Jersey Mike’s Subs

the food was good, bit ther swrvice is horrible. I went twice and both times our order was messed up. The first time they put the wrong number on our ticket so they walked around with our tray of food until it was cold and our entire order had to be remade. Then the second time our receipt clearly said ham sandwich with baked chips and roast beef with regular chips and they bring ham with regular chips and a turkey sandwich? not worth the money

Anytime I get the chance to eat at Jersey Mike’s I do. I fully intended to take a picture of my#43 Chipotle cheese steak sandwich but it was so good I couldn’t put it down! Best cheese steak sandwich around!

Really good, one of the better sandwich shops you’ll find in downtown East Peoria. Everything is cut right in front of you, and prepared how you want it. If getting a sub, be sure to get it «Mike’s Way». Also have really good cheesesteaks.
If you join their loyalty club you can earn points on each visit towards free food.

Go here for lunch pretty regularly and am a big fan of their cheese steaks. Service has always been friendly and prompt even when busy lunch hour. Prices are reasonable for what you get and am satisfied with the meal every time. Not a ton of parking off the road making you go behind the strip mall and walk around when busy during busy hours of the day. Overall a good option in the area for a good sandwich.

Horribly slow and unorganized. Next time if I’m going to have to spend this much time, I’ll just go to a good sit down restaurant instead and save time. n Food was ok, ordered a mushroom steak, was served soggy, overcooked, and poorly assembled.

Today was my first time at Jersey Mike’s and it won’t be my last. I ordered the Chipotle Cheesesteak and it was one of the best cheesesteak I have ever had. I ordered a regular sized and it was more the enough, and priced very reasonably for the size and quality. With the regular size that large I can’t even imagine how big the giant must be. With 3 different types of cheesesteaks and a variety of other cold and hot subs this place is a must for any sandwich lover.

As far as the food goes, my sandwich was absolutely delicious. One of the best sub’s I’ve had at a sub shop. Fresh meat, fresh ingredients– perfect. The staff was also very friendly and helpful as well.
The reason it doesn’t get the five stars it deserves was the interaction between the manager and one of the workers. A younger girl welcomed us and asked how she could help us only to be immediately sternly told by her manager working on something behind her that she needed to go do a different job instead. And it didn’t just stop there, she went on and on to her and a co-​worker, which created an awkward moment and we could tell the young girl felt embarrassed. There were no name tags being worn, but the manager had red hair and glasses. She was friendly to us a few minutes later after the episode, but how she handled her staff, especially in front of customers was inappropriate and from everything we saw, completely unnecessary and an abuse of power.
It’s unfortunate because the food was great. However, I have no plans to return to that particular store until that manager is removed.

Awesome food, great staff every time I have been here. Even when they are backed up the workers keep everyone happy. Try the chicken chipotle for a treat!

Tried Jersey Mikes for the first time. Nice selection of sandwiches and soup. Fast service and the food was great. They offer three sizes of subs. They really pile on the lettuce and other goodies. Plenty of meat too. I will definitely be back.

We visited Jersey Mikes for the first time, and found staff to be helpful and friendly. The service was good. They didn’t seem rushed, and even more so, listened and didn’t seem to want US to rush. The sandwiches were good, much better and more fresh than Subway. We will return!

We had to try out the new sub place and it’s really, really good! I had the hot philly cheesesteak sandwich and Kevin had the hot chipotle sandwich. Both were awesome, cooked fresh and quickly after we ordered. This is absolutely the best cheesesteak sandwich I have had in Peoria!
We will be back again soon.

I had never heard of this place before stopping in on a busy weekend. Their gimmick is that they fresh slice your meat choices right in front of you from a deli cooler at the front counter after you order your sandwich. There are a lot of choices that can be a salad, or sandwich on white or wheat. You can also have your sub toasted. I ordered a mini that was about 5 – 6 inches and it came out to be $ 6.24 so a little more expensive than Potbelly’s next door. Their bread has a really nice crust on it with a soft, fresh bite inside. I don’t especially care for bread so I took off the bottom bun and made it open-​faced. Their toppings were fresh and flavorful although were pretty skimpily added. Two small slices of a roma tomato doesn’t really cover 6 inches of sandwich.
I didn’t think there was anything too crazy special about the sandwich I ordered: California Club with turkey, bacon and avocado. Maybe it’s the Jersey toppings of vinegar and oil that really bring it up a notch? I’ll give them another try to find out.
One star definitely came off for too many people in the assembly line of workers. One slices the meat and lays it on the sandwich, one person adds toppings, one person wraps it in paper and writes a smily face on it, one person rings you up at the register. The person wrapping the sandwich is totally superfluous. Not to mention that he has on gloves and is touching the sandwich directly but is also picking up and using a Sharpie to write a number and smiley face on the wrapper after the cashier is also touching your money and the same Sharpie. That person needs to go do something else and leave the wrapping to the person doing the toppings and skip the dumb smiley face on the wrapper altogether. The thought of all those money germs getting on my fresh sandwich made my smile turn into a frown.