Mellow Mushroom

Friendly waitstaff, very good pizza, and reasonable prices. I’m not a fan of the sandwiches, just stick to the pizza. Quick seating even on weekends. One of the few restaurants around Lake Oconee that’s open on Sunday’s.

Normally I’m a big fan of MM. However this was a real disappointment that I can only say was due to three take out pizzas. When we got them home, the dough was not fully cooked. I have never had pizza with undercooked dough. You could not tell from looking at the top but you could when trying to eat it.
We were having a large party and did not discover until we had served everyone.
I would have thought the cook would notice or the person who cuts the pizza into slices.
Salads and wings were in contrast very good.

It’s a chain, but I always feel like they are all different. Haven’t had a bad meal at any of them.

This restaurant has horrible, horrible customer service. For anyone new to town looking to order food the process is long and the staff who I encountered were rude. Mellow mushroom is one of my favorites but customer service goes a long way. I’m not impressed.

We are from NJ so we are accustomed to NY style pizza. This pizza is average… seemed like Papa John’s to me. Our kids wouldn’t eat it. The wings were good. Atmosphere of the place nice. If you want authentic NY style pizza, head to Luigi’s.

Although a chain based specialty pizza shop, the craft of making pizza is one that must be mastered to perfection. It all starts with the dough, in this case it seems lile the dough its very tasty and well seasoned. If you can master the dough, the rest is simply creativity and concoctioning the perfect ingredients. Keeping the ingredients organic also makes a huge difference, we ordered the Holy Shiitake pie; this pie is a must have for any mushroom lover (cremini, portabella and button mushrooms) and as if that was not enough we added crumbled sausage on top.
I enjoyed every bite of it, right down to the last bite. Oh did I mentioned the pizza was drizzled with a bit of truffle oil? All i was missing was a fine bottle of Rioja at table side to call it a 5 star Bruch on a lazy Sunday afternoon.
If my doctor allowed me, i would eat here at least twice a week.
We also ordered the tie dye. it was good as it chicken, tomatoes, basil, currry and thai chili sauce.
Had a large order of chicken wings. that were delicious.
They deliver consistent quality in every pizza pie that comes out that oven. I been eating at The mellow mushrooms for a few years anytime we are in Georgia and their pizza rocks!

Usually pretty decent… but today was the worst service by far. Waitress was very rude and snappy. Food was hot. Salad was cold but there was also hair in it. After the rude service I won’t be going back.

Delicious wings and reasonable. Meaty, juicy, and large. Didn’t care for their blue cheese but their house Italian for their feel salad was one of the best. Service has been a problem in the past, not tonight. Perfect spring Eve to sit on their patio.

What I love about this place is the different unique pizzas. This can be a fun place for a group 6 or less (due to the limited large tables).
The service can be sometimes slow depending on how many to go orders they have going. They are pricy for the pizza IMO.
I would give it a go if Pizza is your thing for tonight.

Already gave a bad review on this but had to had another. Last time they were out of wings and served meatballs that were barely warm. Today — no wings, no meatballs and no soda. Incredible. Will not be back in a while. The owner needs to have a really long chat with the manager. You can’t sell what you don’t have.

the staff is very friendly but the food itself here leaves something to be desired — considering the price. Small spinach salad was sooo expensive and it didnt have the apples that were promised!!! Five dollars extra to substitute chicken for tofu on a medium pie?! kind of outrageous :-(

Staff was friendly. Food was subpar to other Mellow Mushrooms. Also ordered an appetizer and two pies for our table. Brought out one of the pies first? Then the appetizer and second pizza? Waitress was nice and said «I don’t know what happened» when she brought put the first pizza but I mean if you screw up start over and get it right. No?

This Mellow Mushroom is just a short drive from Lake Oconee, which is nice after a long day on the lake. The service can be hit or miss sometimes, but the food is always good.

Disappointing food, off-​tasting draft beers. Today’s visit was a dining experience well worth forgetting.

Last two times I was here, it took us forever to get seated. They seated the people behind us before we got a table before we did and there were only four of us. The third time we didn’t even get seated. After 5 minutes we left. Not going back

I’ve never had any complaints with this location. Food has always been of good quality, draft beer selection is up to par, and service is friendly.
The only drawback is that the patio is sparsely decorated and its proximity to the street makes it hard to carry on a conversation.

Great food, great vibe. Running off of a hippy vibe, this restaurant has managed to remain in Eatonton for a fairly long time, which is quite rare considering the seasonal clientele to the region. Their pizza is great and has nice combos, but their sides are good but not great. The pretzels were pretty interesting, although not the best I’ve ever had.

What a great place! When you step in the door here you will be immediately transported back to the hippie days. We had the Hippy Dippy Trio (appetizer) and the Philosopher’s Pie (pizza). It was great food. :)