have roasted red peppers that are made authentic Italian style. Love love love love love love

I am updating my earlier review; as a gluten-​free gal, I have given Cirello’s several chances and it’s a done-​deal; they make the worst, most bitter, texture-​repulsive crust in town.

I know that I’m spoiled by the east coast, but if someone is going to say their pizza is «New York style,» you would expect they would deliver a better crust.

Best lunch special on spaghetti! Friendly staff and good beer on tap plus I’m watching sports. It doesn’t get any better!

So tasty! Happy hour is a great deal on beer and cider! The Rinz is my favorite pizza!

Our family orders pizza every friday night. Recently younger members had lobbied for a new pizza supplier, so we had been trying out Cirellos. The first week, we ordered the pizza, it came in less than 45 minutes and was really good. The next week, things did not go as well.
I called, ordered the pizza, the nice kid on the phone advised it would be delivered in «45 minutes to an hour.» I hung up at 5:43. By 7:03, the kids were starting to bounce off the walls and I figured I would check on the pizza, maybe the driver got lost. This is essentially how that conversation went:
me; Hi, I was calling to check on our pizza.
her: Oh, we are really busy tonight, I am sure its on the way.
me: Could you check anyway.
her: just a minute. (a few minutes later) it should be there in an hour to an hour in a half.
me: are you kidding? thats 2 and an half hours for delivery!
her: well, we are *really* busy tonight.
me: but when i called the guy said it would be here in 45 minutes to an hour.
her: well, i don’t know what to tell you, he shouldn’t have said that. (direct quote)
me: i’d like to speak with the manager.
her: just a minute (a few minutes later) oh the delivery driver just came back. he will deliver your pizza soon.
me: I’d still like to talk to the manager.
her: hold on. (another few minutes later) he’s really busy. he will call you back later.
well, the pizza showed up about 15 minutes later around 7:40. the manager never called back.
My take on this: Cirrellos has great pizza and seems to have plenty of customers. They made it clear they don’t need me, so I will be buying my pizza elsewhere.

Terrible with quoting times for pizza pickup. I waited an extra 40 minutes beyond the 35 I was quoted. Really frustrating.
The pizza crust is great — soft top, crisp bottom — and is the only reason this isn’t a one star review. I still wouldn’t wait 1.5 hours for a small pizza though, especially after being quoted 30 minutes.

Honestly, I have never had better pizza than I had tonight! I am a garlic lover and the sausage and salamis were just perfection on the Cirellos special. We just don’t feel like you can do better in Corvallis for pizza! We have been coming here since it opened but tonight’s pizza surpassed all others.