Hometown Pizza – Crestwood

Decent place. The price of the food was good, but you also get what you pay for. It is not amazing quality, but it is pretty good for what it is. I had the chicken Alfredo which was $ 6.99. I saw the basic Alfredo pasta which is what I got without chicken was only $ 6.29. The difference in pricing is the fact that the chicken is not truly real, but rather a compressed chicken product. It is still chicken, but it is not nearly as good as real chicken, of course. I also ordered a glass of Merlot, and it wasn’t that good, but what do you expect for $ 4.50. It was passable. I was a little unnerved with the restroom, meaning the men’s toilet was very tiny. I am not a small man, but I am not a big one either. For me to say that, it has to be tiny for anyone. Also, there was not a coat hanger in the men’s restroom, so I was forced to hang my coat on the air freshener dispenser. The service was very good. Meredith, my server, was very nice and pleasant and very responsive. Not a bad place, but also not amazing.

The building itself is older and a bit of a dump and very cold inside. The pizza is pretty decent. I enjoyed the Bbq chicken pizza. The salad bar was pretty good but could use a few more veggies.

My buddy and stopped in for pizza a couple of weeks ago because we did not want to drive to town. What a pleasant surprise. Great pizza. Good service. Cold beer. Will definitely go back if I am out that way again in the future. Recommend.

Waiting for a take out and watching the long haired guys making pizzas with no head covering, guys plating bread going to tables with no gloves on, guy walks in off the street, logs into work, goes straight to making pizzas without washing hands and no hard or hairnet.
What a shame.

I remember going to the Hometown Pizza locations in LaGrange and Crestwood when I was a kid as a special treat, this I’ll always have fond memories :) My husband and I still pop in the Crestwood location from time to time, usually for the lunch buffet. You can’t beat the price! I think it’s $ 6. I really enjoy their pizza as well as their baked spaghetti, which I have even replicated at home because I like it so much. The service is always attentive and friendly.

Fast lunch option. Pizza pretty good. Good bread sticks. Buffet available for lunch so it’s fast and ready when you arrive. Will cost you about $ 10 to $ 11 depending on tip for lunch. That includes a drink. Very attentive and nice wait staff.

This place is great. The breadsticks are as awesome as they say — my particular favorite is a thin crust option with garlic. I also really enjoyed their thin crust pizzas — I think this place has mastered thin crust offerings.
All the staff was very attentive and kind. AND the price was fair (for buffet).
Will be returning.

It’s all about the breadsticks, which are more like cheese sticks at a chain restaurant, but better. We always get the large order, and we all enjoy it more than the pizza. Otherwise we usually got Joe’s Special or Southwest Chicken pizza. They have specials going on during the week, with their breadsticks or kids eating free, it’s worth checking.

While roadtripping from Nashville to Cleveland with twin two year olds, we stopped in for lunch at Hometown Pizza. It was a little bit after lunch time, and most tables were full. The pizza came out quickly, and the service was good. The pizza was definitely not the best, but did the trick for the little ones. I probably won’t come here again.

Consistently good pizza. By far the best in crestwood area. For local pizza this is the best and our #1 choice.

Pizza was okay, good price but you can find better pizza around.

Fantastic crust and sauce. Family atmosphere.

Went here for dinner two Friday’s ago with a group of friends. I honestly wasn’t expecting much because the other Hometown Pizza is pretty bad. So, I decided to try the buffalo wings dinner. Wings are usually good anywhere you go, as long as they are cooked enough. When I ordered, I specifically asked the waitress to have my wings cooked ‘crispy’. she told me it would take a little longer, which was fine. When they bring out the food, my dish was the last to arrive — I expected that. What I didn’t expect were chicken wings with rubbery skin, not crispy. I didn’t have time to re-​order so I just ate them. The meat was cooked at least. I assume they must pre-​boil the wings before a quick drop in the fryer. My friends ordered the «house specialty’ thin crust pizza. It was truly the thinnest crust we ever saw. It looked like a tortilla and apparently wasn’t the least bit filling. Bottom line, the Crestwood Hometown pizza is as disappointing as the La Grange location.