The Candlelight Inn Bed & Breakfast

My husband and I stayed at the Candlelight Inn near Ithaca in June 2011. We only stayed one night. It was nice and included a delicious breakfast that gave more food than the two of us could finish, including baked goods, fruit, milk and coffee and tea and juice, and scrambled eggs with some veggies and cheese mixed in. We were asked in advance if we had any dietary restrictions, and there was no sense that special food requests would be any imposition. Rather, the owner seemed very concerned with making sure we had the best experience possible.
We had a two room suite, as it was the only room with a king size bed available. (My husband rolls around too much for us to share any bed smaller than a king.) The suite had a second bed in the other room of the suite, a comfy twin size I laid on while watching TV. The cost of the two room two bed suite was favorably comparable to a single room at a niceish hotel. The décor is… aggressively quaint, very kitschy, but unobjectionable. There was also free wifi, not super fast, but perfectly adequate for checking email and other light use. The wifi is unsecured, so you won’t want to do anything sensitive over it, like banking.
Couple fairly minor downsides-​no elevator, which isn’t a huge deal in a two story house, but I don’t think they had any first floor bedrooms, so I don’t think the location is handicapped accessible. Also, we weren’t told at check in that the pool was part of the property (we thought it might be a neighbor’s.) Had we known, we definitely would have made use of it.
Overall, this is definitely a good option if you’re staying in the Ithaca area!