Pizza Heaven

Have been going here for years. Love this place!!! The family and staff that run it are so nice. The food is amazing. I’ve never had a bad experience here!
Love their wheat pizza crust too. Portions are large. Great selections too!

We went on an extremely busy night, perhaps that is why things were not running smoothly. Nice table, friendly staff. A lot of take out customers. My chicken sandwich, came with cheese, which I specifically asked, no cheese. The chicken was dry. The homemade chips were great. My wife’s dish, cheese pasta dish came out still frozen, sent back and it still was not hot on second time back to the table. The dinner rolls seemed under cooked. Our guest enjoyed her ziti dish. The salads seemed ok. I had to ask for a refill on my soda. Not sure, if I will give it a second chance.

I know this doesn’t matter to many people, but upon being seated, I was informed that there are absolutely no gluten-​free options on their menu. Thankfully, I’m not celiac so I didn’t have to disrupt the large group we are with, but I will certainly deal with stomach issues as a result of this. I recognize that there is no requirement that a restaurant have a gluten free menu, but the majority of places make an effort. I’m surprised and admittedly I am disappointed. I’ve heard amazing things about this restaurant and now there are virtually no opportunities for me to enjoy their fare… I’ll give them4 stars; however, as everyone else is enjoying their selections.

I am writing this review strictly about their pizza. I ordered the lunch special 2 pizzas and a soda except I don’t drink soda so they charged me $ 6.50 for 2 slices. I waited about 15 – 20 mins for my pizza to arrive to my table which is way too long in my opinion. I’ve had a whole large pizza baked in less time. The restaurant was busy as it was lunch time but they should be prepared for that. Pizza was average at best. Cheese and tomatoes were falling off with each bite which I hate. Pizza didn’t have any sauce on there either. I like homemade tomato sauce on my pizza. And the pizza was very floppy so it made it difficult to enjoy. I won’t be returning here at least not for their pizza.

I am a pizza lover and this is no heaven. I got half buffulo chicken and half margherita. Cost $ 25!!! Worth $ 5. Absolutely nothing special about the pizza. Crust below average. Cheese okay. In other words. Never again. Anthonys coal fire across the street is much tastier

Amazing pizza, especially if you order it double dough style. It’s a little out of my way but I always go here when I’m in town

Thanks for another great dinner… I don’t like eating in the restaurant is old school pizza place that’s not very attractive… Pizza is average but the golden gem of pizza heaven is the entrees the sausage and peppers is to die for… And the stuffed shells are like momma used to make… You must try this place not for the pizza but for the meals… I always order out because of the atmosphere but the food is awesome

Had heard really good reviews about this pizza restaurant from my neighbors on our local Weston FB pages. Finally had an opportunity to try it today. Was in the area running errands and popped in for a slice. My husband is watching his figure and didn’t order one but when I saw how big the two slices I ordered were I gave him one. Before we even tasted it, my husband who is Italian and an excellent cook said that he could tell that they use good cheese by the color of the grease on the plate, lol! I have to say that he was right. The pizza was absolutely delicious! We are from NY and we know good pizza when we see it. This one for sure does not disappoint! Our waiter was very friendly and attentive. We will definitely be coming back for more. Keep up the good work Pizza Heaven!!!

Pizza was first off extremely greasy. Soggyness level 7 – 8 with very flimsy slices soaked in grease. The crust had very little taste as well or might have been drowned out by the grease. All of my co-​workers including myself had upset stomachs due to the grease.

I was actually on my way to McDonalds to get something to eat but then I saw this pizzeria and was curious. The servers were very sweet. They were constantly checking on us making sure everything was ok. We ordered the garlic rolls as appetizers which came out pretty quick. I was very happy with how fresh the bread tasted. Then we shared a large pizza which was awesome. For dessert we had a Nutella pizza which was even more amazing. I definitely wouldn’t mind coming back.

The food is excellent! The service was great. The place is small and quaint. We loved the pizza and mozzarella sticks. The chicken parm sandwich was really good and the homemade chips were to die for.

For a local restaurant on the fringe of Weston I would rate what I had as very good. Crust, pizza sauce and cheese worked, very good garlic rolls and same for broccoli rabe with garlic and oil. Definitely recommend this joint.

5 stars all the time! I am a regular here. My boyfriend and I come here for «Pizza Party Friday» (something between us, not the restaurant) and it never disappoints. The service is great and beyond friendly, and the food is delicious.
Feels like I’m in an Italian home.

