Sgambati’s New York Pizza

Excellent!!!
Kelly our waiter was helpful and fun.
Food was above our expectations.
Bone in wings highly recommended!

I’ve had sgambattis about five times now, different types of pizza and garlic knots and what have you. I’ve traveled most of this country and consider myself well versed in pizza quality. Unfortunately, this place never met the hype so many from Green Bay have proffered.
The pizza tastes mediocre, but for the price it can leave some to be desired. The quantities are large, so that makes up for it. The worst problem I’ve had is how every single time I’ve eaten there or gotten it to go, it has made me Ill. I figured this a coincidence, so I tried a few more times. Every time, cramping and the runs. I don’t understand how people can stomach this, but such is life. Get some glass nickel or anything else, or just don’t eat. You’d do better.

Ordered a calzone and some garlic knots from them and wasnt impressed at all. They said it would be delivered in an hour an hour and 15 minutes later they called and said the driver would be at my place in 15 minutes, a half hour later he finally showed up, and didnt carry any singles for change. Then the food was hot but was subpar at best. I will not be going back to Sgambatis.

This was our first time there. After ordering two pizzas and garlic cheese bread. The cheese bread came immediately and was good. The pizzas came after 1 hour 15 minutes. One pizza was burnt and the other was pretty good but the crust was very tough. How can this be New York style when it tastes like they use frozen crust. Needless to say we probably won’t be back.

I love Sgambati’s, been here dozens of times. We love the New York style pizza, garlic knots, the Manhattan bowl, and the stromboli. The service is really hit or miss, whether it is busy or not, the service can be very frustrating. The food is delicious, you just can’t be in a hurry.

I feel obligated to update my review as my experience has improved over the years. My main concerns were around customer service and I have seen some major improvements. The food has always been good and I look forward to being able to recommend Sgambati’s to my friends confidently. I’ll be dining here again.

I’m having a hard time going between a 1 star and a 2 star review. The atmosphere is nice, and the bartender was very friendly. We were seated at a table that had a direct view to the pizzas displayed for slices. That was one problem. I’ll get back to that in a minute.
Our waitress seemed frazzled, maybe she had too many tables, not sure. Needless to say, it was a little slow. We weren’t in a hurry, so it didn’t bother us too much. We ordered 3 slices total and a Greek salad. The salad was just o.k. It had sliced black and green olives on it. I am pretty sure Greek olives are Kalamata, NOT canned sliced black ones. It came with Ceasar dressing… don’t even get me started. When we got the salad, we had about ¼ of the container filled with the dressing provided. They had run out, and were going to get more. So basically, someone was running to the grocery store to get some dressing. Needless to say, we never received any more dressing or were we offered a different type. Not the best start.
Back to where our table was located. I had a direct view to the cooks. Not a good idea at all. I was horrified to see how the food was being handled. Apparently they do not have a spatula to serve a slice of pizza or do they wear gloves. I saw our waitress go back there and put our slices into the oven herself since our ticket had gotten «lost». No hand washing, One of the cooks with longer greasy hair, which was quite stringy hanging out of his stocking cap, wiped his nose and shirt quite often before he would man handle the pizza slices with bare hands. It was horrifying to watch the whole thing.
We finally received our warmed up slices after about 45 mins. The waitress apologized, and my husband confirmed with her that she had to put them in. Two of the three were good. The teriyaki chicken was good, but a little pineapple would have put it over the top since it had a little kick to it. Also very good was the teriyaki beef and broccoli. The mac and cheese was unedible. I’m pretty sure there was a cheese spread (like you use on a cracker at a supper club) as the «sauce». The kids have had several other mac and cheese pizza, and have never left a bite. More than half of this one was left at the restaurant. My husband tasted it and deemed it disgusting.
Definitely NOT somewhere we will go back. Quite disappointing.

