Payne’s Pizza & More

This is the pizza my kids beg for so we get it when we want great pizza. My favorite is the Big Daddy; it’s so loaded with toppings and the best flavor! Great job guys!

Great pizza! Sauce isnt to tart. Real cheese and they arnt afraid to put on plenty of toppings! Absolutely the best Italian subs anywhere! Fast friendly delivery

Payne’s had always been sorted out for me on Unilocal as it is listed as $$$$. I happened to catch it on tonight’s search for fast pasta, and it was great (and very affordable)! I ordered spaghetti and breadsticks. The service was very friendly, and the food was ready quickly and it packaged together well for me to take home. Very tasty, but I personally will order with light sauce next time. Great for takeout, but the dining room definitely could use a makeover and the parking lot could use more lighting. In all, paid less than $ 10 and took home a whole lotta yummy food, which makes me happy.

Just got Payne’s pizza for the first time last night. It was delicious! it’s not like a lot of the new pizza that you see out today (fancy crust, crazy flavors — maybe they have that too) and less than impressive toppings.
We tried a classic large pepperoni pizza (we always try a pepperoni pizza when we go to a place for the first time.) This pizza has a more traditional taste — simple, yet delicious crust with light flavorful sauce (a mildly sweet taste), pepperoni that was flavorful but not overpowering or too spicy, and cheese that taste fresh from the farm. The cheese was the best part!
This place just became our new ‘go-​to’ pizza place. It doesn’t look pretty on the outside, but it’s what’s on the inside that counts! And what’s on the inside is some fantastic pizza.

Best and biggest subs in Delaware… try the Reuben ! Also, they have a good chicken Alfredo pizza. They have a buffet during lunch.

I really like their pizza and they are super quick on delivery. Take credit cards over the phone, kind of wish they had online ordering like the bigger chains.

Pizza buffets are usually not among my favorite places as thet give you cheap crust and toppings to make it cheaper to eat. Not Payne’s — $ 6 for lunch buffet with drink and the pizza is excellent on a basic thin crust.
Not my wife’s favorite so we don’t order it often but I do like the subs and homemade soups as well.

Got wings for the first time. When one orders wings, there are certain assumptions in place (unless the menu tackles them ahead of time): fried and sauced.
And I am an ass for assuming.
The wings are baked I think. Hard to tell actually. They are not sauced, nor does any sort of sauce accompany them. They are spiced though.
But how were they? Very good. Once I bent my mind around what they were, I enjoyed them. Got the «hot» version. Quotation marks because butter is spicier. Good thing I always have hot sauce on me.
Would I get them again? Maybe. If they came with sauce or were sauced? Definitely. Take a hint Payne’s.

Me and my guy were looking for a pizza place in Delaware and we stumbled across Payne’s. It’s fairly small, and the boyfriend said it had changed owners several times. There were alot of cars in the parking lot but only 2 diners inside. It seems that they may have alot of staff so they must be doing pretty good business. Anyhow, we order Annie’s pizza (I don’t remember the name) but it was great. Covered in several types of meat and it came out quickly. Both of us shared a medium pizza and had 2 drinks for under $ 20 bucks… I am satisfied.

Pizza is alright but would go to shortys over Payne.

This pizza has a sweeter taste to eat. They have killer subs.
My 3^rd favorite pizza joint in town.