Brothers Pizza

Great pizza and friendly takeout service!

Everything here is made fresh daily… and it shows. The fry their sausage and bacon everyday… veggies chopped fresh… great crust, great sauce! Very small seating area, so would recommend avoiding dining in during peak times. Delivery is a local option.

Good pizza. Quick delivery. This last order we had pizza, calzone, breadsticks, Stromboli, mozzarella sticks, salad, and spaghetti with meatballs. The baked (dough) items were burned but the last two times everything was fine. I’d stick with the pizza here.

Pizza was very good. My kids loved it too. The wings were good as well but i had asked for a few extras they repeated over the phone and then did not bring them. Over food was a five but attention to detail was a 3. I would order again.

I’m not a pizza fan, but out of the choices in Crystal River, this one’s the best. I prefer take out over eating in. We’ve experienced some interesting service from the waitresses. They do have some decent specials and they do deliver.

Amazing pizza! Place is clean and people are friendly. They aren’t stingy with the topping either. If you’re in the area and craving pizza, you won’t be disappointed.

I’m so happy my family and I stumbled upon this place. We’ve dropped in almost weekly for over two years now and we have yet to be disappointed.
Tons of options on the menu, and every single one of them is well-​executed. Good prices overall, but especially on their daily specials.

I grew up in nyc and I live in Chicago and brothers pizza has really friendly Staff and great pizza! My sister ordered the Greek pizza and loved it, and I had a mushroom spinach and olive pizza which was really good as well! My mom was not a huge fan of their pasta because she thought it was too garlicky, so maybe stick to pizza (that being said my dad who loves garlic was a fan) We also had the garlic knots which were fantastic! Seriously not to sound like a snotty New Yorker but I didn’t expect pizza of this quality!
Our waitress was super friendly and helpful even though we came close to closing time!

Picked this place based on positive Unilocal reviews. Got a medium cheese, pepperoni, sausage and bacon for pick-​up and took it back to our hotel. It was delicious! Crust was excellent. Would definitely order again if we were local!

My wife & I have always been chain store pizza people until about six months ago. Now it’s Brother’s exclusively. Best locally made pizza around, bar none. Everything on the menu is made fresh to order and fantastic.

Amazing Place to eat. The food was awesome. Great Pizza, great bread knots and the bread bowls were good also. The staff was friendly and attentive. We come to Crystal River once a year and we will def make this a repeat restaurant.

Wanting something with some flavor to it. Debated… mexican, pizza, ribs… Hmmm.
Ended up here and boy are we glad we did.
Located in a strip mall, very clean, (bathrooms spotless), small but comfortable.
Ordered a large pizza with a few customizations. Came out as ordered, in a timely manner.
We are full time RV’ers and have been disappointed in our pizzas all across this great country.
This one has a great crust, not too thick, not too thin. A good sauce that actually has flavor. Generous portions of toppings.
Another plus, every day between 4 and 7 pm. Two for one beers.
Staff and service were excellent.
We are in the area for another ten days. We will be back!

Placed an order for delivery. The guy on the phone wasn’t very nice, but the pizza was awesome. Got the chicken & broccoli, huge pieces of pie that had me wanting to eat more!

Not exactly New York style pizza but pretty close. When I want good pizza this is one of the places I order from.

What a great surprise! Great pizza, the garlic rolls are to die for. We had the nicest waitress. Highly recommend.

I am super picky about pizza. This place is good and decent prices. The pesto pizza is amazing!!!

We like this place. They make a nice pie. Good crust. The folks are always polite. We are a carry out customer but always enjoy being greeted at the counter.
Sausage and pepperoni pizza with Garlic! The car stinks after a 10 minute ride. Heavenly.

A while back this location held a quite nice Italian/​Pizza restaurant (don’t remember the name) which I enjoyed very much, but it disappeared for some reason. I was again in the neighborhood and saw that the spot was now Brother’s Pizza, so hoping that the previous place’s Karma was still present I dropped in for lunch.
The interior is small but comfortable and clean. My server was friendly and efficient (and also very pretty, but that doesn’t impact the review). I had two slices; one pepperoni and one veggie combo, which was spinach, tomato, peppers and ‘shrooms with a white sauce, as well as a soda.
First — Both these slices had ABSOLUTELY THE BEST CRUST I HAVE EVER HAD. Nominally «thin crust» pizza but not New York thin, it was a perfect combination of light, tender, firm and crispy but not crunchy. Even the outer crust without cheese or toppings was heavenly — I did not leave a crumb.
The sauce and toppings, especially on the white pie were also first rate and plentiful. One slice of pizza would have been enough for a lunch with a side salad, but I wanted to try two different types.
I will be sure to come back and try some of their other Italian food, as the orders of pasta etc. that I saw being served looked mighty tasty (but it will be hard to beat the pizza)!

I think this is the best pizza in Crystal River, Fl. I have lived and traveled all over the country so I know a good pizza. I had given up on getting a good one here in our little town. I found Brothers last summer and have been going there ever since. The only reason I did not give them 5 stars is because of the price of the salad. If you subtract items from the garden salad you don’t like and ask them to put in items you do like they charge you ala carte for each item. So a 7.00 salad became a 12.00 salad. And I’m talking veggies here, not expensive ingredients like meat or seafood. So I just never order the salad anymore. So keep up the good work.

Pizza by the slice place. Basic ones like pepperoni and cheese, as well as fancier selections like a tomato, mushroom, spinach one with a garlicky white sauce. A selection of 5 – 6 pizzas at any one time, including one deep dish for those who love their bread, and garlic knots. Also had whole pizzas and basic pasta dishes, though I don’t know the details.
Service during lunch was fast, they pop the pizza back in the oven to warm and crisp it. All the pies looked fresh, ready for a quick reheat.
I had a slice of the tom, mush, spinach. The crust was crisp and flavorful, plenty of spinach, white sauce was balanced, with good flavor and not oily. Not a fan of canned mushrooms, but it’s expected at most joints.
For 3.25 per slice, it’s good pizza at a decent price. I didn’t see if they had lunch slice specials, will update review if I see something.
Service was fast, polite, and efficient. Couple tables outside for the smokers, or to enjoy the sun.
Easy to find in the Publix shopping center, at the south end.
Will definitely be back.