Fantastic staff and wonderful pizza. This is a very relaxing place with great people just off the beaten path. Recommended highly

Love it. Been there about 5 times and never a complaint. Little bit of everything on the menu is a plus. Made it in to the new location once, just as good as the other

I have been to the Depere store before and had ok service. I thought I would check out the new one today. Worse then I expected. We sat at the bar. A girl took our order and then we never saw her again till after we were done with our food! Which was a really long time as our burgers took half hour or more to get and all of our food came out at separate times. The other waitresses did take care of us as good as possible with all the commotion going on. Overall I really don’t think I will be back. I’m disappointed cause I work very near and was happy to have a new place opening!

Been there a few times now. The last two times had the calzone, which is huge! Comes with a large side of marinara, which tastes homemade. For the kids they get a single slice and we typically get the garlic knots.
If you order the white pizza it has little blobs of ricotta on top, which we love.
Service is fine.
Will keep going back.

Very good pizza and pasta! They also have a nice bar area with a lot of good drink selections. I have been going here for years. It is a bit on the pricey side for being a pizza place, but still definitely worth a visit!

Came in on a Sunday, waited an extraordinary long time for our SLICE of pizza that they simply needed to warm up, all while tolerating a bloody mary. I recommend finding a more efficient and delicious place to enjoy your meal vs. this Sbarro’s-like pizza joint.

We stopped in today for lunch. Food and service were both very good. Would recommend to friends.

Went for lunch based on Unilocal reviews. The Greek salad was very good. For the price it was very big, as opposed to the chains that have been increasing prices and shrinking the salads. I also had a meat lovers slice. Came out nice and hot with lots of toppings. They have outside dining in the back overlooking a small pond. Very clean and open bar area.

We have only ever gotten delivery so I can only speak to that service and I have no complaints. Food always arrived before their estimated delivery time and was hot and fresh.
I have gotten the white pizza a few times and it was amazing each time, will look forward to getting it again! My dad got the supreme and said it was really good too, great flavor. Have also tried the garlic knots a few times, again, great flavor, lots of garlic! My only suggestion would be to serve the garlic knots with marinara.
I will definitely recommend Sgambati’s for pizza. Look for a coupon on their menu or the website for an even better deal as well.

Bring your appetite!!! You get ALOT of bang for your buck at Sgambatis. The portions are large, really good pizza, location somewhat inconvenient. Beware of items with ground beef though — they serve those frozen round dog food pellets :)
Outdoor seating around a really nice duck pond. My partner and I often order lunch to go and we usually get one salad which is plenty for 2 people and pizza by the slice. We have tried all their pizza and only found one we didn’t care for — the ala vodka which had frozen breaded chicken on it. If you eat in the service is hit or miss and the place is not normally crowded as it used to be. I have never been disappointed in my food and I would recommend Sgambatis as a place to try out.

I was really excited to find a NYC style Pizzeria in De Pere and all the rave reviews just pushed me in there tonight. However, I was very very very disappointed. Here’s why:
My Order —
3 Garlic knots
1 slice is each pizza below:
BBQ chicken
Mediterranean
Meat lovers
Opened the box when I got home. …all 3 slices were burnt and the crust hard hardened and burnt really dark brown… toppings were burnt. .no way I could fold that «NYC» style pizza.
Taste.. Nothing special. .prolly Cuz everything was burnt.
Garlic knots were much better. .relatively speaking.
Not excited anymore for having a NYC style pizzeria so close to my place.

Meal: I got the lasagna w/​garlic knots
Pro’s: The place is really cool and nice inside. really clean. The Garlic Knots that came with the lasagna were delicious. really good seasoning. the red sauce and cheese in the lasagna was very good. Great seasoning.
Con’s the beef they used in the lasagna were those frozen perfectly round flash frozen ground beef pellets. I hate to see a local place to this. Make a deal with a local butcher shop to get decent beef or Italian sausage to go with the great sauce and cheese. I also didn’t like the lack of a local tap selection. They only had two local brews out of 8 taps.

Sgambat’s is pretty close to the pizza you find in New York. The one thing missing is the charred crust from the coal fired pizza ovens in Brooklyn, but I’m not complainIng. Even better, they serve pizza by the slice, or by the whole pie, which is much larger than your standard pizza chains. I had the meat lovers and it was delicious. They also have a full bar which is great and the service and employees are very friendly. If you like New York pizza that you can fold, you’ve found your new pizza spot!