Frosty’s Ice Cream

Delicious! The small is huge !
Not enough tables for customers.

A medium Arctic sweet rich and more than I needed!!!
Does anyone want to go dancing with me to wear off the calories?
Although their history is short, Frosty’s seems history because it is a reminder of «the classic American custard (soft ice cream) stand.»
I like Perry’s ice cream but it always seems weird to go to a drive in ice cream location and buy a couple scoops of an ice cream I can buy at the grocery store.
Service was fast and the options were many!
Not a bad meal finisher but now I need to dance!

Delicious ice cream. I think that’s all the review you need but I would also mention that there were plenty of options and the custard is especially good.
The ambiance was nice too, which is a weird thing to say about an ice cream stand which only boasts a few outdoor tables, but there were tons of families here and with everyone enjoying a nice warm evening, it really feels like a hometown kinda place.

It’s right across from my work — doesn’t get any better when I’m craving ice cream for lunch. Their custard is delicious!

Frontseat’s is an ice cream shop that lobbies every parent to let their kids sit in the front seat. Not always a good idea, but it is what it is.
Frosty’s on the other hand, is a second location of the very popular ice cream spot out on Broadway in Lancaster. It has similar limited summer hours, and is closed in winter, and is similarly a 4-​star.
The custard is nice and cheap, but it’s nothing special. It tastes good, but isn’t amazing. I’m a huge fan of custard, and some of the ones around here and especially in Rochester are miraculous. Frosty’s isn’t that. Also, at both locations, the employees completely messed up my order, but in both cases, gave me a fixed one and let me keep the messed up one. In this case it was a Coconut ice cream instead of vanilla custard. But honestly I didn’t love the coconut at all.

Frosty’s is an awesome little shop on the end of George Urban. Really reminds me of my childhood, passing by Dairy Queen for a small ice cream stand less than a mile up the road.
With a really… really extensive menu. Frosty’s gas everything you could ever crave in frozen form. Frozen Bananas, Hard Ice Cream, Slushies, Soft Serve, Cakes, Sundaes. And an extensive milkshake list that will not disappoint by any means. The Red Velvet Ice cream is my absolute favorite. And the salted caramel milkshake is also heavenly.
On a nice summers day it’s nice to come out and have a treat. Especially supporting a small local business that’s rocking out better product then anything around!

Great destination for an after-​dinner ice cream. They have a vast selection in Perry’s hard ice cream flavors, as well as, other options of soft serve, milkshakes, sundaes, etc. We even got our pup something off the menu: «Doggy delight», which was a small cup of vanilla ice cream with a couple of dog treats.
I ordered a «small» ice cream in a dish — it ended up coming out so large and piled high, I had to inquire about the large. They told me the large would be two scoops more! Mine was so big I kept it in my freezer and ate it over the course of 3 days!
For a «small» ice cream, a cookie blizzard-​milkshake thing (sorry, can’t recall the menu name), and a doggy delight it came to $ 9 something.
They have outdoor benches, tables, and umbrellas to enjoy your treat and rest at.
CASH ONLY!

Best place in WNY for Humongous Cones w/​inexpensive pricing! I take my kids here every other day, love this place, love the staff, recommend this hot spot or should i say cool spot to everyone :)

Have always stopped by Frosty’s for a custard cone. This time for the custard cake for a birthday. It was amazing! Didn’t even realize they had cakes but had time to read the menu while waiting in line and noticed it. No more DQ cakes for me!

Generous portions and almost too many delectable treats to choose from! A baby cone is the perfect sized treat!

I can drive by all but one ice cream shop and never miss it except when it comes to Frozen French Custard.
Frosty’s other location, in Lancaster, has been on my list of faves for a couple years now and, happily, they just opened another location!
Another place with another small driveway but… that means we have two to pick from and it is en route to so many places for me, Yay!
If you ask for a medium size cone, you better be hungry, for although they are not bashful with their pricing, they are generous with their servings.
As a frozen custard Connoisseur, I do suggest you do not order it in humid weather as it will always affect the dessert. Choose a soda or some
hard ice cream instead.
Frosty’s has many wonderful things to pick from with menus that cover the whole front of their shop.
This is an outdoor arrangement with a couple of picnic tables, there are no indoor facilities but well worth the stop.
They move fast, do not let the line frighten you, they are worth it!
See ya there!