I finally went to this place for a sit-​down dinner; something I have been wanting to do for a while now since I usually only order take-​out pizza for lunch. Finally had the chance to try an appetizer, too. We went with the stuffed artichoke. It was such a different yet tasty dish. It’s basically an artichoke that’s cooked in this broth and stuffed with breadcrumbs and other goodness. The garlic rolls were also really great!
I didn’t think the pizza here could get any better, but it did! Fresh and hot out of the oven, amazingly delicious. We had ½ Margarita and ½ Benny’s Pizza. Not one slice remained! I was so stuffed from the pizza and was about to pass on dessert, but then I saw a waitress walk by with this huge delicious cappuccino and tiramisu — I couldn’t pass on it. The cappuccino was perfect. The tiramisu I took to go and ate it when I got home. It was good, but was just a bit lacking in coffee flavor.

Absolutely amazing, never fails. Doesn’t matter which chef is in the kitchen. Everything that comes out, every day at any time is Delicious. I have tried them for lunch and for dinner and it has NEVER FAILED. You CAN NOT go wrong with coming here individually, With a Group of Friend or with your Family. The meals that come out of the kitchen are absolutely Delicious. Exquisite cuisine at a reasonable price, No wonder The Rock eats here.

Best of the best of the best. The only problem: one location. Normally I finish off a statement with a boom. This place is double boom!

Pizza heaven is a family oriented pizzeria that will not disappoint!!! My nieces are regulars here, so when I asked them where they wanted to eat they knew this was the place! We ordered soooooo much food and all was sooo good… I felt disgusted with myself after eating it all. but it was soooooo good! I ordered a pie half mushrooms half chicken and it was yuuuumy!!! We also had the garlic rolls, a salad, beef carpaccio and Calamari as an appetizer… it was alll soooo good!!!
The restaurant’s atmosphere was very good and the server as well as all the staff, were very very friendly and helpful. The food came in a timely manner and the overall experience was great! A must frequent place.

Customer service and food is TOP NOTCH!
I took my son here last weekend to check it out and we really were in Pizza Heaven.
Frank and his sons and staff are really welcoming and friendly. They are Sicilian and so am I so that’s a huge bonus for me because it had the family feel like I was at my Nonna’s for Sunday dinner and that’s exactly what it felt like after I left. Full belly, satisfied and happy.
We ordered the beef carpaccio-​so incredible. Really fresh. They even put a nice fresh salad in the middle and it was really fresh and savory.
While we were eating the carpaccio the waitress asked if we preferred plain or garlic rolls-​garlic hands down. She brought us 2-​one for each. Heaven again in my mouth.
We ordered the Benny pizza and oh my god. Out of this world.
We also ordered one small tiramisu made by the owner. The best I have ever had.
I want to note that I read some reviews about leftovers being soggy and sauce being watery on their pasta and calamari being soggy after taking it home. Earth to dingus: calamari and pasta need to be eaten fresh at any restaurant. Take home containers continue to steam your food which means soggy everything. Pizza take out is one thing, but you can’t take home fresh and home made Italian pasta and fried squid and expect it to be the same quality afterward. Don’t mark down the restaurant because you don’t have common sense.

I’ve been coming to Pizza Heaven for years now for their pizza. You really can’t go wrong. But i’m basing my review on my delivery order, a dish I’ve never tried before; the Maine Lobster ravioli.
I was very disappointed. First off, on their menu, certain ravioli entrées (and appetizers), as well as stuffed shells, or manicotti, they clearly state how many it comes with, 2, 4, 6. Well, my order didn’t state the quantity. So I’m expecting a regular full pasta dish. It only came with 5. If I knew, would not have ordered it, especially for $ 16.95. You can choose vodka or alfredo sauce but I substituted for marinara. The marinara sauce was very watery.
All pasta entrées come with 2 garlic rolls and a side salad. The dressing that they put to the side is very good, super zesty. But just because its a side salad doesn’t mean it should be put together without heart or care. It had 1 cherry tomato and 1 olive, very odd. and the lettuce itself looked old. I had to add croutons of my own to give it some life.
To finish, I tried their chocolate fudge cake. For $ 5.50, I’m expecting a great slice, a slice you just want to ditch the dessert fork. It satisfies that obnoxious sweet tooth that pops up after a meal (or in this case, a not-​so-​hearty meal), but I would not recommend it. I think I will just stick their awesome pizza pies.

Best bet for take away pizza in this area. NY-​style that is… The pies only come in 2 sizes– basically a single pie and their «Large» pie I think is more like a medium pie anywhere else. A family of 4 really has to order 2 large pies — 3 if they want leftovers or if there are some hefty pizza eaters in the house.
Personally, I’d skip the other classic Italian meal dishes on the menu. I tried the eggplant parm dinner once and was disappointed with the flavor, consistency– but $ 12 including salad, pasta and garlic rolls — a very reasonable deal.
The place is pretty small but you can easily grab a table on weeknights– later the better. Weekends — order and take out. Grateful for the tasty slices close to home.