Tony’s Pizza

Ok, truth be told I stopped going to Tony’s, the pizza was terrible.
About six months ago a friend suggested we give them another try. So I did, the pizza was actually great. Crispy crust with great sauce.
Have been going there just about every Friday since; that little chubby guy knows how to make great pizza.
If you left Tony’s due to lousy pizza, I strongly suggest you give them another try.

PiZza has not been the same for a while i dont want to come here ever again i was sick for a week after one slice of pizza

While not a place for people who like Domino’s or Papa John’s, Tony’s hands down has the most authentic, best pizza around. Various friends who moved to other states (FL, CA, SC, TX, etc) talk about how much they miss Tony’s, and make it one of their first stops every visit. Figure Tony’s has been around for many, many years (decades!!!), in a neighborhood saturated with Italians — lousy Italian eateries don’t last long around here.

Not much to say. It’s a subpar pizza shop. Not the worst slice or best slice I’ve had. Def not a place I go out of my way for.

Tried to call today to order lunch for my office. no one answers the phone at 11:30 on a Friday morning?!?
and it’s not like I called once and didn’t try again… Sorry to say, they didn’t get my business today!
…you’ve been warned…

We order from Tony’s Pizza every Friday for probably the last 5 years. Was always reasonably happy with them but lately its just awful. 3 out of the last 4 orders something was missing and the food has been subpar. I don’t know whats going on there but we will be finding a new place for Friday Dinner. 03/​07/​2014 you forgot the calzone with meatball — drove back to get it and you dared charge me for it. It was burnt and disgusting. Never again

Would not recommend, had a chicken cutlet parm hero the bread was like mush and I don’t think it was chicken? Don’t know what it was the pizza was tasteless and cold a spinach calzone don’t even ask about that!

Just OK. I’ve tasted better but I’ve tasted worse too. We only ordered a regular pie. Maybe they have other selections on the menu that are worth talking about but based on just their pizza, they’re just a regular pizzeria. Nothing special.

Good pizza, but don’t order without coupons! If you don’t have one they have a stack at the counter.

Been eating Tonys for years, sometimes the sauce changes a bit however good quality, reasonable prices, a friendly, family place. It’s my go to place for take out Italian food in town.

I enjoy Tony’s pizzeria. It’s one of those old classic joints you would go to after a school activity or when you use to cut class and go to old joints like this place.
This place brings back old school memories.

If I had too sum up what pizza on Long Island taste like. I would choose this location.
Good solid slice. Awesome specials and its got that small business feel I love. Good cheese Good Crust below avg sauce.
Will Repeat soon.

This is our go-​to spot for Italian food in Deer Park. They have been in business for a very long time and it’s not hard to see why.
The pizza is pretty good — my dad sometimes goes elsewhere because of a special he found, but I remember their pizza being pretty tasty.
Yesterday as my birthday dinner I chose pasta. We ordered two of the spaghetti and meatballs dishes, and one baked ziti. The baked ziti was amazing and so cheesy. YUM. The spaghetti was great, but the sauce was just a liiiiittle bit too acidic for me. I didn’t eat the meatballs but my dad and brother seemed to really enjoy them as they were very tender from sitting in the sauce.
Lastly, I have to say that for the prices (which are so low!) you get a lot of food. Every place I’ve found in the city so far gives half of what Tony’s does, and charges more.
This places keeps our stomachs happy and I’m craving it again already. Next time I’m home…

Been doing pizza at Tony’s for years. Always great, tastes great always cooked to order. The last few weeks we, we’ve been knocking down some chicken parm heros and I have to say they were beyond great. Always went to la scala or Emilio’s in commack for chix parm but now Tony’s is my go to establishment, Guys keep up the good work you’ve really earned this customers loyalty.

Tonys is just a regular boring old fashioned looking pizza place. Cheap pizza no flavor. Not the best choice for those seeking the best tasting pie fine for the bland eater, or someone looking for a deal.

Good slice of pizza in Deer Park. Affordable lunch specials, tasty heroes.